Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
61 changes: 36 additions & 25 deletions README.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -10,19 +10,24 @@ review. Network Automation Lab treats that work as a small QA platform: local
inputs are validated deterministically, results become machine-readable and
human-readable evidence, and unsafe or unavailable paths fail closed.

**Stage 2: CLOSURE CANDIDATE.** Separate Owner-authorized one-shot VRRP
read-only proofs completed for MikroTik Lab1 and Lab2, each through the same
target-aware fail-closed runtime, one exact command, and zero retries. The
Lab2 proof also has independently reviewed persistent startup bindings and
fresh-process reconstruction. A new prospective documentation candidate dated
**2026-11-08** starts at `c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7`.
Historical PR #92 merged and declared closure, but its pre-commit independent
review provenance remains **NOT_ESTABLISHED**; the recovered historical
post-CI PASS has a provenance limitation. Neither result supplies this new
candidate's review or CI. The unchanged closure sequence still requires a
different Agent's pre-commit review, a separately authorized commit and push,
exact-commit Safe CI, and independent post-CI review before formal closure.
[Closure candidate scope and evidence](docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md).
**Stage 2: CLOSED — documentation-only, fixed-head scope.** The completed
bounded Lab1/Lab2 technical results and their original safety limits remain
unchanged; this status update does not repeat their validation.

The Owner approved **DOCUMENTATION_ONLY_FIXED_HEAD** closure on **2026-11-10**
for `0f774c47b2529a5f93c0b0abd7c245b85e2d61d2`.
[PR #98](https://github.com/Robinlee0929/Network_Automation_Lab/pull/98) is MERGED
at main `18fd0d6ce4230e947acdb1d57d5e3a9128c0ccb6`;
[post-merge Safe CI 42760192089](https://github.com/Robinlee0929/Network_Automation_Lab/actions/runs/42760192089)
is SUCCESS. The [closure record](docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md#decision-summary) separates that fixed decision
from later publication and retained historical evidence.

**Historical preparation (2026-11-08):** the prospective candidate began at
`c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7`. Historical PR #92 declared closure,
but its pre-commit independent review provenance remains **NOT_ESTABLISHED**;
the recovered historical post-CI PASS retains its provenance limitation.
The then-pending candidate Gates remain recorded as historical evidence in
the closure record. They were not backdated to PASS.

FIX-04 Candidate technical acceptance remains **ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES**;
Inactive Runtime Binding is **NOT_ESTABLISHED** and Deployment Acceptance is
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -313,21 +318,21 @@ It includes contributor and security guidance, Issue and pull request
templates, newcomer-friendly Issues, and protected-`main` governance through
pull requests and Safe CI. Stage 1's planning entry is retained as historical
context. The separately authorized, bounded Stage-2 implementation and live
proofs now form a closure candidate; the canonical
[Stage model](docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md)
and [formal closure candidate](docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md)
record the proof, remaining review gate, and limits.
proofs are covered by the Owner's fixed-head documentation-only closure; the
canonical [Stage model](docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md)
and [formal closure record](docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md)
record the decision, publication evidence, historical Gates, and retained limits.

| Stage | Purpose | Status |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **Stage 0 — Closed public baseline** | Mock-only, dry-run, report-only, reviewer-visible, fail-closed validation and evidence | **CLOSED** |
| **Stage 1 — Read-only Lab Integration Planning** | Historical planning entry for contracts, allowlists, failure behavior, evidence, and credential boundaries | Historical planning record; see the bounded Stage-2 outcome below |
| **Stage 2 — Narrow Read-only Lab Adapter** | Separate bounded MikroTik Lab1 and Lab2 VRRP proofs; target-aware composition; one exact command per authorization; zero retries; normalized evidence; persistent Lab2 startup reconstruction | **CLOSURE CANDIDATE — independent closure review and remote Safe CI pending** |
| **Stage 2 — Narrow Read-only Lab Adapter** | Separate bounded MikroTik Lab1 and Lab2 VRRP proofs; target-aware composition; one exact command per authorization; zero retries; normalized evidence; persistent Lab2 startup reconstruction | **CLOSED — Owner approved 2026-11-10; documentation-only fixed-head scope** |
| **Stage 3 — Controlled Config Plan Generation** | Future human-reviewable configuration plans only; no apply | **NOT STARTED / requires separate Owner authorization** |
| **Stage 4 — Controlled Change Execution** | Permit narrowly approved lab changes with explicit safeguards and evidence | **Future / separate gate** |
| **Stage 5 — Production-like Platform** | Add mature access control, audit, rollback, monitoring, and human approval | **Long-term / not currently authorized** |

The bounded Stage-2 exit is the major-development pause point. The candidate
The bounded Stage-2 exit is the major-development pause point. The closure record
records two independent one-shot operations; the Lab2 proof did not revalidate
Lab1 and does not establish overall Lab1/Lab2 VRRP pair health. It also does
not establish generic RouterOS or every MikroTik model/version, multi-vendor
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -500,11 +505,11 @@ release lanes; they are not performed by documentation-only changes.

## Current Release Status

| Area | Current status (August baseline with Stage-2 closure candidate) |
| Area | Current status (August baseline with Stage-2 documentation-only closure) |
| --- | --- |
| Stage-0 Network Automation Lab | **CLOSED** at `main@aff250735ade18e4c274be8ac53c9672bb2cb07f` |
| Stage-1 Read-only Lab Integration Planning | Historical planning-entry record; see the Stage-2 closure candidate |
| Stage-2 bounded MikroTik VRRP validation | Lab1 historical proof retained; Lab2 proof PASS/CLOSED on repository baseline `ea73196281e38a01af7bf959cc5e1bc60b0b2499`; persistent Lab2 startup reconstruction and independent binding review PASS; overall Stage 2 is a **CLOSURE CANDIDATE** |
| Stage-1 Read-only Lab Integration Planning | Historical planning-entry record; see the Stage-2 closure record |
| Stage-2 bounded MikroTik VRRP validation | Lab1 historical proof retained; Lab2 proof PASS/CLOSED on repository baseline `ea73196281e38a01af7bf959cc5e1bc60b0b2499`; persistent Lab2 startup reconstruction and independent binding review PASS; overall Stage 2 is **CLOSED for DOCUMENTATION_ONLY_FIXED_HEAD** |
| Dual-Lab AI Query | **DL-02, DL-03, DL-04, and DL-05 accepted; bounded offline MVP complete**; PR #93 merged; pre/post-merge Safe CI PASS, fresh exact-SHA review PASS, Owner acceptance ACCEPT / PASS; 0 unresolved material findings; P3 open/non-blocking; 7 maintenance build warnings retained; no live authority |
| DL-06 offline transition contract | **DL-06-00 specification established; DL-06-01 Owner accepted / PASS and published to main through PR #95; pre/post-merge Safe CI PASS**; 0 unresolved material findings; 3 retained non-blocking findings; DL-06-02 NOT_AUTHORIZED; DL-06-03 BLOCKED; no live authority |
| Stage 3 | **NOT STARTED / requires separate Owner authorization** |
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -653,6 +658,12 @@ future capabilities stay behind their separate authorization and safety gates.

### Post-release or deferred

The 18 npm-affected package groups, including Critical, remain unrepaired.
Seven Build Warnings and 13 Optional Missing reports remain open. This
documentation-only closure creates no security exemption or deployment-safety
claim. Next.js must receive separately authorized security remediation and
validation before restart or deployment.

- Continue WF-01-03B security research only after explicit reauthorization.
- Revisit C017/AppContainer research if it remains relevant.
- Plan WF-01-03C through WF-01-03F as separate future work.
Expand All @@ -672,7 +683,7 @@ future capabilities stay behind their separate authorization and safety gates.
- Keep the historical post-merge Safe CI maintenance findings OPEN: that run reported 5
vulnerabilities (2 moderate, 2 high, 1 critical), and Next.js emitted 7
filesystem-tracing warnings. These are non-Stage-2-blocking maintenance items;
the Stage-2 closure candidate does not resolve them. The later DL-06-01
the Stage-2 documentation-only closure does not resolve them. The later DL-06-01
environment-restoration observation reported 12 vulnerabilities, retained above;
these are distinct observations, not evidence of remediation.

Expand All @@ -691,7 +702,7 @@ deliberately non-executing public review path.
- [Canonical Quick Start and demo runbook](docs/phase_2n/phase_2n_01_canonical_quick_start_and_demo_runbook_documentation_only.md)
- [Accepted Stage-0 user-facing baseline](docs/phase_2n/phase_2n_05_final_user_facing_acceptance_review_phase_closure_review_only.md)
- [Stage 0 formal closure](docs/automation_readiness/stage0_formal_closure.md)
- [Stage 2 formal closure candidate](docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md)
- [Stage 2 formal closure record](docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md)

### Architecture and safety

Expand All @@ -716,6 +727,6 @@ deliberately non-executing public review path.

Historical records describe the state and authorization boundary at the time
they were written. Use Current Release Status above and the canonical Stage
model for the August baseline and subsequent bounded Stage-2 closure candidate.
model for the August baseline and subsequent bounded Stage-2 documentation-only closure.

This project is distributed under the [MIT License](LICENSE).
59 changes: 43 additions & 16 deletions docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,16 +1,16 @@
# Actual Automation Integration Plan

**Decision summary: Stage 2 is a CLOSURE CANDIDATE.** The historical
Owner-authorized MikroTik Lab1 VRRP proof remains accepted, and a later,
separately authorized Lab2 one-shot proof passed through the same target-aware
runtime. Persistent Lab2 startup bindings, fresh-process reconstruction, and
their independent review also passed. The 2026-11-08 prospective candidate
preserves the historical PR #92 declaration and the unresolved pre-commit
review provenance. Final Stage-2 closure requires the unchanged pre-commit
review, commit/push, exact-commit Safe CI, and independent post-CI review
sequence in the [closure record](stage2_formal_closure.md). The default public
review path remains Stage-0 offline evidence browsing. Stage 3 is **NOT
STARTED / requires separate Owner authorization**.
**Decision summary: Stage 2 is CLOSED for DOCUMENTATION_ONLY_FIXED_HEAD.**
The Owner approved closure on 2026-11-10 for
`0f774c47b2529a5f93c0b0abd7c245b85e2d61d2` after the existing section 13
sequence completed. [PR #98](https://github.com/Robinlee0929/Network_Automation_Lab/pull/98)
published the result at main `18fd0d6ce4230e947acdb1d57d5e3a9128c0ccb6`;
[post-merge Safe CI 42760192089](https://github.com/Robinlee0929/Network_Automation_Lab/actions/runs/42760192089)
is SUCCESS. The [closure record](stage2_formal_closure.md#decision-summary)
retains the fixed decision, historical provenance gap, and maintenance limits.
This reconciliation does not repeat acceptance or extend the decision to later
commits. The public path remains Stage-0 offline evidence browsing. Stage 3 is
**NOT STARTED / requires separate Owner authorization**.

**Dual-Lab status: DL-05 ACCEPTED / PASS; bounded offline MVP complete.**
DL-02 implementation `bb39e8295a2fa5d69980396dbaf8c374c79a57b3`, DL-03
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -235,6 +235,29 @@ Exit gate:

### Stage 2: Read-only Lab Adapter

Current formal status: **CLOSED**, limited to the Owner's 2026-11-10
`DOCUMENTATION_ONLY_FIXED_HEAD` decision. PR #98 and its post-merge CI are
publication evidence, not deployment acceptance.

```text
STAGE2_FORMAL_STATUS = CLOSED
OWNER_FORMAL_CLOSURE_DECISION = APPROVED
OWNER_FORMAL_CLOSURE_DATE = 2026-11-10
CLOSURE_SCOPE = DOCUMENTATION_ONLY_FIXED_HEAD
CLOSURE_SHA = 0f774c47b2529a5f93c0b0abd7c245b85e2d61d2
PR98_STATUS = MERGED
MAIN_MERGE_SHA = 18fd0d6ce4230e947acdb1d57d5e3a9128c0ccb6
POST_MERGE_SAFE_CI_RUN = 42760192089
POST_MERGE_SAFE_CI_RESULT = SUCCESS
```

The 18 npm-affected package groups, including Critical, remain unrepaired.
Seven Build Warnings and 13 Optional Missing reports remain open. This
documentation-only closure creates no security exemption or deployment-safety
claim. Next.js must receive separately authorized security remediation and
validation before restart or deployment.

**Historical preparation snapshot — 2026-11-08 (not current status):**
Status: **CLOSURE CANDIDATE**. The earlier Lab1 proof and later Lab2 proof each
passed under separate exact Owner authorization. The Lab2 runtime closure gap
is resolved. A new prospective documentation candidate was prepared on
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -367,6 +390,9 @@ interval `1000` ms, version `3`, role `BACKUP`, `running=false`,
`running=false` is not independently characterized as a fault, and this proof
does not establish Lab1 state or overall Lab1/Lab2 VRRP health.

The following status block preserves the earlier Lab2/candidate observation;
its CLOSURE CANDIDATE label is historical, not the current formal decision.

```text
LAB2_S2_RO_11_LIVE_PROOF = PASS
LAB2_LIVE_PROOF_STATUS = CLOSED
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -543,11 +569,12 @@ evidence of a prior explicit Owner authorization and grants no standing live
authority. Every new live access requires fresh exact Owner authorization.

Stage 0 remains the default mock-only, dry-run, report-only public review path.
Stage 2 is a CLOSURE CANDIDATE based on the recorded, separately authorized
Lab1 and Lab2 VRRP read-only proofs and completed persistent Lab2 startup
reconstruction. This candidate activates no new adapter, protocol, provider,
credential, device, or execution capability and permits no repeat attempt.
Formal closure still requires independent closure review and remote Safe CI.
Stage 2 is CLOSED for the Owner's fixed-head documentation-only scope,
based on the completed section 13 sequence and the recorded, separately
authorized Lab1/Lab2 proofs and persistent Lab2 startup reconstruction.
Closure activates no adapter, protocol, provider, credential, device, or
execution capability and permits no repeat attempt. Deployment acceptance,
maintenance findings, and future execution authority remain separate.
The bounded offline Dual-Lab AI Query MVP is accepted and complete. DL-01 is the
completed prerequisite contract; DL-02, DL-03, DL-04, and DL-05 are accepted.
DL-05's accepted implementation remains
Expand Down
64 changes: 62 additions & 2 deletions docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,7 +1,60 @@
# Stage 2 Formal Closure Candidate
# Stage 2 Formal Closure Record

## Decision summary

**Stage 2 is CLOSED for DOCUMENTATION_ONLY_FIXED_HEAD.** On 2026-11-10,
the Owner approved the completed technical results, documentation consistency,
and accepted validation evidence at the fixed closure commit below. This
records the existing decision; it does not restart Stage-2 review, waive
section 13, or approve subsequent commits or deployment.

```text
OWNER_FORMAL_CLOSURE_DECISION = APPROVED
OWNER_FORMAL_CLOSURE_DATE = 2026-11-10
STAGE2_FORMAL_STATUS = CLOSED
CLOSURE_SCOPE = DOCUMENTATION_ONLY_FIXED_HEAD
CLOSURE_SHA = 0f774c47b2529a5f93c0b0abd7c245b85e2d61d2
PR98_STATUS = MERGED
MAIN_MERGE_SHA = 18fd0d6ce4230e947acdb1d57d5e3a9128c0ccb6
POST_MERGE_SAFE_CI_RUN = 42760192089
POST_MERGE_SAFE_CI_RESULT = SUCCESS
FIX04_CANDIDATE_ACCEPTANCE = ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES
FIX04_INACTIVE_RUNTIME_BINDING = NOT_ESTABLISHED
FIX04_DEPLOYMENT_ACCEPTANCE = PENDING
HISTORICAL_PRE_COMMIT_REVIEW = NOT_ESTABLISHED
STAGE3_AUTHORIZED = NO
NAL_LIVE_AUTHORIZED = NO
ROOT_ACTIVATION_AUTHORIZED = NO
APPROVAL_SIGNING_AUTHORIZED = NO
APPROVAL_PLACEMENT_AUTHORIZED = NO
```

The Owner's accepted closure basis includes 523 focused, 1,892 complete Stage-2,
and 4,870 full pytest passes, acceptable Report-index WARN, different-Agent
pre-commit and post-CI review PASS, and
[exact-head Safe CI 42601576002](https://github.com/Robinlee0929/Network_Automation_Lab/actions/runs/42601576002).
These are retained results, not checks rerun by this reconciliation.
[PR #98](https://github.com/Robinlee0929/Network_Automation_Lab/pull/98) subsequently
published the candidate; [post-merge Safe CI 42760192089](https://github.com/Robinlee0929/Network_Automation_Lab/actions/runs/42760192089)
completed successfully at the main merge SHA. Publication does not redefine
the Owner's fixed closure SHA.

The 18 npm-affected package groups, including Critical, remain unrepaired.
Seven Build Warnings and 13 Optional Missing reports remain open. This
documentation-only closure creates no security exemption or deployment-safety
claim. Next.js must receive separately authorized security remediation and
validation before restart or deployment.
FIX-04's [six Owner acceptance notes](actual_automation_integration_plan.md#stage-2-read-only-lab-adapter)
remain verbatim and unresolved. Stage 3, NAL Live, Root Activation, and
Approval Signing/Placement remain unauthorized. CLOSED is neither completed
deployment nor a claim of safe production operation.

## Historical decision summary — 2026-11-08

The following preparation-time snapshot is retained verbatim. Its present-tense
CLOSURE CANDIDATE and PENDING labels describe 2026-11-08, not current status.
The later decision above does not backfill historical review provenance.

Stage 2 is a **CLOSURE CANDIDATE**, not formally closed. The repository's
bounded S2-RO-01 through S2-RO-11 capability is complete; separate one-shot
Lab1 and Lab2 live proofs are accepted; and persistent Lab2 target and
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -61,6 +114,10 @@ authority. Those are distinct trust domains.

### Prospective reconciliation: 2026-11-08

This section preserves the preparation-time evidence, including all then-PENDING,
NOT_CREATED, and NOT_RUN values. CURRENT_* names below belong to that historical
snapshot; the current formal decision is recorded in the decision summary.

The Owner authorized a new six-file candidate from the committed base below.
The isolated candidate uses the committed Portfolio document; it does not
import the original worktree's unpublished Portfolio edits.
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -264,7 +321,10 @@ changed. These are historical local checks only, not the 2026-11-08 candidate's
validation or proof that the newly installed Node tree is identical to the
historical environment.

### Current candidate validation
### Historical candidate validation requirements — 2026-11-08

The following requirements and environment describe candidate preparation.
They do not request another validation run or reopen the completed closure.

The prospective candidate requires fresh focused target-registry/composition/
entrypoint tests, complete `tests/stage2`, full `python -m pytest`, and
Expand Down
Loading
Loading