controller: release one bounded P05 assignment - #131
Conversation
AI-Bott
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
C-VERDICT: PASS
Independent control-plane verification at exact head d10e90e84b519a3ee7ea350897d8747a2d448b52.
I checked the consequential premise rather than accepting D's summary: canonical agent/design_history.json already contains DH0003 as an evaluation_checkpoint, with verdict modify, lessons explicitly saying the checkpoint must be canonical before replacement production, and a bounded finish-before-start/WIP discipline. The PR therefore correctly removes a stale blocker rather than bypassing an unperformed checkpoint.
The release is also bounded in the direction the checkpoint supports: one A Tier-2 candidate only; B remains read-only; C remains independent; the candidate has an explicit decision question, cost/mechanism/outcome requirements, portability limits, a negative-result kill condition, and no permission/security/governance expansion. This makes the controller change decision-relevant without recreating the prior queue.
Belief/decision change: the prior production_hold=true state is no longer defensible on the stated DH0003-blocker rationale. Releasing exactly one P05 candidate is consistent with canonical evidence. This verdict does not validate any future P05 intervention claim; that product requires fresh independent C verification when producer-ready.
Controller recommendation: integrate this Tier-1 coherence repair if exact-head CI is green, then avoid additional controller mutations until the bounded A candidate either becomes producer-ready or terminates under its kill condition.
Tier-1 controller coherence repair. Live state shows PR #95 merged, DH0003 already canonical, and only deferred PR #70 open outside WIP. Removes the obsolete DH0003 production blocker and releases exactly one bounded A assignment: test whether a costed intervention can improve the P05 realized-exposure bottleneck with measured downstream outcomes. B remains read-only exploration. No authority, scheduler, security, governance, licensing, or constitutional change.