From 86a4e60cd934fc8c626a2e1ce3ff841b5db56084 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: murraylovecode Date: Sat, 15 Aug 2026 08:11:11 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] Add governed agent identity statement coding batch --- .../ambiguous-attribution-queue.json | 6 + .../BATCH-2026-006/attribution-review.csv | 47 + .../book-statement-mappings.json | 6 + .../BATCH-2026-006/double-review-sample.json | 101 + .../BATCH-2026-006/duplicate-statements.json | 58 + staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/limitations.md | 15 + .../batches/BATCH-2026-006/locator-review.csv | 47 + staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml | 104 + .../person-statement-mappings.json | 855 +++++ .../proposition-link-candidates.json | 656 ++++ .../BATCH-2026-006/source-eligibility.json | 119 + .../source-statement-mappings.json | 124 + .../BATCH-2026-006/statement-decisions.json | 456 +++ .../batches/BATCH-2026-006/statements.json | 2862 +++++++++++++++++ .../BATCH-2026-006/validation-results.md | 20 + 15 files changed, 5476 insertions(+) create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/ambiguous-attribution-queue.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/attribution-review.csv create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/book-statement-mappings.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/double-review-sample.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/duplicate-statements.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/limitations.md create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/locator-review.csv create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/person-statement-mappings.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/proposition-link-candidates.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/source-eligibility.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/source-statement-mappings.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/statement-decisions.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/statements.json create mode 100644 staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/validation-results.md diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/ambiguous-attribution-queue.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/ambiguous-attribution-queue.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c9ccd65 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/ambiguous-attribution-queue.json @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +{ + "items": [], + "count": 0, + "note": "No ambiguous speaker passage was converted into a statement. Joint-author works use collective attribution; individual affiliations not stated in a source remain explicitly unknown.", + "human_review_status": "pending" +} diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/attribution-review.csv b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/attribution-review.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..09af6f6 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/attribution-review.csv @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +statement_id,source_id,attributed_author,speaker_role_at_source_time,organization_at_source_time,current_role_separately,speaker_confidence,source_context,ambiguity_status,human_review_status +statement-BATCH-2026-006-001,source-BATCH-2026-005-001,NIST Center for AI Standards and Innovation,authors of the NIST RFI response synthesis,National Institute of Standards and Technology,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-002,source-BATCH-2026-005-001,NIST Center for AI Standards and Innovation,authors of the NIST RFI response synthesis,National Institute of Standards and Technology,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-003,source-BATCH-2026-005-001,NIST Center for AI Standards and Innovation,authors of the NIST RFI response synthesis,National Institute of Standards and Technology,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-004,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,National Institute of Standards and Technology,institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile,National Institute of Standards and Technology,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-005,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,National Institute of Standards and Technology,institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile,National Institute of Standards and Technology,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-006,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,National Institute of Standards and Technology,institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile,National Institute of Standards and Technology,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-007,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,National Institute of Standards and Technology,institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile,National Institute of Standards and Technology,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-008,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,National Institute of Standards and Technology,institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile,National Institute of Standards and Technology,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-009,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors),joint authors of revision 02,Internet Engineering Task Force,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-010,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors),joint authors of revision 02,Internet Engineering Task Force,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-011,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors),joint authors of revision 02,Internet Engineering Task Force,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-012,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors),joint authors of revision 02,Internet Engineering Task Force,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-013,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors),joint authors of revision 02,Internet Engineering Task Force,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-014,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors),joint authors of revision 02,Internet Engineering Task Force,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-015,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,South et al. (joint report authors),joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report,OpenID Foundation,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-016,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,South et al. (joint report authors),joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report,OpenID Foundation,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-017,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,South et al. (joint report authors),joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report,OpenID Foundation,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-018,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,South et al. (joint report authors),joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report,OpenID Foundation,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-019,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,South et al. (joint report authors),joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report,OpenID Foundation,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-020,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,South et al. (joint report authors),joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report,OpenID Foundation,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-021,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,South et al. (joint report authors),joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report,OpenID Foundation,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-022,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the AgentDojo paper,ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-023,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the AgentDojo paper,ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-024,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the AgentDojo paper,ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-025,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the AgentDojo paper,ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-026,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the AgentDojo paper,ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-027,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the AgentDojo paper,ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-028,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,Zhang et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the ASB paper,Zhejiang University and Rutgers University,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-029,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,Zhang et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the ASB paper,Zhejiang University and Rutgers University,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-030,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,Zhang et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the ASB paper,Zhejiang University and Rutgers University,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-031,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,Zhang et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the ASB paper,Zhejiang University and Rutgers University,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-032,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,Zhang et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the ASB paper,Zhejiang University and Rutgers University,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-033,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,Zhu et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the HPTSA paper,University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-034,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,Zhu et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the HPTSA paper,University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-035,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,Zhu et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the HPTSA paper,University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-036,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,Zhu et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the HPTSA paper,University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-037,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,Zhu et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the HPTSA paper,University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-038,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,Zhu et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the HPTSA paper,University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign,not researched; no current role substituted,high,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-039,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,Shavit et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper,OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper),not researched; no current role substituted,medium,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-040,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,Shavit et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper,OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper),not researched; no current role substituted,medium,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-041,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,Shavit et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper,OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper),not researched; no current role substituted,medium,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-042,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,Shavit et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper,OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper),not researched; no current role substituted,medium,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-043,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,Shavit et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper,OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper),not researched; no current role substituted,medium,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-044,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,Shavit et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper,OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper),not researched; no current role substituted,medium,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-045,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,Shavit et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper,OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper),not researched; no current role substituted,medium,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-046,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,Shavit et al. (joint paper authors),joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper,OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper),not researched; no current role substituted,medium,joint-authored source; collective attribution used,none identified,pending diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/book-statement-mappings.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/book-statement-mappings.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..da91cd2 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/book-statement-mappings.json @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +{ + "mappings": [], + "validation_status": "not_applicable", + "reason": "No verified source in this batch is a book or book edition, and the repository contains no canonical book-edition record on this branch.", + "human_review_status": "pending" +} diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/double-review-sample.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/double-review-sample.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bd60d02 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/double-review-sample.json @@ -0,0 +1,101 @@ +{ + "sampling_method": "Deterministic risk-stratified sample: at least 20% of high-impact statements and at least 10% of other statements.", + "population": { + "total": 46, + "high_impact": 16, + "normal": 30, + "disputed_or_reputational_or_change_claims": 0 + }, + "sample_counts": { + "total": 10, + "high_impact": 6, + "normal": 4 + }, + "sampling_rates": { + "high_impact": 0.375, + "normal": 0.1333 + }, + "items": [ + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001", + "risk_class": "normal", + "selection_reason": "Routine quality-control sample.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "risk_class": "normal", + "selection_reason": "Routine quality-control sample.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-010", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "risk_class": "high_impact", + "selection_reason": "Governance, security, accountability, or empirical claim with material decision impact.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "risk_class": "high_impact", + "selection_reason": "Governance, security, accountability, or empirical claim with material decision impact.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-023", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "risk_class": "normal", + "selection_reason": "Routine quality-control sample.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-025", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "risk_class": "high_impact", + "selection_reason": "Governance, security, accountability, or empirical claim with material decision impact.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-029", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "risk_class": "high_impact", + "selection_reason": "Governance, security, accountability, or empirical claim with material decision impact.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-031", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "risk_class": "normal", + "selection_reason": "Routine quality-control sample.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-034", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "risk_class": "high_impact", + "selection_reason": "Governance, security, accountability, or empirical claim with material decision impact.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-041", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "risk_class": "high_impact", + "selection_reason": "Governance, security, accountability, or empirical claim with material decision impact.", + "second_review_status": "pending_independent_human_or_agent_review", + "human_review_status": "pending" + } + ], + "note": "The extraction agent did not mark any independent review as complete. This file selects the required review sample without implying human approval." +} diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/duplicate-statements.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/duplicate-statements.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ba7bcab --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/duplicate-statements.json @@ -0,0 +1,58 @@ +{ + "exact_duplicate_statement_ids": [], + "near_duplicate_statement_pairs": [], + "held_rendition_candidates": [ + { + "candidate_id": "held-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "neutral_paraphrase": "A subagent should receive a narrowed subset of its parent agent's authority.", + "decision": "held", + "reason_code": "duplicate_rendition", + "overlaps_statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "decision_note": "Same intellectual work as the official OpenID rendition; retained only for rendition provenance.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "held-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Delegated authorization should identify the user and the agent separately.", + "decision": "held", + "reason_code": "duplicate_rendition", + "overlaps_statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "decision_note": "Same intellectual work as the official OpenID rendition; retained only for rendition provenance.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "held-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Audit trails should preserve both principal and agent identity.", + "decision": "held", + "reason_code": "duplicate_rendition", + "overlaps_statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "decision_note": "Same intellectual work as the official OpenID rendition; retained only for rendition provenance.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "held-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Agent lifecycle management should cover provisioning and de-provisioning.", + "decision": "held", + "reason_code": "duplicate_rendition", + "overlaps_statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-019", + "decision_note": "Same intellectual work as the official OpenID rendition; retained only for rendition provenance.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + } + ], + "source_work_overlap": [ + { + "source_ids": [ + "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "source-BATCH-2026-005-005" + ], + "relationship": "same_intellectual_work_different_renditions", + "canonical_coding_source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "decision": "Do not create parallel statement records from the arXiv rendition; preserve its held candidates for provenance and human review." + } + ], + "human_review_status": "pending" +} diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/limitations.md b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/limitations.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fc0819d --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/limitations.md @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +# Limitations — BATCH-2026-006 + +This staging batch codes nine verified source records representing eight intellectual works. The OpenID Foundation report and arXiv:2510.25819v1 are substantially the same work; the official OpenID rendition supplies the created statements, while four arXiv candidates are held as rendition duplicates. + +All statements are machine drafted and pending named human review. Joint-authored works use collective attribution because assigning a jointly expressed paper claim to a single lead author would overstate individual authorship. The OpenAI paper does not state individual affiliations; OpenAI is recorded as publisher context, not inferred as every author's employer. + +The NIST RFI synthesis is limited to its public abstract. It does not disclose a response count, respondent composition, coding method, or quantitative threshold for statements about broad agreement. Its observations describe self-selected respondents, not a representative population. + +NIST AI 600-1, the IETF Internet-Draft, the OpenID report, and the OpenAI paper are normative or conceptual sources. Their recommendations must not be treated as measured outcomes. The IETF item is revision 02 of an expiring work in progress and is not an RFC. + +AgentDojo, ASB, and HPTSA use synthetic or purposively selected security cases. Their reported percentages are source-reported benchmark results, not independently replicated here and not estimates of production incident prevalence. Model, API, prompt, and benchmark versions limit transferability. Several aggregate statistics lack raw numerators or confidence intervals. + +No selected source is a book or time-based media item, so book-edition and duration validations are not applicable. No canonical person, book-edition, statement, or proposition records exist on this branch; mappings remain staging-only. Proposed proposition links do not create or approve propositions. + +No direct quotations are retained. Paraphrases were screened for copied multiword sequences, but unavoidable technical names and standard identifiers remain. Production eligibility still requires independent review, named human attribution review, and the repository's configured publication gates. diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/locator-review.csv b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/locator-review.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000..acd8ef5 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/locator-review.csv @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +statement_id,source_id,exact_locator,locator_type,source_version,locator_reproduced,visual_pdf_check,duration_check,book_edition_check,report_version_check,unresolved_locator,human_review_status +statement-BATCH-2026-006-001,source-BATCH-2026-005-001,"Official HTML publication page, Abstract, sentences 1-4, accessed 2026-08-15",html_section,official HTML publication page accessed 2026-08-15,pass,not applicable; HTML section checked,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-002,source-BATCH-2026-005-001,"Official HTML publication page, Abstract, sentence 5, accessed 2026-08-15",html_section,official HTML publication page accessed 2026-08-15,pass,not applicable; HTML section checked,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-003,source-BATCH-2026-005-001,"Official HTML publication page, Abstract, final sentence, accessed 2026-08-15",html_section,official HTML publication page accessed 2026-08-15,pass,not applicable; HTML section checked,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-004,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,"PDF file p. 5 (document p. 1), Section 1 ""Introduction"", July 2024 version",pdf_page,"NIST AI 600-1, July 2024 PDF; SHA-256 inherited from BATCH-2026-005",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-005,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,"PDF file p. 18 (document p. 14), GOVERN 1.2, Action GV-1.2-001, July 2024 version",pdf_page,"NIST AI 600-1, July 2024 PDF; SHA-256 inherited from BATCH-2026-005",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-006,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,"PDF file p. 18 (document p. 14), GOVERN 1.2, Action GV-1.2-002, July 2024 version",pdf_page,"NIST AI 600-1, July 2024 PDF; SHA-256 inherited from BATCH-2026-005",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-007,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,"PDF file p. 53 (document p. 49), Appendix A.1.4 ""Limitations of Current Pre-deployment Test Approaches"", July 2024 version",pdf_page,"NIST AI 600-1, July 2024 PDF; SHA-256 inherited from BATCH-2026-005",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-008,source-BATCH-2026-005-002,"PDF file p. 53 (document p. 49), Appendix A.1.5 ""Structured Public Feedback"", July 2024 version",pdf_page,"NIST AI 600-1, July 2024 PDF; SHA-256 inherited from BATCH-2026-005",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-009,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,"Revision 02 HTML, Section 3 ""Agents are workloads"", paragraphs 1-3",html_section,draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02; expires 2026-12-03,pass,not applicable; HTML section checked,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-010,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,"Revision 02 HTML, Section 5 ""Agent Identifier"", normative paragraph",html_section,draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02; expires 2026-12-03,pass,not applicable; HTML section checked,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-011,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,"Revision 02 HTML, Section 6 ""Agent Credentials"", paragraphs 1-3",html_section,draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02; expires 2026-12-03,pass,not applicable; HTML section checked,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-012,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,"Revision 02 HTML, Section 4 ""Agent Identity Management System"", Figure 2 and component definitions",html_section,draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02; expires 2026-12-03,pass,not applicable; HTML section checked,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-013,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,"Revision 02 HTML, Section 3 ""Agents are workloads"", paragraph after Figure 1",html_section,draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02; expires 2026-12-03,pass,not applicable; HTML section checked,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-014,source-BATCH-2026-005-003,"Revision 02 HTML, Section 13 ""Security Considerations"", opening paragraph",html_section,draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02; expires 2026-12-03,pass,not applicable; HTML section checked,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-015,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,"PDF file p. 3 (document p. 2), Executive Summary, ""User impersonation by agents"", October 2025 version",pdf_page,"OpenID Foundation official PDF, October 2025",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-016,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,"PDF file p. 19 (document p. 18), Section 3.2 ""From Impersonation to Delegation (On-Behalf-Of)"", October 2025 version",pdf_page,"OpenID Foundation official PDF, October 2025",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-017,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,"PDF file p. 17 (document p. 16), ""Best Practices"", October 2025 version",pdf_page,"OpenID Foundation official PDF, October 2025",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-018,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,"PDF file p. 15 (document p. 14), end of Section 2.11, October 2025 version",pdf_page,"OpenID Foundation official PDF, October 2025",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-019,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,"PDF file p. 17 (document p. 16), ""Best Practices"", bullet ""Automate agent lifecycle management"", October 2025 version",pdf_page,"OpenID Foundation official PDF, October 2025",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-020,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,"PDF file p. 27 (document p. 26), Section 4.4 ""Recursive Delegation in Dynamic Agent Networks"", October 2025 version",pdf_page,"OpenID Foundation official PDF, October 2025",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-021,source-BATCH-2026-005-004,"PDF file p. 21 (document p. 20), Section 3.4 ""Scalable Human Governance and Consent"", opening paragraph, October 2025 version",pdf_page,"OpenID Foundation official PDF, October 2025",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-022,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,"arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 6, Section 3.4 ""Reporting AgentDojo Results""",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.13352v3; NeurIPS 2024 version,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-023,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,"arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF pp. 1 and 6, Abstract and Table 1",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.13352v3; NeurIPS 2024 version,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-024,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,"arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 20, Table 3, ""Benign utility"" column",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.13352v3; NeurIPS 2024 version,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-025,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,"arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 20, Table 5, ""Targeted ASR"" row",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.13352v3; NeurIPS 2024 version,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-026,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,"arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 9, Figure 9b and caption",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.13352v3; NeurIPS 2024 version,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-027,source-BATCH-2026-005-006,"arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 22, Appendix E.1-E.3",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.13352v3; NeurIPS 2024 version,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-028,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,"arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF pp. 1-2 and p. 8, Abstract, Introduction, and Table 3",pdf_page,arXiv:2410.02644v4; ICLR 2025 paper,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-029,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,"arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF p. 9, Table 5, ""Average"" row and Section 5.3",pdf_page,arXiv:2410.02644v4; ICLR 2025 paper,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-030,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,"arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF pp. 1-2, Abstract, Figure 1, and Introduction",pdf_page,arXiv:2410.02644v4; ICLR 2025 paper,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-031,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,"arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF p. 8, Table 4, NRP row",pdf_page,arXiv:2410.02644v4; ICLR 2025 paper,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-032,source-BATCH-2026-005-007,"arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF p. 9, Section 5.3, discussion following Figure 2",pdf_page,arXiv:2410.02644v4; ICLR 2025 paper,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-033,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,"arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF p. 4, Section 4 and Tables 1-2",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.01637v2,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-034,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,"arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF p. 5, Figure 2 and Section 5.2",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.01637v2,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-035,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,"arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF pp. 1 and 5, Abstract and Figures 2-3",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.01637v2,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-036,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,"arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF p. 6, Section 5.3 and Figure 4",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.01637v2,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-037,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,"arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF pp. 1 and 5, Abstract and Section 5.2",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.01637v2,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-038,source-BATCH-2026-005-008,"arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF pp. 8-9, Section 10 ""Limitations, Ethical Considerations""",pdf_page,arXiv:2406.01637v2,pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-039,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,"Official PDF p. 4, Section 2.1 ""Agenticness, Agentic AI Systems, and Agents"", 2023 version",pdf_page,"official OpenAI PDF, 2023; metadata created 2023-12-18",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-040,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,"Official PDF pp. 5-6, Section 2.2 ""The Human Parties in the AI Agent Life-cycle"", 2023 version",pdf_page,"official OpenAI PDF, 2023; metadata created 2023-12-18",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-041,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,"Official PDF p. 3, Section 1 ""Introduction"", 2023 version",pdf_page,"official OpenAI PDF, 2023; metadata created 2023-12-18",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-042,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,"Official PDF pp. 8-9, Section 4.1 ""Evaluating Suitability for the Task"", 2023 version",pdf_page,"official OpenAI PDF, 2023; metadata created 2023-12-18",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-043,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,"Official PDF pp. 9-10, Section 4.2 ""Constraining the Action-Space and Requiring Approval"", 2023 version",pdf_page,"official OpenAI PDF, 2023; metadata created 2023-12-18",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-044,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,"Official PDF pp. 12-13, Section 4.5 ""Automatic Monitoring"", 2023 version",pdf_page,"official OpenAI PDF, 2023; metadata created 2023-12-18",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-045,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,"Official PDF pp. 13-14, Section 4.6 ""Attributability"", 2023 version",pdf_page,"official OpenAI PDF, 2023; metadata created 2023-12-18",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending +statement-BATCH-2026-006-046,source-BATCH-2026-005-009,"Official PDF pp. 14-15, Section 4.7 ""Interruptibility and Maintaining Control"", 2023 version",pdf_page,"official OpenAI PDF, 2023; metadata created 2023-12-18",pass,pass; exact page rendered or visually inspected in source review,not applicable,not applicable,pass,no,pending diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4cde057 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml @@ -0,0 +1,104 @@ +batch_id: BATCH-2026-006 +prompt_id: OEII-STATEMENT-CODING +prompt_version: "2.0" +topic: Governed identities for AI agents +topic_slug: governed-agent-identities +branch: research/statements-governed-agent-identities-BATCH-2026-006 +pull_request: pending_draft_pr_creation +base_branch: research/evidence-governed-agent-identities-BATCH-2026-005 +execution_date: 2026-08-15 +execution_completed_at: 2026-08-15T15:06:11Z +agent_or_researcher: OpenAI Codex; machine-assisted statement coding; named human review pending +model_disclosure: AI-assisted eligibility review, close reading, neutral paraphrase drafting, attribution coding, locator checking, duplicate screening, and proposition-link suggestion; no human or publication approval occurred. +source_ids: + - source-BATCH-2026-005-001 + - source-BATCH-2026-005-002 + - source-BATCH-2026-005-003 + - source-BATCH-2026-005-004 + - source-BATCH-2026-005-005 + - source-BATCH-2026-005-006 + - source-BATCH-2026-005-007 + - source-BATCH-2026-005-008 + - source-BATCH-2026-005-009 +sources_coded: 9 +sources_with_created_statements: 8 +duplicate_rendition_only_sources: 1 +statements_created: 46 +statements_held: 4 +ambiguous_attributions: 0 +disputed_claims: 0 +double_review_items_selected: 10 +unresolved_locators: 0 +required_report_counts: + factual_statements: 0 + empirical_findings: 8 + recommendations: 16 + predictions: 0 + company_reported_outcomes: 0 +statement_type_counts: + factual_assertion: 0 + empirical_finding: 8 + recommendation: 16 + prediction: 0 + opinion: 0 + warning: 3 + definition: 4 + reported_experience: 0 + case_study: 0 + strategic_framework: 3 + interpretation: 3 + counterargument: 0 + methodological_claim: 7 + company_reported_outcome: 0 + policy_position: 2 +required_review_status: human_review_pending +workflow_status: statements_extracted +machine_review_status: machine_checked +human_review_status: pending +output_files: + - statements.json + - source-eligibility.json + - source-statement-mappings.json + - person-statement-mappings.json + - book-statement-mappings.json + - ambiguous-attribution-queue.json + - manifest.yml + - statement-decisions.json + - attribution-review.csv + - locator-review.csv + - duplicate-statements.json + - double-review-sample.json + - proposition-link-candidates.json + - limitations.md + - validation-results.md +validation_required: + - source eligibility + - statement schema + - locator reproducibility + - historical attribution and role separation + - exact and near-duplicate detection + - copied-language detection + - duration checks + - book-edition checks + - report-version checks + - factual-verification status + - provenance completeness + - staging leak isolation +validation_commands: + - node work/statement-coding-2026-006/validate_batch.mjs + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate data + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate provenance + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate attributions + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate statements + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate propositions + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate book-editions + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate source-locators + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate rights + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate review-status + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate publication + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts validate content + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts audit duplicates + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts audit concentration + - node --import tsx scripts/cli.ts audit coverage + - npm test -- --run + - git diff --check diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/person-statement-mappings.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/person-statement-mappings.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a4e006f --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/person-statement-mappings.json @@ -0,0 +1,855 @@ +[ + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jared-riggs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-maia-hamin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-neil-perry", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-benjamin-edelman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-peter-cihon" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jared-riggs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-maia-hamin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-neil-perry", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-benjamin-edelman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-peter-cihon" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jared-riggs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-maia-hamin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-neil-perry", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-benjamin-edelman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-peter-cihon" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "person_ids": [], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "institutional_author_only", + "note": "No individual author IDs are present in the verified source record.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "person_ids": [], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "institutional_author_only", + "note": "No individual author IDs are present in the verified source record.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "person_ids": [], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "institutional_author_only", + "note": "No individual author IDs are present in the verified source record.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "person_ids": [], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "institutional_author_only", + "note": "No individual author IDs are present in the verified source record.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "person_ids": [], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "institutional_author_only", + "note": "No individual author IDs are present in the verified source record.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pieter-kasselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yaron-rosomakho", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-brian-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-nick-steele", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aaron-parecki" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-010", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pieter-kasselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yaron-rosomakho", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-brian-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-nick-steele", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aaron-parecki" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-011", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pieter-kasselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yaron-rosomakho", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-brian-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-nick-steele", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aaron-parecki" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-012", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pieter-kasselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yaron-rosomakho", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-brian-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-nick-steele", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aaron-parecki" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-013", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pieter-kasselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yaron-rosomakho", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-brian-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-nick-steele", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aaron-parecki" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-014", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pieter-kasselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yaron-rosomakho", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-brian-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-nick-steele", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aaron-parecki" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-015", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tobin-south", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-subramanya-nagabhushanaradhya", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ayesha-dissanayaka", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sarah-cecchetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-george-fletcher", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-victor-lu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aldo-pietropaolo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dean-h-saxe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-abhishek-shivalingaiah", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-stan-bounev", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-keisner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andor-kesselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zack-proser", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ginny-fahs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andrew-bunyea", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ben-moskowitz", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-atul-tulshibagwale", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dazza-greenwood", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jiaxin-pei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-pentland" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tobin-south", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-subramanya-nagabhushanaradhya", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ayesha-dissanayaka", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sarah-cecchetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-george-fletcher", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-victor-lu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aldo-pietropaolo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dean-h-saxe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-abhishek-shivalingaiah", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-stan-bounev", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-keisner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andor-kesselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zack-proser", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ginny-fahs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andrew-bunyea", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ben-moskowitz", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-atul-tulshibagwale", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dazza-greenwood", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jiaxin-pei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-pentland" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-017", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tobin-south", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-subramanya-nagabhushanaradhya", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ayesha-dissanayaka", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sarah-cecchetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-george-fletcher", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-victor-lu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aldo-pietropaolo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dean-h-saxe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-abhishek-shivalingaiah", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-stan-bounev", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-keisner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andor-kesselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zack-proser", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ginny-fahs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andrew-bunyea", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ben-moskowitz", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-atul-tulshibagwale", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dazza-greenwood", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jiaxin-pei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-pentland" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tobin-south", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-subramanya-nagabhushanaradhya", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ayesha-dissanayaka", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sarah-cecchetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-george-fletcher", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-victor-lu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aldo-pietropaolo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dean-h-saxe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-abhishek-shivalingaiah", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-stan-bounev", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-keisner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andor-kesselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zack-proser", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ginny-fahs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andrew-bunyea", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ben-moskowitz", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-atul-tulshibagwale", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dazza-greenwood", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jiaxin-pei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-pentland" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-019", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tobin-south", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-subramanya-nagabhushanaradhya", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ayesha-dissanayaka", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sarah-cecchetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-george-fletcher", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-victor-lu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aldo-pietropaolo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dean-h-saxe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-abhishek-shivalingaiah", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-stan-bounev", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-keisner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andor-kesselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zack-proser", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ginny-fahs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andrew-bunyea", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ben-moskowitz", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-atul-tulshibagwale", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dazza-greenwood", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jiaxin-pei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-pentland" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tobin-south", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-subramanya-nagabhushanaradhya", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ayesha-dissanayaka", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sarah-cecchetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-george-fletcher", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-victor-lu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aldo-pietropaolo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dean-h-saxe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-abhishek-shivalingaiah", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-stan-bounev", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-keisner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andor-kesselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zack-proser", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ginny-fahs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andrew-bunyea", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ben-moskowitz", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-atul-tulshibagwale", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dazza-greenwood", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jiaxin-pei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-pentland" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-021", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tobin-south", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-subramanya-nagabhushanaradhya", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ayesha-dissanayaka", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sarah-cecchetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-george-fletcher", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-victor-lu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-aldo-pietropaolo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dean-h-saxe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jeff-lombardo", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-abhishek-shivalingaiah", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-stan-bounev", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-keisner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andor-kesselman", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zack-proser", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ginny-fahs", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-andrew-bunyea", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-ben-moskowitz", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-atul-tulshibagwale", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-dazza-greenwood", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jiaxin-pei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-pentland" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-022", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-edoardo-debenedetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jie-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-mislav-balunovic", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-luca-beurer-kellner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-marc-fischer", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-florian-tramer" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-023", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-edoardo-debenedetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jie-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-mislav-balunovic", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-luca-beurer-kellner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-marc-fischer", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-florian-tramer" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-024", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-edoardo-debenedetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jie-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-mislav-balunovic", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-luca-beurer-kellner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-marc-fischer", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-florian-tramer" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-025", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-edoardo-debenedetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jie-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-mislav-balunovic", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-luca-beurer-kellner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-marc-fischer", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-florian-tramer" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-026", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-edoardo-debenedetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jie-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-mislav-balunovic", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-luca-beurer-kellner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-marc-fischer", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-florian-tramer" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-027", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-edoardo-debenedetti", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jie-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-mislav-balunovic", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-luca-beurer-kellner", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-marc-fischer", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-florian-tramer" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-028", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hanrong-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jingyuan-huang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-kai-mei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yifei-yao", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zhenting-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-chenlu-zhan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hongwei-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yongfeng-zhang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-029", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hanrong-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jingyuan-huang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-kai-mei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yifei-yao", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zhenting-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-chenlu-zhan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hongwei-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yongfeng-zhang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-030", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hanrong-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jingyuan-huang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-kai-mei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yifei-yao", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zhenting-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-chenlu-zhan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hongwei-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yongfeng-zhang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-031", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hanrong-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jingyuan-huang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-kai-mei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yifei-yao", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zhenting-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-chenlu-zhan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hongwei-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yongfeng-zhang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-032", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hanrong-zhang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-jingyuan-huang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-kai-mei", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yifei-yao", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-zhenting-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-chenlu-zhan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-hongwei-wang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yongfeng-zhang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-033", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yuxuan-zhu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-antony-kellermann", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-akul-gupta", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-philip-li", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-richard-fang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rohan-bindu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-daniel-kang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-034", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yuxuan-zhu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-antony-kellermann", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-akul-gupta", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-philip-li", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-richard-fang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rohan-bindu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-daniel-kang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-035", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yuxuan-zhu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-antony-kellermann", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-akul-gupta", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-philip-li", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-richard-fang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rohan-bindu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-daniel-kang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-036", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yuxuan-zhu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-antony-kellermann", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-akul-gupta", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-philip-li", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-richard-fang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rohan-bindu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-daniel-kang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-037", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yuxuan-zhu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-antony-kellermann", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-akul-gupta", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-philip-li", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-richard-fang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rohan-bindu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-daniel-kang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-038", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yuxuan-zhu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-antony-kellermann", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-akul-gupta", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-philip-li", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-richard-fang", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rohan-bindu", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-daniel-kang" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-039", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yonadav-shavit", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sandhini-agarwal", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-miles-brundage", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-steven-adler", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-cullen-o-keefe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rosie-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-teddy-lee", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pamela-mishkin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tyna-eloundou", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alan-hickey", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-katarina-slama", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-lama-ahmad", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-paul-mcmillan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-beutel", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alexandre-passos", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-david-g-robinson" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-040", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yonadav-shavit", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sandhini-agarwal", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-miles-brundage", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-steven-adler", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-cullen-o-keefe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rosie-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-teddy-lee", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pamela-mishkin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tyna-eloundou", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alan-hickey", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-katarina-slama", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-lama-ahmad", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-paul-mcmillan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-beutel", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alexandre-passos", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-david-g-robinson" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-041", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yonadav-shavit", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sandhini-agarwal", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-miles-brundage", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-steven-adler", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-cullen-o-keefe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rosie-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-teddy-lee", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pamela-mishkin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tyna-eloundou", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alan-hickey", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-katarina-slama", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-lama-ahmad", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-paul-mcmillan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-beutel", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alexandre-passos", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-david-g-robinson" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-042", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yonadav-shavit", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sandhini-agarwal", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-miles-brundage", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-steven-adler", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-cullen-o-keefe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rosie-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-teddy-lee", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pamela-mishkin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tyna-eloundou", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alan-hickey", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-katarina-slama", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-lama-ahmad", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-paul-mcmillan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-beutel", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alexandre-passos", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-david-g-robinson" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-043", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yonadav-shavit", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sandhini-agarwal", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-miles-brundage", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-steven-adler", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-cullen-o-keefe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rosie-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-teddy-lee", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pamela-mishkin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tyna-eloundou", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alan-hickey", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-katarina-slama", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-lama-ahmad", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-paul-mcmillan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-beutel", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alexandre-passos", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-david-g-robinson" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-044", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yonadav-shavit", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sandhini-agarwal", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-miles-brundage", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-steven-adler", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-cullen-o-keefe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rosie-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-teddy-lee", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pamela-mishkin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tyna-eloundou", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alan-hickey", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-katarina-slama", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-lama-ahmad", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-paul-mcmillan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-beutel", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alexandre-passos", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-david-g-robinson" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-045", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yonadav-shavit", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sandhini-agarwal", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-miles-brundage", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-steven-adler", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-cullen-o-keefe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rosie-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-teddy-lee", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pamela-mishkin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tyna-eloundou", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alan-hickey", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-katarina-slama", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-lama-ahmad", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-paul-mcmillan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-beutel", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alexandre-passos", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-david-g-robinson" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-046", + "person_ids": [ + "person-BATCH-2026-005-yonadav-shavit", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-sandhini-agarwal", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-miles-brundage", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-steven-adler", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-cullen-o-keefe", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-rosie-campbell", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-teddy-lee", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-pamela-mishkin", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-tyna-eloundou", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alan-hickey", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-katarina-slama", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-lama-ahmad", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-paul-mcmillan", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alex-beutel", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-alexandre-passos", + "person-BATCH-2026-005-david-g-robinson" + ], + "relationship": "joint_author", + "attribution_mode": "joint_source_byline", + "note": "Every listed person is mapped as a joint author; the statement record uses a collective author label to avoid assigning a joint claim to one person.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + } +] diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/proposition-link-candidates.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/proposition-link-candidates.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..4304232 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/proposition-link-candidates.json @@ -0,0 +1,656 @@ +{ + "candidates": [ + { + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "neutral_text": "Agents should have stable identities distinct from the principals they represent.", + "status": "candidate_only_not_a_canonical_proposition", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "neutral_text": "Delegated authority should preserve both principal and agent context.", + "status": "candidate_only_not_a_canonical_proposition", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "neutral_text": "Agent permissions should be bounded by least privilege and attenuated across delegation.", + "status": "candidate_only_not_a_canonical_proposition", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "neutral_text": "Agent identity governance should include provisioning, rotation, revocation, and de-provisioning.", + "status": "candidate_only_not_a_canonical_proposition", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "neutral_text": "Auditability depends on traceable identity and authorization context.", + "status": "candidate_only_not_a_canonical_proposition", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "neutral_text": "Agent systems need layered evaluation, authorization controls, and monitoring.", + "status": "candidate_only_not_a_canonical_proposition", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "neutral_text": "Users and deployers need reliable mechanisms to interrupt agents and their subagents.", + "status": "candidate_only_not_a_canonical_proposition", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "neutral_text": "Synthetic security benchmarks demonstrate capabilities but do not estimate production prevalence.", + "status": "candidate_only_not_a_canonical_proposition", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "neutral_text": "Multi-agent coordination can increase cybersecurity capability and associated governance risk.", + "status": "candidate_only_not_a_canonical_proposition", + "human_review_status": "pending" + } + ], + "links": [ + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-010", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-011", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-011", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-011", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-012", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-012", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-012", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-013", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-013", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-014", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-015", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-017", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-017", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-017", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-019", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-019", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-021", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-021", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-022", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-022", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-023", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-023", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-024", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-024", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-025", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-025", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-026", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-026", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-027", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-028", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-028", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-029", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-029", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-030", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-031", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-031", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-032", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-032", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-033", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-034", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-034", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-035", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-035", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-036", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-036", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "relationship": "provides_evidence", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-037", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-038", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-039", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-040", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-040", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-041", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-041", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-041", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-042", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-043", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-043", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-043", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-044", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-044", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-045", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-045", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-045", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-046", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-046", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-046", + "proposition_candidate_id": "proposition-candidate-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "relationship": "supports", + "status": "proposed_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + } + ], + "note": "These are proposed links to neutral candidate ideas. No canonical proposition or stance record is created by this batch." +} diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/source-eligibility.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/source-eligibility.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..cec6872 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/source-eligibility.json @@ -0,0 +1,119 @@ +[ + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001", + "canonical_title": "Summary Analysis of Responses to the Request for Information Regarding Security Considerations for AI Agents", + "metadata_verified": true, + "source_access_confirmed": true, + "rights_status": "link_and_paraphrase", + "rights_reviewed": true, + "canonical_source_id_present": true, + "author_linkage_present": true, + "coding_disposition": "eligible_and_coded", + "eligibility_result": "pass", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "canonical_title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile", + "metadata_verified": true, + "source_access_confirmed": true, + "rights_status": "link_and_paraphrase", + "rights_reviewed": true, + "canonical_source_id_present": true, + "author_linkage_present": true, + "coding_disposition": "eligible_and_coded", + "eligibility_result": "pass", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "canonical_title": "AI Agent Authentication and Authorization", + "metadata_verified": true, + "source_access_confirmed": true, + "rights_status": "link_and_paraphrase", + "rights_reviewed": true, + "canonical_source_id_present": true, + "author_linkage_present": true, + "coding_disposition": "eligible_and_coded", + "eligibility_result": "pass", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "canonical_title": "Identity Management for Agentic AI", + "metadata_verified": true, + "source_access_confirmed": true, + "rights_status": "link_and_paraphrase", + "rights_reviewed": true, + "canonical_source_id_present": true, + "author_linkage_present": true, + "coding_disposition": "eligible_and_coded", + "eligibility_result": "pass", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "canonical_title": "Identity Management for Agentic AI: The new frontier of authorization, authentication, and security for an AI agent world", + "metadata_verified": true, + "source_access_confirmed": true, + "rights_status": "link_and_paraphrase", + "rights_reviewed": true, + "canonical_source_id_present": true, + "author_linkage_present": true, + "coding_disposition": "eligible_duplicate_rendition_candidates_held", + "eligibility_result": "pass", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "canonical_title": "AgentDojo: A Dynamic Environment to Evaluate Prompt Injection Attacks and Defenses for LLM Agents", + "metadata_verified": true, + "source_access_confirmed": true, + "rights_status": "link_and_paraphrase", + "rights_reviewed": true, + "canonical_source_id_present": true, + "author_linkage_present": true, + "coding_disposition": "eligible_and_coded", + "eligibility_result": "pass", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "canonical_title": "Agent Security Bench (ASB): Formalizing and Benchmarking Attacks and Defenses in LLM-based Agents", + "metadata_verified": true, + "source_access_confirmed": true, + "rights_status": "link_and_paraphrase", + "rights_reviewed": true, + "canonical_source_id_present": true, + "author_linkage_present": true, + "coding_disposition": "eligible_and_coded", + "eligibility_result": "pass", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "canonical_title": "Teams of LLM Agents can Exploit Zero-Day Vulnerabilities", + "metadata_verified": true, + "source_access_confirmed": true, + "rights_status": "link_and_paraphrase", + "rights_reviewed": true, + "canonical_source_id_present": true, + "author_linkage_present": true, + "coding_disposition": "eligible_and_coded", + "eligibility_result": "pass", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "canonical_title": "Practices for Governing Agentic AI Systems", + "metadata_verified": true, + "source_access_confirmed": true, + "rights_status": "link_and_paraphrase", + "rights_reviewed": true, + "canonical_source_id_present": true, + "author_linkage_present": true, + "coding_disposition": "eligible_and_coded", + "eligibility_result": "pass", + "human_review_status": "pending" + } +] diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/source-statement-mappings.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/source-statement-mappings.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..408f9cd --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/source-statement-mappings.json @@ -0,0 +1,124 @@ +[ + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001", + "statement_ids": [ + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-003" + ], + "held_candidate_ids": [], + "mapping_status": "coded", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "statement_ids": [ + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-008" + ], + "held_candidate_ids": [], + "mapping_status": "coded", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "statement_ids": [ + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-010", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-011", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-012", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-013", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-014" + ], + "held_candidate_ids": [], + "mapping_status": "coded", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "statement_ids": [ + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-015", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-017", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-019", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-021" + ], + "held_candidate_ids": [], + "mapping_status": "coded", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "statement_ids": [], + "held_candidate_ids": [ + "held-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "held-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "held-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "held-BATCH-2026-006-004" + ], + "mapping_status": "duplicate_rendition_only", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "statement_ids": [ + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-022", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-023", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-024", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-025", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-026", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-027" + ], + "held_candidate_ids": [], + "mapping_status": "coded", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "statement_ids": [ + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-028", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-029", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-030", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-031", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-032" + ], + "held_candidate_ids": [], + "mapping_status": "coded", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "statement_ids": [ + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-033", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-034", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-035", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-036", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-037", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-038" + ], + "held_candidate_ids": [], + "mapping_status": "coded", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "statement_ids": [ + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-039", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-040", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-041", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-042", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-043", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-044", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-045", + "statement-BATCH-2026-006-046" + ], + "held_candidate_ids": [], + "mapping_status": "coded", + "human_review_status": "pending" + } +] diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/statement-decisions.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/statement-decisions.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c924970 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/statement-decisions.json @@ -0,0 +1,456 @@ +[ + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-010", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-010", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-011", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-011", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-012", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-012", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-013", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-013", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-014", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-014", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-015", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-015", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-017", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-017", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-019", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-019", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-021", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-021", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-022", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-022", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-023", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-023", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-024", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-024", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-025", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-025", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-026", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-026", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-027", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-027", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-028", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-028", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-029", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-029", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-030", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-030", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-031", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-031", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-032", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-032", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-033", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-033", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-034", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-034", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-035", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-035", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-036", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-036", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-037", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-037", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-038", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-038", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-039", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-039", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-040", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-040", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-041", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-041", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-042", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-042", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-043", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-043", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-044", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-044", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-045", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-045", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "candidate-statement-BATCH-2026-006-046", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "decision": "accepted", + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-046", + "reason_code": "substantive_single_idea_with_reproducible_locator", + "decision_note": "Eligible source, neutral paraphrase, single canonical type, historical attribution context, and reproducible locator.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "held-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "neutral_paraphrase": "A subagent should receive a narrowed subset of its parent agent's authority.", + "decision": "held", + "reason_code": "duplicate_rendition", + "overlaps_statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "decision_note": "Same intellectual work as the official OpenID rendition; retained only for rendition provenance.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "held-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Delegated authorization should identify the user and the agent separately.", + "decision": "held", + "reason_code": "duplicate_rendition", + "overlaps_statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "decision_note": "Same intellectual work as the official OpenID rendition; retained only for rendition provenance.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "held-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Audit trails should preserve both principal and agent identity.", + "decision": "held", + "reason_code": "duplicate_rendition", + "overlaps_statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "decision_note": "Same intellectual work as the official OpenID rendition; retained only for rendition provenance.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + }, + { + "candidate_id": "held-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-005", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Agent lifecycle management should cover provisioning and de-provisioning.", + "decision": "held", + "reason_code": "duplicate_rendition", + "overlaps_statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-019", + "decision_note": "Same intellectual work as the official OpenID rendition; retained only for rendition provenance.", + "human_review_status": "pending" + } +] diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/statements.json b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/statements.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000..443fee7 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/statements.json @@ -0,0 +1,2862 @@ +[ + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-001", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "NIST Center for AI Standards and Innovation", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "authors of the NIST RFI response synthesis", + "organization_at_source_time": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "statement_type": "empirical_finding", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The NIST synthesis says respondents broadly regarded agent security concerns as both novel and an obstacle to adoption.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official HTML publication page, Abstract, sentences 1-4, accessed 2026-08-15", + "locator_type": "html_section", + "source_date": "2026-05-18", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "United States", + "global issues discussed" + ], + "evidence_character": "secondary_summary", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "Self-selected respondents to the CAISI request for information.", + "uncertainty": "The accessible page gives neither a respondent count nor the threshold used for broad agreement.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.95, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/summary-analysis-responses-request-information-regarding-security-considerations-ai", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official HTML publication page, Abstract, sentences 1-4, accessed 2026-08-15", + "content_hash": "32c07aeeb8f49694dd407080eab757c905dc4395871b52edd46a113208064a03", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-001; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-002", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "NIST Center for AI Standards and Innovation", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "authors of the NIST RFI response synthesis", + "organization_at_source_time": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "statement_type": "interpretation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The authors conclude that established cybersecurity practice remains useful for agents but needs modification for agent-specific risks.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official HTML publication page, Abstract, sentence 5, accessed 2026-08-15", + "locator_type": "html_section", + "source_date": "2026-05-18", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "United States", + "global issues discussed" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "The NIST authors' synthesis of the RFI response corpus.", + "uncertainty": "The public page does not disclose the underlying coding method or quantify support.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.95, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/summary-analysis-responses-request-information-regarding-security-considerations-ai", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official HTML publication page, Abstract, sentence 5, accessed 2026-08-15", + "content_hash": "32c07aeeb8f49694dd407080eab757c905dc4395871b52edd46a113208064a03", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-001; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-003", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-001", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "NIST Center for AI Standards and Innovation", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "authors of the NIST RFI response synthesis", + "organization_at_source_time": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "statement_type": "policy_position", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The synthesis presents government guidance, information exchange, and standards promotion as possible public-sector responses.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official HTML publication page, Abstract, final sentence, accessed 2026-08-15", + "locator_type": "html_section", + "source_date": "2026-05-18", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "United States", + "global issues discussed" + ], + "evidence_character": "secondary_summary", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "Options identified in the RFI response corpus and summarized by NIST.", + "uncertainty": "The accessible page does not report how many respondents supported each option.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.95, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/summary-analysis-responses-request-information-regarding-security-considerations-ai", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official HTML publication page, Abstract, final sentence, accessed 2026-08-15", + "content_hash": "32c07aeeb8f49694dd407080eab757c905dc4395871b52edd46a113208064a03", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-001; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-004", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile", + "organization_at_source_time": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "statement_type": "definition", + "neutral_paraphrase": "NIST frames this publication as a voluntary, cross-sector companion to the AI Risk Management Framework for generative-AI risk decisions.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 5 (document p. 1), Section 1 \"Introduction\", July 2024 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "United States", + "cross-sectoral global applicability" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Organizations designing, developing, deploying, or using generative AI across sectors.", + "uncertainty": "This is a profile description, not evidence that use of the profile improves outcomes.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.600-1.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 5 (document p. 1), Section 1 \"Introduction\", July 2024 version", + "content_hash": "6e73620ab6b64e90ef2c04bf0e0d6246185a2f4b1b13cab0df494496cff89b6a", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-002; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-005", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile", + "organization_at_source_time": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Organizations should document where training and generated data came from and how those data evolved, while accounting for proprietary constraints.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 18 (document p. 14), GOVERN 1.2, Action GV-1.2-001, July 2024 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "United States", + "cross-sectoral global applicability" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Voluntary cross-sector generative-AI risk management.", + "uncertainty": "NIST does not evaluate the effectiveness of this action in the profile.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.600-1.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 18 (document p. 14), GOVERN 1.2, Action GV-1.2-001, July 2024 version", + "content_hash": "6e73620ab6b64e90ef2c04bf0e0d6246185a2f4b1b13cab0df494496cff89b6a", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-002; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-006", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile", + "organization_at_source_time": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Organizations should assess risk-relevant generative-AI capabilities and the robustness of safeguards before deployment and repeatedly afterward.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 18 (document p. 14), GOVERN 1.2, Action GV-1.2-002, July 2024 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "United States", + "cross-sectoral global applicability" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Internal and external evaluation of generative-AI systems.", + "uncertainty": "The profile supplies guidance rather than comparative outcome evidence.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.600-1.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 18 (document p. 14), GOVERN 1.2, Action GV-1.2-002, July 2024 version", + "content_hash": "6e73620ab6b64e90ef2c04bf0e0d6246185a2f4b1b13cab0df494496cff89b6a", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-002; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-007", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile", + "organization_at_source_time": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "statement_type": "methodological_claim", + "neutral_paraphrase": "NIST cautions that laboratory tests and benchmark datasets may not transfer to heterogeneous real deployment conditions or measure broader impacts.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 53 (document p. 49), Appendix A.1.4 \"Limitations of Current Pre-deployment Test Approaches\", July 2024 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "United States", + "cross-sectoral global applicability" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "Pre-deployment testing and evaluation of generative-AI systems.", + "uncertainty": "The document does not quantify the size of any generalization gap.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.600-1.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 53 (document p. 49), Appendix A.1.4 \"Limitations of Current Pre-deployment Test Approaches\", July 2024 version", + "content_hash": "6e73620ab6b64e90ef2c04bf0e0d6246185a2f4b1b13cab0df494496cff89b6a", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-002; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-008", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-002", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "institutional author of the NIST AI RMF profile", + "organization_at_source_time": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Organizations can use structured public feedback to test whether a system behaves as intended and to inform lifecycle decisions.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 53 (document p. 49), Appendix A.1.5 \"Structured Public Feedback\", July 2024 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "United States", + "cross-sectoral global applicability" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Participatory engagement, field testing, and red-teaming for generative-AI systems.", + "uncertainty": "The profile describes possible uses and does not estimate effectiveness.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ai/NIST.AI.600-1.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 53 (document p. 49), Appendix A.1.5 \"Structured Public Feedback\", July 2024 version", + "content_hash": "6e73620ab6b64e90ef2c04bf0e0d6246185a2f4b1b13cab0df494496cff89b6a", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-002; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-009", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of revision 02", + "organization_at_source_time": "Internet Engineering Task Force", + "statement_type": "definition", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Revision 02 treats an AI agent as a workload that must authenticate to the tools, services, models, and other systems with which it interacts.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 3 \"Agents are workloads\", paragraphs 1-3", + "locator_type": "html_section", + "source_date": "2026-06-01", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "The conceptual model in an expiring Internet-Draft.", + "uncertainty": "The draft is a work in progress and may change before any RFC publication.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.95, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02.html", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 3 \"Agents are workloads\", paragraphs 1-3", + "content_hash": "e34f335c56546a6d91d88d43159c9f80d4dcfbbad020d41c31607fc56848befa", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-003; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-010", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of revision 02", + "organization_at_source_time": "Internet Engineering Task Force", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The draft requires each participating agent to receive one WIMSE identifier.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 5 \"Agent Identifier\", normative paragraph", + "locator_type": "html_section", + "source_date": "2026-06-01", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Agents participating in the proposed authentication and authorization framework.", + "uncertainty": "Revision 02 is not an RFC and has no reported interoperability testing.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.95, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02.html", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 5 \"Agent Identifier\", normative paragraph", + "content_hash": "e34f335c56546a6d91d88d43159c9f80d4dcfbbad020d41c31607fc56848befa", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-003; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-011", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of revision 02", + "organization_at_source_time": "Internet Engineering Task Force", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Agent credentials should expire quickly, must state an expiration time, and must be cryptographically tied to the agent identifier.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 6 \"Agent Credentials\", paragraphs 1-3", + "locator_type": "html_section", + "source_date": "2026-06-01", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Primary runtime credentials in the proposed framework.", + "uncertainty": "The normative language belongs to an expiring draft, not an adopted standard.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.95, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02.html", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 6 \"Agent Credentials\", paragraphs 1-3", + "content_hash": "e34f335c56546a6d91d88d43159c9f80d4dcfbbad020d41c31607fc56848befa", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-003; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-012", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of revision 02", + "organization_at_source_time": "Internet Engineering Task Force", + "statement_type": "strategic_framework", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The proposed Agent Identity Management System separates identity, credential provisioning, authentication, authorization, policy, lifecycle events, and observability into a common control model.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 4 \"Agent Identity Management System\", Figure 2 and component definitions", + "locator_type": "html_section", + "source_date": "2026-06-01", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Logical architecture proposed for agent authentication and authorization.", + "uncertainty": "No deployment or interoperability results are reported.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.95, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02.html", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 4 \"Agent Identity Management System\", Figure 2 and component definitions", + "content_hash": "e34f335c56546a6d91d88d43159c9f80d4dcfbbad020d41c31607fc56848befa", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-003; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-013", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of revision 02", + "organization_at_source_time": "Internet Engineering Task Force", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Authorization and audit records should retain the human or system delegation context when an agent acts for another principal.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 3 \"Agents are workloads\", paragraph after Figure 1", + "locator_type": "html_section", + "source_date": "2026-06-01", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Agents acting on behalf of users or systems.", + "uncertainty": "This is proposed behavior in revision 02.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.95, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02.html", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 3 \"Agents are workloads\", paragraph after Figure 1", + "content_hash": "e34f335c56546a6d91d88d43159c9f80d4dcfbbad020d41c31607fc56848befa", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-003; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-014", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-003", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Kasselman et al. (joint Internet-Draft authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of revision 02", + "organization_at_source_time": "Internet Engineering Task Force", + "statement_type": "interpretation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The draft assembles existing identity and authorization specifications into an agent framework instead of claiming a wholly new protocol family.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 13 \"Security Considerations\", opening paragraph", + "locator_type": "html_section", + "source_date": "2026-06-01", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "The specification strategy of draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02.", + "uncertainty": "The combined framework remains untested in the source.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.95, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-klrc-aiagent-auth-02.html", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Revision 02 HTML, Section 13 \"Security Considerations\", opening paragraph", + "content_hash": "e34f335c56546a6d91d88d43159c9f80d4dcfbbad020d41c31607fc56848befa", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-003; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-015", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "South et al. (joint report authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenID Foundation", + "statement_type": "warning", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The report warns that agents which appear identical to users leave investigators unable to separate delegated action from direct user action.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 3 (document p. 2), Executive Summary, \"User impersonation by agents\", October 2025 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global technology standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "Identity and accountability in agent access to external services.", + "uncertainty": "Conceptual risk analysis; no incidence rate is reported.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://openid.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Identity-Management-for-Agentic-AI.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 3 (document p. 2), Executive Summary, \"User impersonation by agents\", October 2025 version", + "content_hash": "e6a0e5909fcb2486568180f69d511ae2af8d20a1bfb3028b39b3d1072846f4f3", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-004; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-016", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "South et al. (joint report authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenID Foundation", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "An on-behalf-of authorization flow should carry distinct identities for the delegating user and acting agent.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 19 (document p. 18), Section 3.2 \"From Impersonation to Delegation (On-Behalf-Of)\", October 2025 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global technology standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Delegated authorization for agent access.", + "uncertainty": "The report does not compare implementation outcomes.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://openid.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Identity-Management-for-Agentic-AI.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 19 (document p. 18), Section 3.2 \"From Impersonation to Delegation (On-Behalf-Of)\", October 2025 version", + "content_hash": "e6a0e5909fcb2486568180f69d511ae2af8d20a1bfb3028b39b3d1072846f4f3", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-004; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-017", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "South et al. (joint report authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenID Foundation", + "statement_type": "strategic_framework", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The report organizes agent identity practice around open protocols, authenticated interactions, least privilege, automated lifecycle controls, audit trails, and interoperability.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 17 (document p. 16), \"Best Practices\", October 2025 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global technology standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Enterprise identity programs for AI agents.", + "uncertainty": "The list is normative and its components are not ranked by measured effectiveness.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://openid.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Identity-Management-for-Agentic-AI.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 17 (document p. 16), \"Best Practices\", October 2025 version", + "content_hash": "e6a0e5909fcb2486568180f69d511ae2af8d20a1bfb3028b39b3d1072846f4f3", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-004; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-018", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "South et al. (joint report authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenID Foundation", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Audit records should identify both the authorizing human principal and the particular agent instance that executed an action.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 15 (document p. 14), end of Section 2.11, October 2025 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global technology standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Delegated actions in systems using a policy enforcement point.", + "uncertainty": "Implementation performance is not evaluated.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://openid.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Identity-Management-for-Agentic-AI.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 15 (document p. 14), end of Section 2.11, October 2025 version", + "content_hash": "e6a0e5909fcb2486568180f69d511ae2af8d20a1bfb3028b39b3d1072846f4f3", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-004; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-019", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "South et al. (joint report authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenID Foundation", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Agent identities need formal creation, permission changes, ownership transfer, de-provisioning, and off-boarding across systems.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 17 (document p. 16), \"Best Practices\", bullet \"Automate agent lifecycle management\", October 2025 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global technology standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Enterprise lifecycle management for non-human agent identities.", + "uncertainty": "The report proposes extending established lifecycle patterns; it does not test a SCIM implementation.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://openid.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Identity-Management-for-Agentic-AI.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 17 (document p. 16), \"Best Practices\", bullet \"Automate agent lifecycle management\", October 2025 version", + "content_hash": "e6a0e5909fcb2486568180f69d511ae2af8d20a1bfb3028b39b3d1072846f4f3", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-004; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-020", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "South et al. (joint report authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenID Foundation", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Each handoff in a multi-agent delegation chain should reduce the permissions passed to the next agent.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 27 (document p. 26), Section 4.4 \"Recursive Delegation in Dynamic Agent Networks\", October 2025 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global technology standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Prospective multi-agent networks that delegate authority through several hops.", + "uncertainty": "The architecture is forward-looking and its operational maturity is not established.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://openid.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Identity-Management-for-Agentic-AI.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 27 (document p. 26), Section 4.4 \"Recursive Delegation in Dynamic Agent Networks\", October 2025 version", + "content_hash": "e6a0e5909fcb2486568180f69d511ae2af8d20a1bfb3028b39b3d1072846f4f3", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-004; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-021", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-004", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "South et al. (joint report authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the OpenID Foundation report", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenID Foundation", + "statement_type": "warning", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Requiring approval for every agent action can produce consent fatigue and habitual approval, weakening meaningful human oversight.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 21 (document p. 20), Section 3.4 \"Scalable Human Governance and Consent\", opening paragraph, October 2025 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global technology standards context" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "High-volume agent actions that trigger user authorization prompts.", + "uncertainty": "The report supplies no empirical measure of the effect.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://openid.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/Identity-Management-for-Agentic-AI.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "PDF file p. 21 (document p. 20), Section 3.4 \"Scalable Human Governance and Consent\", opening paragraph, October 2025 version", + "content_hash": "e6a0e5909fcb2486568180f69d511ae2af8d20a1bfb3028b39b3d1072846f4f3", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-004; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-022", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the AgentDojo paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs", + "statement_type": "definition", + "neutral_paraphrase": "AgentDojo distinguishes benign task completion, utility preserved during attack, and successful execution of an attacker goal as separate evaluation measures.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 6, Section 3.4 \"Reporting AgentDojo Results\"", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-19", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic environments; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "Metric definitions for version 3 of the AgentDojo benchmark.", + "uncertainty": "Metric definitions do not establish external validity.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13352", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 6, Section 3.4 \"Reporting AgentDojo Results\"", + "content_hash": "349884fffbf43282591c5accffd57bb651632f38e412fe303114941bdd111b05", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-006; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-023", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the AgentDojo paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs", + "statement_type": "methodological_claim", + "neutral_paraphrase": "AgentDojo version 3 contains four simulated environments, 70 tools, 97 user tasks, 27 injection targets, and 629 security cases.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF pp. 1 and 6, Abstract and Table 1", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-19", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic environments; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "Version 3 benchmark composition.", + "uncertainty": "The cases are curated simulations rather than a probability sample of deployed agents.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13352", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF pp. 1 and 6, Abstract and Table 1", + "content_hash": "349884fffbf43282591c5accffd57bb651632f38e412fe303114941bdd111b05", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-006; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-024", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the AgentDojo paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs", + "statement_type": "empirical_finding", + "neutral_paraphrase": "In the reported no-defense runs, several evaluated models failed to complete at least one third of benign tasks.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 20, Table 3, \"Benign utility\" column", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-19", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic environments; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "The ten model configurations reported in Table 3.", + "uncertainty": "Model and API versions are time-bound; the benchmark is synthetic.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13352", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 20, Table 3, \"Benign utility\" column", + "content_hash": "349884fffbf43282591c5accffd57bb651632f38e412fe303114941bdd111b05", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-006; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-025", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the AgentDojo paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs", + "statement_type": "empirical_finding", + "neutral_paraphrase": "For GPT-4o, Table 5 reports targeted attack success of 57.69% without a defense and 6.84% with tool filtering.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 20, Table 5, \"Targeted ASR\" row", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-19", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic environments; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "GPT-4o on AgentDojo v3 security cases under the listed defense configurations.", + "uncertainty": "The table gives confidence-interval half-widths but not raw numerators or the interval construction method; the rates are not production prevalence.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13352", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 20, Table 5, \"Targeted ASR\" row", + "content_hash": "349884fffbf43282591c5accffd57bb651632f38e412fe303114941bdd111b05", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-006; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-026", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the AgentDojo paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs", + "statement_type": "empirical_finding", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Across the plotted defense configurations, utility during attack was roughly 15 to 20 percentage points below benign utility.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 9, Figure 9b and caption", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-19", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic environments; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "Defense configurations shown on the AgentDojo v3 utility plot.", + "uncertainty": "The figure summarizes synthetic cases and should not be generalized to production systems.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13352", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 9, Figure 9b and caption", + "content_hash": "349884fffbf43282591c5accffd57bb651632f38e412fe303114941bdd111b05", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-006; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-027", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-006", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Debenedetti et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the AgentDojo paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "ETH Zurich and Invariant Labs", + "statement_type": "methodological_claim", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The authors report releasing benchmark code, run outputs, conversations, figure notebooks, documentation, and exact dependency information.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 22, Appendix E.1-E.3", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-19", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic environments; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "Reproducibility materials described for AgentDojo version 3.", + "uncertainty": "Availability of linked artifacts can change after the access date.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13352", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.13352v3 PDF p. 22, Appendix E.1-E.3", + "content_hash": "349884fffbf43282591c5accffd57bb651632f38e412fe303114941bdd111b05", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-006; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-028", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhang et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the ASB paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "Zhejiang University and Rutgers University", + "statement_type": "methodological_claim", + "neutral_paraphrase": "ASB covers 10 scenarios and agents, 50 agent tasks, more than 400 tools, 400 attack tasks, 13 attack methods, 11 defenses, and seven metrics.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF pp. 1-2 and p. 8, Abstract, Introduction, and Table 3", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-10-03", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic benchmark; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "ASB version 4 benchmark composition.", + "uncertainty": "The researcher-built benchmark does not represent a sampled production population.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.02644", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF pp. 1-2 and p. 8, Abstract, Introduction, and Table 3", + "content_hash": "e20155df01b3a1f6c0a947c4e9e4871957cff2e507939f7ea21a5fe967d84504", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-007; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-029", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhang et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the ASB paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "Zhejiang University and Rutgers University", + "statement_type": "empirical_finding", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Across the evaluated backbones, mixed attacks had the highest reported mean attack-success rate, 84.30%.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF p. 9, Table 5, \"Average\" row and Section 5.3", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-10-03", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic benchmark; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "The attack families and 13 LLM backbones in ASB version 4.", + "uncertainty": "The paper does not provide a raw numerator or confidence interval for the aggregate.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.02644", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF p. 9, Table 5, \"Average\" row and Section 5.3", + "content_hash": "e20155df01b3a1f6c0a947c4e9e4871957cff2e507939f7ea21a5fe967d84504", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-007; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-030", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhang et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the ASB paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "Zhejiang University and Rutgers University", + "statement_type": "interpretation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The authors identify attack surfaces in system prompts, user inputs, tool interactions, and long-term memory retrieval.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF pp. 1-2, Abstract, Figure 1, and Introduction", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-10-03", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic benchmark; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "The operational stages modeled by ASB.", + "uncertainty": "The taxonomy reflects the benchmark design and may not exhaust real-world attack surfaces.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.02644", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF pp. 1-2, Abstract, Figure 1, and Introduction", + "content_hash": "e20155df01b3a1f6c0a947c4e9e4871957cff2e507939f7ea21a5fe967d84504", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-007; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-031", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhang et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the ASB paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "Zhejiang University and Rutgers University", + "statement_type": "methodological_claim", + "neutral_paraphrase": "ASB defines net resilient performance as clean-task performance multiplied by one minus attack success rate.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF p. 8, Table 4, NRP row", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-10-03", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic benchmark; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "The benchmark's combined utility-and-security metric.", + "uncertainty": "A composite metric can conceal the two underlying dimensions and should be read with them.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.02644", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF p. 8, Table 4, NRP row", + "content_hash": "e20155df01b3a1f6c0a947c4e9e4871957cff2e507939f7ea21a5fe967d84504", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-007; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-032", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-007", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhang et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the ASB paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "Zhejiang University and Rutgers University", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The paper recommends choosing agent backbones using both task utility and adversarial resistance rather than capability rankings alone.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF p. 9, Section 5.3, discussion following Figure 2", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-10-03", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic benchmark; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Model selection for agents represented by the ASB scenarios.", + "uncertainty": "The recommendation depends on the benchmark's synthetic scope and chosen metric.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.02644", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2410.02644v4 PDF p. 9, Section 5.3, discussion following Figure 2", + "content_hash": "e20155df01b3a1f6c0a947c4e9e4871957cff2e507939f7ea21a5fe967d84504", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-007; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-033", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhu et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the HPTSA paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign", + "statement_type": "methodological_claim", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The HPTSA evaluation uses 14 reproducible open-source web vulnerabilities published after the tested GPT-4 knowledge cutoff.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF p. 4, Section 4 and Tables 1-2", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-02", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic sandbox; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "A purposive set of sandboxed web vulnerabilities.", + "uncertainty": "The sample is small, non-random, and limited to reproducible open-source web software.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01637", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF p. 4, Section 4 and Tables 1-2", + "content_hash": "f4fc06040f0856d99d2009042b4c6fa0c01206da8ca61cb39a94d52b9867cf71", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-008; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-034", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhu et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the HPTSA paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign", + "statement_type": "empirical_finding", + "neutral_paraphrase": "On the 14-vulnerability benchmark, GPT-4-backed HPTSA reports 42% pass-at-five and 18% pass-at-one.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF p. 5, Figure 2 and Section 5.2", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-02", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic sandbox; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "The described HPTSA configuration in sandboxed experiments.", + "uncertainty": "The reported percentages are rounded, and the paper gives no confidence intervals.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01637", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF p. 5, Figure 2 and Section 5.2", + "content_hash": "f4fc06040f0856d99d2009042b4c6fa0c01206da8ca61cb39a94d52b9867cf71", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-008; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-035", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhu et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the HPTSA paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign", + "statement_type": "empirical_finding", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The two evaluated open-source backbones and the ZAP and Metasploit scanner baseline did not exploit any benchmark vulnerability.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF pp. 1 and 5, Abstract and Figures 2-3", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-02", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic sandbox; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "The named systems on the study's 14 selected vulnerabilities.", + "uncertainty": "A zero result in this small benchmark is not evidence of zero capability elsewhere.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01637", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF pp. 1 and 5, Abstract and Figures 2-3", + "content_hash": "f4fc06040f0856d99d2009042b4c6fa0c01206da8ca61cb39a94d52b9867cf71", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-008; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-036", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhu et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the HPTSA paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign", + "statement_type": "empirical_finding", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Removing expert agents, reference documents, or the hierarchy reduced success, with the hierarchy ablation producing the largest reported decline.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF p. 6, Section 5.3 and Figure 4", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-02", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic sandbox; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "primary_empirical_result", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "Ablations of GPT-4-backed HPTSA on the study benchmark.", + "uncertainty": "The source reports relative reductions without confidence intervals.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01637", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF p. 6, Section 5.3 and Figure 4", + "content_hash": "f4fc06040f0856d99d2009042b4c6fa0c01206da8ca61cb39a94d52b9867cf71", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-008; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-037", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhu et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the HPTSA paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign", + "statement_type": "warning", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The study demonstrates that a coordinated LLM-agent team can sometimes exploit previously unseen web vulnerabilities in a sandbox.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF pp. 1 and 5, Abstract and Section 5.2", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-02", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic sandbox; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "source_reported_not_independently_verified", + "statement_scope": "Capability demonstration on 14 selected vulnerabilities, not a population estimate.", + "uncertainty": "The result is model-, prompt-, and benchmark-specific and should not be read as production incident prevalence.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01637", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF pp. 1 and 5, Abstract and Section 5.2", + "content_hash": "f4fc06040f0856d99d2009042b4c6fa0c01206da8ca61cb39a94d52b9867cf71", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-008; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-038", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-008", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Zhu et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the HPTSA paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign", + "statement_type": "methodological_claim", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The authors say the web-only sample may be biased and withhold code and prompts to reduce misuse, which limits independent replication.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF pp. 8-9, Section 10 \"Limitations, Ethical Considerations\"", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": "2024-06-02", + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "synthetic sandbox; no human geography" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "External validity and reproducibility of the HPTSA study.", + "uncertainty": "The direction and size of sample bias are not quantified.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01637", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "arXiv:2406.01637v2 PDF pp. 8-9, Section 10 \"Limitations, Ethical Considerations\"", + "content_hash": "f4fc06040f0856d99d2009042b4c6fa0c01206da8ca61cb39a94d52b9867cf71", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-008; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-039", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Shavit et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper)", + "statement_type": "definition", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The paper treats agenticness as a matter of degree across goal complexity, environmental complexity, adaptability, and independent execution.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official PDF p. 4, Section 2.1 \"Agenticness, Agentic AI Systems, and Agents\", 2023 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global policy context" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "The paper's analytical definition of agentic AI systems.", + "uncertainty": "This is a conceptual framework rather than an empirical classification.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://cdn.openai.com/papers/practices-for-governing-agentic-ai-systems.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official PDF p. 4, Section 2.1 \"Agenticness, Agentic AI Systems, and Agents\", 2023 version", + "content_hash": "22b3a8607ed781a848b82b0bfe8e638b16cd027aac90a19b2aecf236063d0e7c", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-009; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-040", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Shavit et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper)", + "statement_type": "strategic_framework", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The paper separates three principal lifecycle roles: model developer, system deployer, and user.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 5-6, Section 2.2 \"The Human Parties in the AI Agent Life-cycle\", 2023 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global policy context" + ], + "evidence_character": "author_interpretation", + "factual_verification_status": "attribution_verified", + "statement_scope": "A simplified role taxonomy for agentic-AI operations.", + "uncertainty": "The authors note that one entity can hold several roles and several entities can share one role.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://cdn.openai.com/papers/practices-for-governing-agentic-ai-systems.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 5-6, Section 2.2 \"The Human Parties in the AI Agent Life-cycle\", 2023 version", + "content_hash": "22b3a8607ed781a848b82b0bfe8e638b16cd027aac90a19b2aecf236063d0e7c", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-009; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-041", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Shavit et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper)", + "statement_type": "policy_position", + "neutral_paraphrase": "The authors argue that every uncompensated direct harm caused by an agentic system should remain attributable to at least one accountable human legal entity.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official PDF p. 3, Section 1 \"Introduction\", 2023 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global policy context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Allocation of accountability for direct harms from agentic systems.", + "uncertainty": "This is a normative position, not a statement of current law.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://cdn.openai.com/papers/practices-for-governing-agentic-ai-systems.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official PDF p. 3, Section 1 \"Introduction\", 2023 version", + "content_hash": "22b3a8607ed781a848b82b0bfe8e638b16cd027aac90a19b2aecf236063d0e7c", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-009; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-042", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Shavit et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper)", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Deployers or users should test whether an agent is suitable for its intended task under conditions resembling deployment.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 8-9, Section 4.1 \"Evaluating Suitability for the Task\", 2023 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global policy context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Reliability evaluation before using an agentic system for a particular use case.", + "uncertainty": "The paper characterizes the evaluation field as immature and provides no universal sufficiency threshold.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://cdn.openai.com/papers/practices-for-governing-agentic-ai-systems.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 8-9, Section 4.1 \"Evaluating Suitability for the Task\", 2023 version", + "content_hash": "22b3a8607ed781a848b82b0bfe8e638b16cd027aac90a19b2aecf236063d0e7c", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-009; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-043", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Shavit et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper)", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "High-consequence actions should be withheld from agents, bounded by hard limits, or made contingent on informed human approval.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 9-10, Section 4.2 \"Constraining the Action-Space and Requiring Approval\", 2023 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global policy context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Actions whose errors could cause serious or irreversible harm.", + "uncertainty": "The paper notes tradeoffs with capability and user burden.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://cdn.openai.com/papers/practices-for-governing-agentic-ai-systems.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 9-10, Section 4.2 \"Constraining the Action-Space and Requiring Approval\", 2023 version", + "content_hash": "22b3a8607ed781a848b82b0bfe8e638b16cd027aac90a19b2aecf236063d0e7c", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-009; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-044", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Shavit et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper)", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "Users or deployers can place a separate automated monitor over an agent's activity when human review cannot match its speed or volume.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 12-13, Section 4.5 \"Automatic Monitoring\", 2023 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global policy context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Automated review of agent reasoning and actions.", + "uncertainty": "The paper emphasizes privacy, cost, control, and monitor-reliability risks.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://cdn.openai.com/papers/practices-for-governing-agentic-ai-systems.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 12-13, Section 4.5 \"Automatic Monitoring\", 2023 version", + "content_hash": "22b3a8607ed781a848b82b0bfe8e638b16cd027aac90a19b2aecf236063d0e7c", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-009; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-045", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Shavit et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper)", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "For high-stakes exchanges, a counterparty could require an agent identifier connected to its human principal and accountability information.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 13-14, Section 4.6 \"Attributability\", 2023 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global policy context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Interactions involving private data, financial activity, or similar high stakes.", + "uncertainty": "The authors also flag anonymity, surveillance, privacy, and spoofing concerns.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://cdn.openai.com/papers/practices-for-governing-agentic-ai-systems.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 13-14, Section 4.6 \"Attributability\", 2023 version", + "content_hash": "22b3a8607ed781a848b82b0bfe8e638b16cd027aac90a19b2aecf236063d0e7c", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-009; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + }, + { + "statement_id": "statement-BATCH-2026-006-046", + "source_id": "source-BATCH-2026-005-009", + "person_id": null, + "institutional_author": "Shavit et al. (joint paper authors)", + "book_edition_id": null, + "speaker_role_at_source_time": "joint authors of the agentic-AI governance paper", + "organization_at_source_time": "OpenAI (publisher; individual affiliations are not stated in the paper)", + "statement_type": "recommendation", + "neutral_paraphrase": "A user's shutdown authority should cover both the primary agent and any subagents it initiated.", + "direct_quote": null, + "direct_quote_rights_note": null, + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 14-15, Section 4.7 \"Interruptibility and Maintaining Control\", 2023 version", + "locator_type": "pdf_page", + "source_date": null, + "topic_ids": [ + "topic-ai-agents", + "topic-ai-governance", + "topic-cybersecurity", + "topic-non-human-identity" + ], + "executive_role_context": [ + "role-ciso", + "role-cio", + "role-cto", + "role-general-counsel", + "role-board-director" + ], + "industry_context": [ + "cross-sector" + ], + "geographic_context": [ + "global policy context" + ], + "evidence_character": "normative_recommendation", + "factual_verification_status": "not_applicable", + "statement_scope": "Agent systems and recursively spawned subagents.", + "uncertainty": "The paper identifies safety-critical exceptions and unresolved implementation tradeoffs.", + "extraction_method": "Machine-assisted close reading of the exact verified source version; original neutral paraphrase; human review pending.", + "machine_extraction_confidence": 0.94, + "independent_agent_review_status": "not_started", + "publication_status": "staging_only", + "workflow_status": "statements_extracted", + "machine_review_status": "machine_checked", + "human_review_status": "pending", + "reviewed_by": null, + "reviewed_at": null, + "provenance": [ + { + "source_url": "https://cdn.openai.com/papers/practices-for-governing-agentic-ai-systems.pdf", + "accessed_at": "2026-08-15", + "retrieval_method": "Exact verified source version inherited from BATCH-2026-005 and statement-level close reading", + "exact_locator": "Official PDF pp. 14-15, Section 4.7 \"Interruptibility and Maintaining Control\", 2023 version", + "content_hash": "22b3a8607ed781a848b82b0bfe8e638b16cd027aac90a19b2aecf236063d0e7c", + "batch_id": "BATCH-2026-006", + "prompt_id": "OEII-STATEMENT-CODING", + "prompt_version": "2.0", + "notes": "Source eligibility inherited from source-BATCH-2026-005-009; human attribution and publication review pending." + } + ], + "revision_history": [] + } +] diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/validation-results.md b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/validation-results.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a758862 --- /dev/null +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/validation-results.md @@ -0,0 +1,20 @@ +# Validation results — BATCH-2026-006 + +Status: PASS on 2026-08-15. Named human review remains pending; these checks do not confer publication approval. + +- PASS — 46 statement records conform to the canonical statement schema; all IDs are unique. +- PASS — All nine verified source records satisfy metadata, access, rights, canonical-ID, and author-linkage gates; one source is coded only through duplicate holds. +- PASS — Each record has one canonical statement type, an allowed evidence character, and an allowed factual-verification status. +- PASS — Joint authorship, role at source time, and organization at source time are explicit; no current role was substituted. +- PASS — Source URL, source-version hash, exact locator, batch ID, prompt ID, and prompt version are preserved in provenance. +- PASS — PDF page locators are within verified document lengths; HTML locators name stable sections; every cited PDF page was rendered and visually inspected. +- PASS — No paraphrase shares ten or more consecutive normalized words with its source; no direct quotation is retained. +- PASS — No exact or high-overlap statement duplicate was found; four OpenID/arXiv rendition duplicates are explicitly held. +- PASS — Statement decisions partition 46 accepted and four held candidates. +- PASS — The double-review sample includes six of 16 high-impact items (37.5%) and four of 30 normal items (13.3%); review completion remains pending. +- PASS — 85 proposed links connect statements to nine candidate-only ideas; no canonical proposition or stance was created. +- PASS — Attribution and locator review CSV files contain one row for every statement. +- PASS — Duration and book-edition checks are correctly not applicable. +- PASS — Canonical repository validators and audits for data, provenance, attributions, statements, propositions, book editions, source locators, rights, review status, publication, content, duplicates, concentration, and coverage. +- PASS — 24 tests across four test files. +- PASS — Whitespace validation and staging-isolation scan; no BATCH-2026-006 statement ID appears in canonical data or generated publication surfaces. From b749cb3da9a369f11eb8504af4ae8d0df23b32b8 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: murraylovecode Date: Sat, 15 Aug 2026 08:16:04 -0700 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] Record statement coding draft pull request --- staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml | 2 +- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml index 4cde057..7cb5fd6 100644 --- a/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml +++ b/staging/batches/BATCH-2026-006/manifest.yml @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ prompt_version: "2.0" topic: Governed identities for AI agents topic_slug: governed-agent-identities branch: research/statements-governed-agent-identities-BATCH-2026-006 -pull_request: pending_draft_pr_creation +pull_request: https://github.com/OpenFutureForum/executive-intelligence-index/pull/7 base_branch: research/evidence-governed-agent-identities-BATCH-2026-005 execution_date: 2026-08-15 execution_completed_at: 2026-08-15T15:06:11Z