From c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: RobinLee Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2026 08:59:56 +0800 Subject: [PATCH 1/2] docs(stage2): record A-02 FIX-04 candidate technical acceptance --- .../actual_automation_integration_plan.md | 32 +++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 32 insertions(+) diff --git a/docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md b/docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md index 194f9e0..da3ad06 100644 --- a/docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md +++ b/docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md @@ -237,6 +237,38 @@ passed under separate exact Owner authorization. The Lab2 runtime closure gap is resolved, but final Stage-2 closure awaits independent closure review and remote Safe CI. Neither proof authorizes another attempt. +**A-02 FIX-04: Candidate technical acceptance is ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES; +Deployment Acceptance remains PENDING.** The Owner designated this Stage-2 +section as the formal record solely for this bounded Candidate technical +acceptance; this designation does not redefine all FIX-04 governance documents. +The accepted evidence covers the Candidate Directory, approvals directory, and +Owner Trust Root JSON against the fixed historical baseline at the time below. + +FIX-04 Provisioning was a separately authorized asset-creation operation that +wrote Candidate assets. The subsequent Candidate acceptance was read-only. +This documentation update records those completed results without repeating +either operation. It does not change the historical Lab1/Lab2 evidence or +complete Stage-2 closure. It grants no authority to apply Startup Pins, activate +the Root, sign or place Approvals, or perform NAL Live operations. + +```text +FIX04_PROVISIONING = SUCCESS +CANDIDATE_TECHNICAL_REVIEW = PASS_WITH_NOTES +OWNER_CANDIDATE_ACCEPTANCE = ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES +ACCEPTANCE_EVIDENCE_TIME = 2026-11-05 09:36:17.897018–09:36:17.908829 Asia/Taipei +INACTIVE_RUNTIME_BINDING_VERIFICATION = NOT_ESTABLISHED +OWNER_DEPLOYMENT_ACCEPTANCE = PENDING +``` + +Required Owner acceptance notes (retained verbatim): + +1. 本次僅接受指定觀察時點的技術證據,不構成持續安全保證。 +2. Inactive Runtime Binding 仍為 NOT_ESTABLISHED,不能宣稱 Root 已獨立證明未啟用。 +3. Startup Pins 比對成功且量測器未套用,不代表所有 Startup/Runtime 均未指向新 Root。 +4. 本次量測獨立於 Provisioning,但仍由同一 Assistant 執行;不同人員/Agent 獨立性未建立。原生量測來自 Codex Sandbox,非 Owner Console。 +5. LastAccessTime 有 7 個物件變動、1 個不變,變動原因未建立;其餘必要一致性檢查全部 PASS。 +6. 未取得原子快照、持續監控或所有未知寫入者不存在的證明;SACL 未讀取。 + #### Historical Lab1 proven scope and result - Device: one specified MikroTik **Lab1**, identified publicly only as From 0f774c47b2529a5f93c0b0abd7c245b85e2d61d2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: RobinLee Date: Mon, 9 Nov 2026 16:36:56 +0800 Subject: [PATCH 2/2] docs(stage2): prepare prospective formal closure candidate --- README.md | 16 ++- .../actual_automation_integration_plan.md | 19 ++- .../stage2_formal_closure.md | 108 +++++++++++++++--- ...ly_s2_ro_10_trusted_runtime_composition.md | 19 ++- ..._vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_11_live_entrypoint.md | 21 +++- docs/portfolio/public_reviewer_walkthrough.md | 18 ++- 6 files changed, 171 insertions(+), 30 deletions(-) diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index e4970e2..2abfc37 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -14,10 +14,22 @@ human-readable evidence, and unsafe or unavailable paths fail closed. read-only proofs completed for MikroTik Lab1 and Lab2, each through the same target-aware fail-closed runtime, one exact command, and zero retries. The Lab2 proof also has independently reviewed persistent startup bindings and -fresh-process reconstruction. Final closure still requires independent review -and remote Safe CI. +fresh-process reconstruction. A new prospective documentation candidate dated +**2026-11-08** starts at `c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7`. +Historical PR #92 merged and declared closure, but its pre-commit independent +review provenance remains **NOT_ESTABLISHED**; the recovered historical +post-CI PASS has a provenance limitation. Neither result supplies this new +candidate's review or CI. The unchanged closure sequence still requires a +different Agent's pre-commit review, a separately authorized commit and push, +exact-commit Safe CI, and independent post-CI review before formal closure. [Closure candidate scope and evidence](docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md). +FIX-04 Candidate technical acceptance remains **ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES**; +Inactive Runtime Binding is **NOT_ESTABLISHED** and Deployment Acceptance is +**PENDING**. The [six retained Owner notes](docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md#stage-2-read-only-lab-adapter) +remain binding. No Root Activation, Approval Signing/Placement, or NAL Live +authority is granted. + The August 2026 release baseline is a local Stage-0 product. The supported release path is designed for local portfolio review: mock-only, dry-run, report-only, and display-oriented. Reviewers do not diff --git a/docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md b/docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md index da3ad06..c57728c 100644 --- a/docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md +++ b/docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md @@ -4,8 +4,11 @@ Owner-authorized MikroTik Lab1 VRRP proof remains accepted, and a later, separately authorized Lab2 one-shot proof passed through the same target-aware runtime. Persistent Lab2 startup bindings, fresh-process reconstruction, and -their independent review also passed. Final Stage-2 closure still requires the -separate independent closure review and remote Safe CI. The default public +their independent review also passed. The 2026-11-08 prospective candidate +preserves the historical PR #92 declaration and the unresolved pre-commit +review provenance. Final Stage-2 closure requires the unchanged pre-commit +review, commit/push, exact-commit Safe CI, and independent post-CI review +sequence in the [closure record](stage2_formal_closure.md). The default public review path remains Stage-0 offline evidence browsing. Stage 3 is **NOT STARTED / requires separate Owner authorization**. @@ -234,8 +237,16 @@ Exit gate: Status: **CLOSURE CANDIDATE**. The earlier Lab1 proof and later Lab2 proof each passed under separate exact Owner authorization. The Lab2 runtime closure gap -is resolved, but final Stage-2 closure awaits independent closure review and -remote Safe CI. Neither proof authorizes another attempt. +is resolved. A new prospective documentation candidate was prepared on +2026-11-08 from `c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7`. Historical PR #92 +merged and declared closure, but its pre-commit independent review remains +NOT_ESTABLISHED; recovered historical post-CI review is +PASS_WITH_PROVENANCE_LIMITATION. Those historical records do not satisfy the +new candidate's Gates. Its pre-commit independent review is PENDING, its commit +is NOT_CREATED, and its remote Safe CI and post-CI review are NOT_RUN. Follow +the unchanged [Closure Contract section 13](stage2_formal_closure.md#13-closure-criteria). +Neither live proof authorizes another attempt, and this prospective work does +not revalidate the historical technical results or grant deployment authority. **A-02 FIX-04: Candidate technical acceptance is ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES; Deployment Acceptance remains PENDING.** The Owner designated this Stage-2 diff --git a/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md b/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md index 31cdab5..5e078d3 100644 --- a/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md +++ b/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md @@ -5,25 +5,33 @@ Stage 2 is a **CLOSURE CANDIDATE**, not formally closed. The repository's bounded S2-RO-01 through S2-RO-11 capability is complete; separate one-shot Lab1 and Lab2 live proofs are accepted; and persistent Lab2 target and -known-host startup reconstruction passed independent review. Final closure -does not require another local validation run: the accepted local validation -for this closure candidate is complete. The remaining sequence is an -independent review of the repaired documentation, a local closure commit, a -branch push, remote Safe CI, and a subsequent independent post-Safe-CI closure -review. Only after every remaining gate passes may Stage 2 be marked formally -closed. +known-host startup reconstruction passed independent review. This is a new +prospective documentation candidate prepared on **2026-11-08**, not a backdated +historical review. Historical PR #92 declared closure, but its pre-commit +independent review provenance remains NOT_ESTABLISHED. The recovered historical +post-CI PASS does not resolve that gap or validate this new candidate. + +The existing section 13 sequence remains controlling: local candidate and +offline validation, independent documentation review, a separately authorized +local commit, branch push, exact-commit remote Safe CI, and independent +post-Safe-CI closure review. Only after all required Gates pass may the Owner +make the formal closure decision. This preparation task grants no authority +for those later actions. ```text STAGE2_STATUS = CLOSURE CANDIDATE STAGE2_FORMAL_STATUS = CLOSURE_CANDIDATE STAGE2_RUNTIME_CLOSURE_GAP = NONE -LOCAL_VALIDATION_STATUS = COMPLETED +LOCAL_VALIDATION_STATUS = PENDING_CURRENT_CANDIDATE_VALIDATION REMOTE_SAFE_CI_STATUS = PENDING POST_SAFE_CI_CLOSURE_REVIEW_STATUS = PENDING READY_FOR_DUAL_LAB_AI_QUERY = NO ``` -This record does not authorize another live attempt or begin Dual-Lab AI Query. +This record does not authorize another live attempt or begin any next phase. +Later, separately accepted offline Dual-Lab work retains its own evidence and +authority boundaries in the [Integration Plan](actual_automation_integration_plan.md); +it does not fill this candidate's missing closure Gates. ## 1. Scope @@ -51,6 +59,55 @@ Repository code defines the bounded capability and validation contracts. Repository-external Owner-controlled deployment assets supply live pins and authority. Those are distinct trust domains. +### Prospective reconciliation: 2026-11-08 + +The Owner authorized a new six-file candidate from the committed base below. +The isolated candidate uses the committed Portfolio document; it does not +import the original worktree's unpublished Portfolio edits. + +Historical closure commit `cf216d0870a3019925faee1870790adfdd093a3d` was +integrated by [PR #92](https://github.com/Robinlee0929/Network_Automation_Lab/pull/92) +at merge `d57b802e5d7a9cbe1d684c3dd058527685c56d62`. +The historical [Safe CI run 35743788235](https://github.com/Robinlee0929/Network_Automation_Lab/actions/runs/35743788235) +passed. PR #92's formal-closure declaration is retained as historical evidence. +Owner-authorized provenance reconciliation found the original post-CI review +PASS, but could not establish the preceding independent pre-commit PASS; the +historical Owner closure instruction was conditional. These are retained +findings, not a new search or a replacement historical PASS. The full historical +closure chain therefore remains unconfirmed. + +```text +HISTORICAL_PRE_COMMIT_REVIEW = NOT_ESTABLISHED +HISTORICAL_POST_CI_REVIEW = PASS_WITH_PROVENANCE_LIMITATION +PR92_MERGE = COMPLETED +CURRENT_CANDIDATE_DATE = 2026-11-08 +CURRENT_CANDIDATE_BASE = c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7 +CURRENT_PRECOMMIT_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW = PENDING +CURRENT_CANDIDATE_COMMIT = NOT_CREATED +CURRENT_CANDIDATE_REMOTE_SAFE_CI = NOT_RUN +CURRENT_POST_CI_REVIEW = NOT_RUN +STAGE2_FORMAL_STATUS = CLOSURE_CANDIDATE +FIX04_CANDIDATE_ACCEPTANCE = ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES +FIX04_INACTIVE_RUNTIME_BINDING = NOT_ESTABLISHED +FIX04_DEPLOYMENT_ACCEPTANCE = PENDING +ROOT_ACTIVATION_AUTHORIZED = NO +APPROVAL_SIGNING_AUTHORIZED = NO +APPROVAL_PLACEMENT_AUTHORIZED = NO +DL06_02_LIVE_AUTHORIZED = NO +``` + +The base includes the separately committed FIX-04 Candidate technical record; +it is not the new Stage-2 closure commit. FIX-04 Provisioning wrote assets under +separate authorization; its later acceptance was read-only. Its +[six Owner acceptance notes](actual_automation_integration_plan.md#stage-2-read-only-lab-adapter) +remain verbatim and unresolved. Startup Pins comparison does not independently +prove current Runtime inactivity. FIX-04 Deployment Acceptance remains pending. + +The document author prepares and self-validates this candidate. A different +Agent's pre-commit independent review is a separate, pending task; author +self-checks do not satisfy it. No historical review is backfilled and no +section 13 criterion or Gate order is waived. + ## 3. S2-RO-01 through S2-RO-11 completion status | Slice | Capability | Candidate status | @@ -182,13 +239,15 @@ test passed 6/6 and its focused repository tests passed 397/397. Earlier S2-RO-10 and S2-RO-11 integration records retain their own focused, Stage-2, full-suite, report-index, independent-review, and hosted-CI evidence. -This closure-candidate change separately completed focused Stage-2 validation, +The historical closure-candidate change separately completed focused Stage-2 validation, the complete Stage-2 suite, full pytest, report-index classification, and a local documentation consistency/readability check. None of those checks contacted Lab1 or Lab2. Remote Safe CI and the independent post-Safe-CI closure -review remain pending and do not require another local validation run. +review were still pending at that record's preparation time. The later PR #92 +and provenance findings are recorded above; this paragraph is not current +candidate evidence. -Local closure-candidate validation completed with the repository code unchanged: +Historical local closure-candidate validation completed with repository code unchanged: | Check | Result | | --- | --- | @@ -201,7 +260,21 @@ Local closure-candidate validation completed with the repository code unchanged: The authoritative reruns used an isolated Windows pytest temporary directory. The full-suite rerun used the existing installed Node dependency tree so Node subprocess fixtures could resolve TypeScript; no dependency was installed or -changed. These are local checks only. Remote Safe CI remains pending. +changed. These are historical local checks only, not the 2026-11-08 candidate's +validation or proof that the newly installed Node tree is identical to the +historical environment. + +### Current candidate validation + +The prospective candidate requires fresh focused target-registry/composition/ +entrypoint tests, complete `tests/stage2`, full `python -m pytest`, and +`python network_lab.py --task report-index`, followed by document/Diff checks. +Each pytest run uses its own new Windows temporary directory outside the +repository, preserving the replay ledger's repository-exclusion Gate. +Python 3.13.7 / pytest 8.4.2 and Node 22.23.2 / npm 10.9.8 / TypeScript 5.9.3 +are the verified local environment. No dependency installation or live proof +is part of this task. Current results and candidate hashes must be recorded +before handoff; historical counts above are not substitutes. ## 11. Historical limitations and unresolved provenance @@ -227,15 +300,16 @@ This candidate must not be interpreted to mean that: - repository source reachability grants execution authority; - generic RouterOS, multi-vendor, arbitrary-command, write, production, fleet, or autonomous-remediation capability exists; -- Dual-Lab AI Query already exists; or +- this candidate grants Dual-Lab AI Query authority (later offline acceptance + has its own separate record); or - Stage 2 is formally closed before remote Safe CI and the subsequent independent post-Safe-CI closure review. ## 13. Closure criteria -Local validation for the current closure candidate is complete. Stage 2 may be -labeled formally closed only after the remaining governance sequence also -completes. The controlling order is: +The prospective candidate must satisfy the existing local validation Gates +with its own evidence. Stage 2 may be labeled formally closed only after the +full governance sequence completes. The controlling order is unchanged: ```text local closure candidate diff --git a/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_10_trusted_runtime_composition.md b/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_10_trusted_runtime_composition.md index 37c2315..09e949f 100644 --- a/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_10_trusted_runtime_composition.md +++ b/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_10_trusted_runtime_composition.md @@ -32,8 +32,23 @@ CANONICAL_STATUS = LAB2_PROOF_COMPLETE_STAGE2_CLOSURE_CANDIDATE The accepted Lab2 proof covers one target, one operation, one command, and one consumed authorization only. It does not revalidate Lab1, prove overall VRRP pair health, establish production readiness or write automation, or grant -future live authority. Stage 2 remains a closure candidate until the separate -independent closure review and remote Safe CI complete. +future live authority. Stage 2 remains a closure candidate under the unchanged +[section 13 closure sequence](stage2_formal_closure.md#13-closure-criteria). + +The 2026-11-08 prospective documentation candidate starts from +`c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7`. Historical PR #92 merged and declared +closure; its pre-commit independent review remains NOT_ESTABLISHED and its +recovered post-CI review is PASS_WITH_PROVENANCE_LIMITATION. This component's +accepted technical evidence below is preserved and supplies neither the new +pre-commit review nor its exact-commit Safe CI. New review is PENDING, the new +commit is NOT_CREATED, and new remote CI/post-CI review are NOT_RUN. + +FIX-04 Candidate acceptance is ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES; Inactive Runtime Binding +is NOT_ESTABLISHED and Deployment Acceptance is PENDING. The historical Lab2 +startup proof below does not prove whether Runtime uses the new FIX-04 Root. +The [six retained FIX-04 notes](actual_automation_integration_plan.md#stage-2-read-only-lab-adapter) +remain applicable. No activation, Approval Signing/Placement, live invocation, +or next-phase authority is granted by this documentation preparation. `OFFLINE_IMPLEMENTATION_AUTHORITY != LIVE_EXECUTION_AUTHORITY` diff --git a/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_11_live_entrypoint.md b/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_11_live_entrypoint.md index 3722fe0..21ad40c 100644 --- a/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_11_live_entrypoint.md +++ b/docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_11_live_entrypoint.md @@ -7,8 +7,23 @@ runtime. Its implementation and independent security review passed with zero unresolved material findings. A later, separately authorized Lab2 one-shot invocation also passed and its proof is closed. The entrypoint returns only canonical S2-RO-01 evidence bytes or one sanitized failure category. The -overall Stage-2 status remains **CLOSURE CANDIDATE** pending independent -closure review and remote Safe CI. +overall Stage-2 status remains **CLOSURE CANDIDATE** under the unchanged +[section 13 closure sequence](stage2_formal_closure.md#13-closure-criteria). + +The 2026-11-08 prospective documentation candidate starts from +`c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7`. Historical PR #92 merged and declared +closure, but its pre-commit independent review is NOT_ESTABLISHED; recovered +historical post-CI review is PASS_WITH_PROVENANCE_LIMITATION. Those results and +the component evidence below do not validate this new candidate. Its separate +pre-commit review is PENDING, commit NOT_CREATED, and remote CI/post-CI review +NOT_RUN. Author self-validation cannot replace a different Agent's review. + +FIX-04 Candidate acceptance remains ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES, Inactive Runtime +Binding NOT_ESTABLISHED, and Deployment Acceptance PENDING. The +[six retained Owner notes](actual_automation_integration_plan.md#stage-2-read-only-lab-adapter) +are unchanged. The historical startup reconstruction below does not establish +the new FIX-04 Root's current Runtime use. No Root Activation, Approval +Signing/Placement, live entrypoint invocation, or next-phase authority follows. `S2_RO_11_IMPLEMENTED != REAL_RUN_AUTHORIZED` @@ -18,7 +33,7 @@ closure review and remote Safe CI. ## Allowed scope and API -Exactly three candidate files are included: +The historical S2-RO-11 implementation candidate included exactly three files: - [Entrypoint](../../validation_framework/stage2_vrrp_readonly_live_entrypoint.py). - [Offline tests](../../tests/stage2/test_vrrp_readonly_live_entrypoint.py). diff --git a/docs/portfolio/public_reviewer_walkthrough.md b/docs/portfolio/public_reviewer_walkthrough.md index 121bcf2..820f0bb 100644 --- a/docs/portfolio/public_reviewer_walkthrough.md +++ b/docs/portfolio/public_reviewer_walkthrough.md @@ -11,11 +11,25 @@ calls, secrets, or command execution from the dashboard. **Stage 2 is a CLOSURE CANDIDATE.** Separate Owner-authorized one-shot MikroTik Lab1 and Lab2 VRRP proofs completed through the bounded read-only runtime. Persistent Lab2 startup reconstruction also passed independent -review. Final closure still requires independent closure review and remote -Safe CI. The results can be explained offline using the +review. The 2026-11-08 prospective documentation candidate starts from +`c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7`. Historical PR #92 merged and declared +closure, but its pre-commit independent review provenance remains +NOT_ESTABLISHED; recovered historical post-CI PASS has a provenance limitation. +It is not a new-candidate PASS. Pre-commit independent review is PENDING, +the new commit is NOT_CREATED, and new remote Safe CI/post-CI review are NOT_RUN. +The existing review -> commit/push -> exact-commit Safe CI -> independent +post-CI review sequence still controls formal closure. Explain these boundaries +and the retained technical results offline using the [formal closure candidate](../automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md). Stage 3 is **NOT STARTED**. +FIX-04 Candidate technical acceptance is ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES, while Inactive +Runtime Binding is NOT_ESTABLISHED and Deployment Acceptance remains PENDING. +Keep the [six Owner acceptance notes](../automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md#stage-2-read-only-lab-adapter) +with this explanation. Startup Pins comparison does not prove Runtime +inactivity. This walkthrough grants no Root Activation, Approval +Signing/Placement, NAL Live, or next-phase authority. + ## One-Sentence Project Positioning Network Automation Lab is a safety-first Python portfolio project that turns