diff --git a/mock_tests/test_readd_no_stale_errors.py b/mock_tests/test_readd_no_stale_errors.py
new file mode 100644
index 000000000..ce397e177
--- /dev/null
+++ b/mock_tests/test_readd_no_stale_errors.py
@@ -0,0 +1,40 @@
+import warnings
+import weaviate
+from weaviate.collections.classes.batch import ErrorObject
+from weaviate.proto.v1 import batch_pb2, weaviate_pb2_grpc
+from .conftest import MOCK_IP, MOCK_PORT, MOCK_PORT_GRPC, mock_class
+
+
+class Svc(weaviate_pb2_grpc.WeaviateServicer):
+    calls = 0
+
+    def BatchObjects(self, request, context):
+        self.calls += 1
+        if self.calls == 2:  # second chunk, once: rate-limit its first object
+            return batch_pb2.BatchObjectsReply(errors=[{"index": 0, "error": "failed with status: 503 error"}])
+        return batch_pb2.BatchObjectsReply()
+
+
+def test_readd_no_stale_errors_and_no_dep020(weaviate_mock, start_grpc_server):
+    """Re-adding rate-limited objects must not leave stale errors behind, and
+    the internal re-add path must not trigger the deprecated
+    ``all_responses`` property's Dep020 warning (issue #2179)."""
+    weaviate_mock.expect_request(f"/v1/schema/{mock_class['class']}").respond_with_json(mock_class)
+    weaviate_pb2_grpc.add_WeaviateServicer_to_server(Svc(), start_grpc_server)
+    client = weaviate.connect_to_local(port=MOCK_PORT, host=MOCK_IP, grpc_port=MOCK_PORT_GRPC)
+    try:
+        col = client.collections.use(mock_class["class"])
+        with warnings.catch_warnings(record=True) as w:
+            warnings.simplefilter("always")
+            with col.batch.fixed_size(batch_size=2, concurrent_requests=1) as b:
+                for i in range(4):
+                    b.add_object({"name": f"o{i}"})
+        r = col.batch.results.objs
+        dep = [x for x in w if "all_responses" in str(x.message)]
+        stale = [x for x in r._all_responses if isinstance(x, ErrorObject)]
+        assert len(dep) == 0, f"deprecated all_responses read during batch: {[str(x.message)[:60] for x in dep]}"
+        assert len(r.errors) == 0
+        assert len(stale) == 0, f"stale errors left behind: {[e.message for e in stale]}"
+        assert len(r._all_responses) == 4
+    finally:
+        client.close()
diff --git a/weaviate/collections/batch/base.py b/weaviate/collections/batch/base.py
index 1d736303c..ae2ff3a37 100644
--- a/weaviate/collections/batch/base.py
+++ b/weaviate/collections/batch/base.py
@@ -715,10 +715,20 @@ def __send_batch(
                     },
                     errors=new_errors,
                     has_errors=len(new_errors) > 0,
+                    # Filter by uuid, not by list position: the batch-wide
+                    # index of an errored object is not its position in
+                    # _all_responses, so position-based filtering left the
+                    # re-added objects' stale errors behind from the second
+                    # chunk on. The private field is read directly to avoid
+                    # the deprecated property's Dep020 warning in internal
+                    # code (issue #2179).
                     _all_responses=[
-                        err
-                        for i, err in enumerate(response_obj.all_responses)
-                        if i not in readded_objects
+                        r
+                        for r in response_obj._all_responses
+                        if not (
+                            isinstance(r, ErrorObject)
+                            and r.object_.uuid in readded_uuids
+                        )
                     ],
                     elapsed_seconds=response_obj.elapsed_seconds,
                 )