Skip to content

Retain domestic forecast views across writes and restarts (#2850) - #2851

Open
hwanjjang wants to merge 6 commits into
fix/domestic-warm-cache-2819from
fix/forecast-cache-retention-2850
Open

Retain domestic forecast views across writes and restarts (#2850)#2851
hwanjjang wants to merge 6 commits into
fix/domestic-warm-cache-2819from
fix/forecast-cache-retention-2850

Conversation

@hwanjjang

@hwanjjang hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026 •
edited
Loading

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Forecast reads rebuilt folded views after unrelated writes, minute changes and process restarts. This change fences writers by key, retains views until selector boundaries, revalidates authoritative catalog identities within 30 seconds, and restores verified views from the existing bounded SSD cache. Request-local overlays and original S16 identities remain intact; disk files remain disposable.

Refs #2850. Stacked on #2841 at 307defeb (fix/domestic-warm-cache-2819); integrate that dependency first. This PR targets its branch. Requested endpoint is PR/review/CI completion, with no merge or deployment.

Start with server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs, then forecast_cache.rs (lifecycle), forecast_manifest.rs (identity), and forecast_disk.rs plus cache/disk.rs (persistence). Review the maintained Archify JSON rather than the 13,824-line generated HTML. The factory prose fixture prepares canonical weather once per reconstruction phase, retains both API-version oracles, and ends detached owners/pools at the runtime boundary. No runtime bound, dependency, production flag or legacy business logic changed.

Validation at 0c163912, candidate 7d0e891a…:

  • Exact-source fixture: 10/10 passed, all 40 national responses on attempt zero; full parallel runtime suite: 48 passed, 0 failed, 3 ignored. Five unattributed peer refusals remain a documented flake-risk signal; zero refusals is not claimed.
  • Fresh six-mode functional smoke preserves all 13 golden views and the original 42,549-byte HTTP hash. SSD restore/unchanged renewal perform no forecast descriptor/raw GET, parse or fold; a three-hour selector-boundary replay matches.
  • All-target Clippy with warnings denied, fmt, 7 Python checks, placement and staged/outgoing artifact checks pass. Outgoing completion ordering before push was not verified.
  • Prior 53 focused Rust checks and Linux domestic 177/0/2 are qualified reuse: the 11 runtime/test/tool files are byte-identical to c7d2. The older reader-disconnection negative control fails at the exact-prose assertion; its test bytes differ from the final fixture.

Claude Opus 5.5 and Grok 4.7 independently returned source PASS. All 14 current PR checks succeeded, including Linux CI39701583980 (foundation 33m41s). Linux domestic passed 177/0/2 and runtime_services passed 48/0/3, including both S16 own-acquisition and factory reconstruction regressions. CI-002 and CI-003 are resolved. Readiness applies to this stacked PR; no formal GitHub approval or merge authorization is implied. The task-owned Cargo target was cleaned; three retained-binary smoke modes passed after cleanup without rebuilding.

See selected evidence, operator contract, and behavior spec. Historical 66be97c8 loopback measurements restored 13 views in 141 ms using 31.70 MiB serialized data; these are not current EC2 capacity measurements. Full structured candidate/review records are preserved in PR comments beyond CI artifact expiry. Earlier failed runs, unknown base Capacity and the runtime-drop timing limitation remain recorded. No live S3/provider call, deployment or merge was performed.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Required independent review: PASS on d02699cc56cc06642a3b43dee81b6adce36ea9be against 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f.

Reviewer: separate OpenAI context /root/review_2850, host-selected GPT-6.1-Sol / medium, fallback slot3. Claude and Grok launch attempts were blocked by automatic approval review because third-party sharing authority was missing; no cross-provider review ran. Optional exact Gemini3.8 high was unavailable. Source hashes and clean working tree were verified after return. This is an agent review comment, not a GitHub human approval or merge authorization.

Required findings: none. Recommended OAI-001 (Low, tests at server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626): add deterministic new-latest-Mid-month and raw-load/final-identity race regressions. The reviewer found the implementation guards and reproduced no current defect. Author action: not selected; preserved as an optional recommendation, with no follow-up tracking or source change.

The reviewer inspected all21 changed paths and runtime/S16 boundaries, requirements, docs and retained golden/HTTP/disk evidence; directly ran7 Python checks, diff whitespace check and candidate/document hash comparison. Rust/smoke/browser results were inspected from author evidence, not rerun. No live service calls. CI readiness is still pending the foundation job. Full required verification/review receipts will be preserved in the final readiness comment; selected measurements are tracked here.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Readiness blocked by foundation CI39681558255: domestic173 passed,4 failed. Existing late-publication/concurrent-acquisition/backfill checks exposed an overly strict final view fence during same-key acquisition. The previous independent PASS applies to d02699c only and does not establish readiness.

The exact late-first-demand failure was reproduced with the owned loopback peer. Correction keeps active-writer reconstruction request-local with no complete S16 IDs or memory/SSD admission, and retries retired generations within the original caller deadline.16 corrected focused library checks pass; existing failed source regressions and full golden/HTTP/disk smoke are being rerun. A new frozen candidate will receive fresh Claude/Grok review after AK's explicit destination sharing approval. No merge/deployment/live provider or S3 call.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Required review — Claude Opus5.5 / medium: PASS on 66be97c896f6827b3e334d22e5b5ce231badf25f vs 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f (candidate2272b0f4). Separate context64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b; actual model/effective effort/plan mode verified from host. AK explicitly approved scoped repository/design/local-evidence sharing before launch.

Required: none. Recommended/Low: CLA-001, possible repeated read/fold cost under epoch churn until the original caller deadline; CLA-002, repeat the transient reconstruction rule explicitly in formal AC1. Neither produced a current defect. Author selects no change: original deadline and owner/CPU/workspace limits remain, and architecture/operator/design already state no complete IDs or memory/SSD admission. The existing spec defines admission and original deadlines. OAI-001 remains Recommended/Low/not selected. No follow-up issues or changes selected.

Claude verified all21 path declarations and committed source hashes, read the complete corrective diff and contextual fence/overlay callers, and confirmed active-writer partial results cannot enter canonical caches or carry complete S16 IDs. Unchanged module review scope reuses the earlier independent assessment; Claude did not deeply re-review codec/manifest/selectors or rerun tests/browser/CI. Source hashes and clean tree match after return. Actual cache integration count is9 (the returned prose said10); all52 current Rust checks are author execution evidence. Full structured review/verification receipts will be retained in final readiness evidence. This agent review is not a GitHub human approval or merge authorization.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Historical receipt archive for d02699c (superseded by66be97c8). This is evidence retention, not readiness: foundation CI39681558255 later found4 compatibility regressions. The exact failed checks and corrective outcome are recorded above. Original passing focused/smoke records and independent review remain revision-bound. These complete receipt texts are preserved here beyond disposable CI artifact expiry; current corrected receipts will be archived separately.

candidate.json — SHA-256 1f559d872cc4c7076c9a9f0b27c1a2c5dc32252893b92e4691e847ae855655ab 
{
  "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "runtime_and_verification_files": {
    "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs": "daff868598adfef4a64c45dd7588fbb2d3f2785965de2beebfabfc203d9bee22",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8",
    "server2/src/cache/disk.rs": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2",
    "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8",
    "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f",
    "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9",
    "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
  },
  "scope": "Runtime/test/tool/declaration bytes; maintained docs assessed separately in self-verification and final PR review."
}
candidate-commit.json — SHA-256 6c4c06a85ca85d35534b19d1808c6f1a325e54ef9f323474fd1f374db796aba9 
{
  "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
  "head": "d02699cc56cc06642a3b43dee81b6adce36ea9be",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "committed_source_hashes_match": true,
  "pr_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851",
  "staged_check": "Artifact policy passed for 21 intended files",
  "outgoing_check": "Artifact policy passed: 1 snapshot (307defeb..HEAD)",
  "working_tree_clean": true
}
self-verification-receipt.json — SHA-256 da52423f7d9dba321d36a308d49d8e631a692353fed8c224ea41766e90b1a49f 
{
  "iteration": 1,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "self-verification deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "4151cb2ca6116312ab080236c11506deb5d29daec61dcf01dee6cfd7adc9e42d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "1bdbf3546c642d9f54a2b1261038deca99da6602241b34641e59756c910b5bc3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation.md",
      "sha256": "8f4e068fa1c448895c48f02a7e693ad521157a0c8e61b400c1a5afd9202eb4a8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design.md",
      "sha256": "b6af0ac00681b1671dbfb38b6343afe9be4a7f182140f4f859dd8be1339cf96e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "af78dbf42accde8b3d1dcd15c0c68d8a4e4155540c8ad5869213f4cb1f7852da"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "057625982f266bb0cccbbb8bd2a6bc495a0532597374d86cc3fbf96b28f1a7bd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "daff868598adfef4a64c45dd7588fbb2d3f2785965de2beebfabfc203d9bee22"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "cdfec0f3e1aabf28e007d1d46d660fc9a9fa5a5e72bd06d994fc6582ea4aac8f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "3e11c3e6fd17f08958d65f3d325ba50d4233cd7cd92df6f04c008d52fa792d51"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "b780f378eaa8e3a5732b91561604bdcef856e671a000187aaf150ce569c93398"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v1.log",
      "sha256": "53da42c89935994bdcdc8d7b6cd15d535256032b5181ef7780fdbcd7ceba4f7d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-final.log",
      "sha256": "7f15d48b67307bbdaff409a273d9ad97d2a224360aca46bca299006731945e65"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression.log",
      "sha256": "43c286822a3ca45dff0f0a1a8bc773d0538622b11369750b21fa47a93be31b54"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-regression.log",
      "sha256": "85c1d48d7b91cd71d2c9c2b5b2ef4c66c00189b96799fb7d69aac8e6b9d565fa"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-final.log",
      "sha256": "9e69455877f7a4d5863ae29de80be3f4b216e96da21677b45bcf431b86591b03"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-final.log",
      "sha256": "f359edc69d8fbec80eda38df456e6874daa82a3348e8831fae83bb70ceb62f6e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-final.log",
      "sha256": "ae71512a2c3b726376e54e726b4fb5c01c39fd7aef498b82f35f5de6f8649c30"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-checker-final.log",
      "sha256": "1ad8a34b53fd9e91c1a985f8170b6574b0c7396979f591f1510447634f8a3c6b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-final.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed self-verification evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}
test-results.json — SHA-256 3e11c3e6fd17f08958d65f3d325ba50d4233cd7cd92df6f04c008d52fa792d51 
{
  "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
  "verification_mode": "tdd",
  "refactor_performed": true,
  "scenarios": [
    {
      "id": "M1",
      "requirement": "AC4",
      "required": true,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 release; owned IPv4 loopback S3 and native HTTP",
      "prerequisites": "Copied/hash-bound example; original730 acquisitions/851 pages; Off provider and no geocoder",
      "actions": "Run seed, complete13-view diagnostic and fresh native HTTP after focused checks",
      "expected": "All13 golden views and original42549B HTTP hash; children/listeners retire",
      "failure": "Changed response, missing golden, timeout, external call or leaked process",
      "cleanup": "Runner reaps all children and peer; evidence retained"
    },
    {
      "id": "M2",
      "requirement": "AC1",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Real cache/writer code with injected bounded dependencies",
      "prerequisites": "Two cached town keys and held writer/build futures",
      "actions": "Read unrelated key during acquisition, then abort/panic and overlap a build",
      "expected": "Same pin and zero counters; no stale flight/installation",
      "failure": "Global clearing, recycled live state or stale installation",
      "cleanup": "Test futures join/abort and cache dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M3",
      "requirement": "AC2",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Fixed clocks and full retained corpus",
      "prerequisites": "Golden pure selectors and existing source builders",
      "actions": "Cross minute and exact publication/retention/day/month/future/rewind boundaries",
      "expected": "Reuse only within interval; all13 answers equal reference replay",
      "failure": "Early refold or stale result at equality",
      "cleanup": "Owned peers/cache scopes retired"
    },
    {
      "id": "M4",
      "requirement": "AC3",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Owned catalog peer and final release example",
      "prerequisites": "Complete canonical scope and bounded30s policy",
      "actions": "Renew unchanged; publish newer same-partition acquisition; inject failed LIST",
      "expected": "Zero raw/descriptor/parse/fold unchanged, newer visible after delay, failed check not renewed",
      "failure": "LIST-only stale identity or expired fallback",
      "cleanup": "Peer and Sources dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M5",
      "requirement": "AC5",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Actual staged Git index and final docs",
      "prerequisites": "Exact path declaration and preserved generated metadata",
      "actions": "Check placement, source hashes, docs/diagram, fmt/Clippy and staged artifact policy",
      "expected": "Declared paths, resolvable links, current docs, no new runtime flag/dependency",
      "failure": "Undeclared implementation or generated output staged",
      "cleanup": "Checks read-only, no index/source mutation"
    }
  ],
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "R-key",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "307defeb+isolation-test",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib actual_writer_future_invalidates -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: unrelated Current view count0 instead of1",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-boundary",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-key-fences-before-boundary",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib selector_interval_crosses -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: arbitrary minute expired fold",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-renew",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-boundaries-before-renewal",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic unchanged_controls_renew -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: no real control LIST after bounded interval",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-disk",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-renewal-before-folded-disk",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic process_restart_restores_folded -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: restart parsed1 acquisition instead of0",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "F-corpus",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "python3 -B server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py --binary <copied-hash-bound-example> --output <smoke-v1> --build-variant release --modes seed diagnostic http disk http-disk disk-boundary",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "6 children0; all13 goldens, SSD restore/renew/boundary and original native HTTP bytes match",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v1.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "G-current",
      "phase": "green",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --locked --offline --lib forecast_ -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "15 focused current-candidate library checks pass",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "P-disk",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --locked --offline --lib cache::disk -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "8 shared raw/forecast disk ownership/capacity/fault regressions pass",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "P-summary",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --locked --offline --test domestic summary_s3 -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "10 S16 integrations including original own-acquisition identity pass",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-regression.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "S-http",
      "phase": "smoke",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "python3 -B server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py --binary <copied-hash-bound-example> --output <smoke-final> --build-variant release --modes seed diagnostic http",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Fresh peer and native Source after focused checks:3 children0,13/13 goldens and original HTTP hash",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "scenario_id": "M1"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-lint",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "cargo clippy --locked --offline --all-targets -- -D warnings",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "All targets pass with warnings denied",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-fmt",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "cargo fmt --check",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Formatting passes",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-python",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "python3 -B server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "7 actual checker controls pass",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-checker-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-placement",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "python3.11+ server2/tools/check_placement.py --root . --declaration server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json --base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Full placement/dependency/resource gate passes",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-artifacts",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "python3 scripts/check-artifact-policy.py --staged",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Actual index policy passes; no source/index mutation",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    }
  ],
  "earlier_failures": [
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/integration-retention.log",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "8/9; assertion used Doc root t1h instead of retained currentData.t1h; corrected oracle, release9/9 passed"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention-v2.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    }
  ]
}
documentation.json — SHA-256 b780f378eaa8e3a5732b91561604bdcef856e671a000187aaf150ce569c93398 
{
  "checked": true,
  "summary": "Transparent internal cache retention/restore optimization preserves every product API/CLI/UI operation and HTTP bytes. No new user workflow or feature surface; existing operator Markdown and architecture/Archify are updated and checked. README/API unchanged. No new screenshot PDF manual applies. Diagram artifact/actual Chrome and viewed light/dark captures passed; metadata preserved locally.",
  "new_feature": false,
  "ux_ui_changed": false,
  "updates": [
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/server2.md",
      "sha256": "2da2cf330dc67b29a373bcdb907cb6ab2fb2366a1b32c8e05b000bd1056c3899"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/operations/server2-domestic-cache.md",
      "sha256": "d28d6913b13190d16eda8da461d6eb75ce8323f0b0e7e65ebc612521eb707adc"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "4151cb2ca6116312ab080236c11506deb5d29daec61dcf01dee6cfd7adc9e42d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "1bdbf3546c642d9f54a2b1261038deca99da6602241b34641e59756c910b5bc3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/evidence/tasks/issue-2850/verification.md",
      "sha256": "8be4ed58d78e68164e075d24f0ddfe892fbac1d3a40de650626bda9a41031f38"
    }
  ],
  "manual": null
}
pr-review-receipt.json — SHA-256 6ffa8b1c94ad1492edb9db9ee19587437b8f113abbd20ade155789fa6bf2fdc5 
{
  "iteration": 1,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "Independent slot3 review PASS; no Required findings or remaining selected changes; optional recommendation not selected",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "4151cb2ca6116312ab080236c11506deb5d29daec61dcf01dee6cfd7adc9e42d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "1bdbf3546c642d9f54a2b1261038deca99da6602241b34641e59756c910b5bc3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation.md",
      "sha256": "8f4e068fa1c448895c48f02a7e693ad521157a0c8e61b400c1a5afd9202eb4a8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design.md",
      "sha256": "b6af0ac00681b1671dbfb38b6343afe9be4a7f182140f4f859dd8be1339cf96e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "af78dbf42accde8b3d1dcd15c0c68d8a4e4155540c8ad5869213f4cb1f7852da"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "057625982f266bb0cccbbb8bd2a6bc495a0532597374d86cc3fbf96b28f1a7bd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "daff868598adfef4a64c45dd7588fbb2d3f2785965de2beebfabfc203d9bee22"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "cdfec0f3e1aabf28e007d1d46d660fc9a9fa5a5e72bd06d994fc6582ea4aac8f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "3e11c3e6fd17f08958d65f3d325ba50d4233cd7cd92df6f04c008d52fa792d51"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "b780f378eaa8e3a5732b91561604bdcef856e671a000187aaf150ce569c93398"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v1.log",
      "sha256": "53da42c89935994bdcdc8d7b6cd15d535256032b5181ef7780fdbcd7ceba4f7d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-final.log",
      "sha256": "7f15d48b67307bbdaff409a273d9ad97d2a224360aca46bca299006731945e65"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression.log",
      "sha256": "43c286822a3ca45dff0f0a1a8bc773d0538622b11369750b21fa47a93be31b54"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-regression.log",
      "sha256": "85c1d48d7b91cd71d2c9c2b5b2ef4c66c00189b96799fb7d69aac8e6b9d565fa"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-final.log",
      "sha256": "9e69455877f7a4d5863ae29de80be3f4b216e96da21677b45bcf431b86591b03"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-final.log",
      "sha256": "f359edc69d8fbec80eda38df456e6874daa82a3348e8831fae83bb70ceb62f6e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-final.log",
      "sha256": "ae71512a2c3b726376e54e726b4fb5c01c39fd7aef498b82f35f5de6f8649c30"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-checker-final.log",
      "sha256": "1ad8a34b53fd9e91c1a985f8170b6574b0c7396979f591f1510447634f8a3c6b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-final.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "pr-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pr-review.md",
      "sha256": "e6b58debf9e9d62ebb89797025b0aa72b8a77aaacd13d4d93efea933d5f7fc59"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "885d3fbffd9c730681d39fd5133d54ddf95326548539c2e6f5aa51a4348f57db"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-launch",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-fallback-launch.json",
      "sha256": "33387b2aca24006de37a5cd37d8ed67009fa612854273c9e60727d0d5b9bc359"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-unavailable",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-dispatch-block.json",
      "sha256": "d4edab069fd78791886fe4ea2b54d5467cdb0cafcd62b7582fc2cdea33f01a68"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Assessed complete independent review scope, checks, settings and fallback observations. Source hashes and tree unchanged after return. No cross-provider execution claimed. CI is evaluated separately before readiness.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  },
  "review": {
    "author_provider": "openai",
    "provider": "openai",
    "model": "gpt-6.1-sol",
    "context_id": "/root/review_2850",
    "independent": true,
    "model_selection_source": "Actual exposed collaboration model catalog plus Paseo codex list_models: GPT-6.1-Sol latest workhorse, default; no preview marker",
    "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T21:54:53.808223+00:00",
    "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
    "effort": "medium",
    "requested_effort": "medium",
    "effort_verified": true,
    "effort_evidence": "Native collaboration spawn_agent accepted explicit model/reasoning_effort and created /root/review_2850",
    "requested_mode": null,
    "mode": null,
    "mode_verified": false,
    "builder_context_id": "/root",
    "author_account": "codex-current",
    "account": "codex-current",
    "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
    "head": "d02699cc56cc06642a3b43dee81b6adce36ea9be",
    "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
    "verdict": "PASS",
    "findings": [
      {
        "id": "OAI-001",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Verification",
        "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
        "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
        "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
        "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
        "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
        "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
      }
    ],
    "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6327461506",
    "record_id": "6327461506",
    "reviewer_slot": 3,
    "unavailable_reviewers": [
      {
        "reviewer_slot": 1,
        "provider": "anthropic",
        "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
        "reason": "Automatic approval review rejected private source/docs/evidence transfer without explicit destination sharing authority",
        "record": "reviewer-dispatch-block.json",
        "slot": 1,
        "account": "paseo-claude-default",
        "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-dispatch-block.json: exact automatic-review rejection, no context created"
      },
      {
        "reviewer_slot": 2,
        "provider": "xai",
        "model": "grok-4.7",
        "reason": "Automatic approval review rejected private source/docs/evidence transfer without explicit destination sharing authority",
        "record": "reviewer-dispatch-block.json",
        "slot": 2,
        "account": "paseo-grok-default",
        "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-dispatch-block.json: exact automatic-review rejection, no context created"
      }
    ],
    "author_changes_remaining": [],
    "read_only_required": false,
    "read_only_verified": false,
    "read_only_evidence": "Review-only assignment; enforced isolation not verified. Post-return runtime/test/tool/declaration hashes match candidate and git status is clean.",
    "self_reported_settings": "Exact model/effort not exposed in reviewer context; host accepted explicit native spawn overrides.",
    "reviewer_checks": [
      "Personally executed seven Python checker tests",
      "Personally executed git diff --check",
      "Personally matched candidate and maintained documentation hashes",
      "Inspected all21 changed paths, runtime and S16 call paths, original retained verification stdout"
    ],
    "limits": [
      "Rust tests and smoke not rerun by reviewer; author logs inspected",
      "No live S3/provider or browser rerun",
      "No CI result asserted by reviewer"
    ],
    "optional_reviewers": [
      {
        "provider": "xai",
        "model": "grok-4.7",
        "effort": "high",
        "status": "SKIPPED_AUTOMATIC_APPROVAL_REJECTION",
        "shared_required_slot": 2,
        "reason": "Explicit third-party sharing approval missing; no run or findings"
      },
      {
        "provider": "google",
        "model": "Gemini3.8 non-Flash",
        "effort": "high",
        "status": "SKIPPED_UNAVAILABLE",
        "reason": "Exact target absent from observed provider catalog; no substitution"
      }
    ]
  }
}
pr-review.md — SHA-256 e6b58debf9e9d62ebb89797025b0aa72b8a77aaacd13d4d93efea933d5f7fc59 
# Independent PR review — issue2850

Exact head d02699cc56cc06642a3b43dee81b6adce36ea9be; base307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f. Candidate sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9.

Verdict PASS from /root/review_2850, separate OpenAI context, native host-selected gpt-6.1-sol/medium. Reviewer self-observation could not expose model/effort; the actual accepted launch records them. Read-only enforcement is unverified, but source hashes and the clean tree were checked after return. No contributing author context was used as reviewer.

Both alternate-provider launch attempts were rejected by automatic approval review for missing explicit sharing authority to Anthropic/xAI. Slot3 follows the installed fallback rule and narrows review to the existing OpenAI environment. No third-party review ran. Grok optional role shares its rejected slot2 attempt; exact optional Gemini3.8 high was absent from the catalog.

The reviewer inspected requirements, scenarios and tests first, all21 changed paths, per-key writer epochs/RAII/ABA/final fences, selector/rewind/control-only renewal, complete searched months, bounded codec and shared cap/LRU, S16/overlay callers, tools/declaration and maintained docs/Archify JSON. GeneratedHTML was assessed through maintained JSON and matching artifact/browser evidence. Correctness/readability/architecture/security/performance were all assessed. No current blocking defect was found. Full structured finding, source locations, rationale, configuration and observations are in reviewer-configuration.json.

OAI-001 is Recommended/Low: deterministic tests for new latest-Mid-month discovery and a raw-load/final-identity race. Implementation defenses were found, but no directly pinned regression was found. Author selects no change because no current defect was reproduced and required coverage passes. This recommendation ends in this review record without follow-up issue or re-review.

Personally executed by reviewer:7 Python checker tests, git diff --check and source/document hash comparison. Rust15+8+9+10, Clippy/fmt/placement and golden/HTTP/disk timings were assessed from retained author logs, not independently rerun. Reviewer did not run browser, CI, real S3/provider or builds. No source/branch/evidence/permission changes or publication. Native returned final PASS retained in task conversation; this report preserves its complete scope, findings, reasoning, checks and limits. Current CI is assessed separately by coordinator before readiness.

Publication URL/ID: https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6327461506 /6327461506. No remaining author-selected changes.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Independent additional review — Grok 4.7 / xAI, host-observed high effort; separate context ba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754.

Head 66be97c896f6827b3e334d22e5b5ce231badf25f; base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f; candidate sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9. PASS: no Required findings and no new GROK findings. OAI-001 remains Recommended/Low, not selected; no follow-up.

Grok checked all21 declared paths/file hashes and five quality axes, including tests, corrective diff, generation/writer RAII, selector intervals, manifest renewal, bounded codec and shared disk ownership. It personally ran read-only git/hash inspection; 52Rust/7Python checks and smoke/browser records were author evidence, not reviewer reruns. Generated HTML was not bulk-read. Read-only enforcement was not verified.

Coordinator qualification: current foundation CI subsequently failed existing summary_s3::the_requests_own_acquisition_keeps_its_stored_identity (176passed/1failed/2ignored). This source review is retained but does not establish readiness; correction and a renewed review are required if source changes. Goldens passed. No merge.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026 •
edited
Loading

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Publication correction: displayed commands now use repository-relative paths instead of the private checkout prefix. Original local receipts and their original SHA256s are unchanged; changed blocks also give the displayed-copy SHA256. Candidate, results, findings and dispositions are unchanged.

Superseded66be97c8 full receipt archive (not readiness). Current source-review PASS preceded CI39685398826 own-acquisition S16 identity failure. Preserved beyond CI artifact expiration; renewed correction/review pending.

candidate.json — SHA256 cffd768819713944eabbc8d2fcf7b1789a090b0ead18c986b75398960b39ee69 
{
  "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "runtime_and_verification_files": {
    "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs": "bdc59a11e6dd5f31175c2acc1143621fe6b89d7c58dab81feec17811bfbe82e1",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8",
    "server2/src/cache/disk.rs": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2",
    "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8",
    "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f",
    "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9",
    "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
  },
  "scope": "Runtime/test/tool/declaration bytes; corrected active-writer reconstruction and bounded retired-flight retry. Docs assessed separately; original candidate retained under revision-v1."
}
candidate-commit.json — SHA256 b38c296c2b8383ffb6ab5edcfc939a67e46b0739b089da45ae5cacdcb6cace87 
{
  "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
  "head": "66be97c896f6827b3e334d22e5b5ce231badf25f",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "committed_source_hashes_match": true,
  "pr_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851",
  "working_tree_clean": true
}
self-verification-receipt.json — SHA256 2d5610886a195fe5e20d42bd14124f76077c2b522470bd77718b2fb89f858dea 
{
  "iteration": 3,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "self-verification deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "f43ba229cbf02a3d8c2a7e3914804058dabbd042d9ab7e6365109e71197b44ca"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "d00916c9131c5c195a8e1aa1daec2c0cdfdabdb9cac5bf7b68aed7ea45443c05"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "bdc59a11e6dd5f31175c2acc1143621fe6b89d7c58dab81feec17811bfbe82e1"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "44042f6b8f596012fce90ff5b235d04def6ee5a0893b00cbab7addbb8e46383c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "af5299170c139a2bd11d67b522d359497c0d7239a9ff906a0ca1999f1f2c1169"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "db08758324a2dc8c3f0bb6318e5a8ef461f484d7b28cf305ec69dcc3cc8d03a4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-green-final.log",
      "sha256": "15aef06ed52d5367a6c7a5003378f0768ad257f2df8a516844b6bf6685cccfb6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-publication-v2.log",
      "sha256": "0868edb4662bcaf5443edab57b472f378100209f04ab0a2be690ee10635a9184"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v2.log",
      "sha256": "25b67f27a287b7d21136f53045bf15d29720175a748966166799f5c3f545bcdf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-acquisition-v2.log",
      "sha256": "fcad485d1c8641390ccf98be073e17416c913ac9c6f649e835d7e43cd52bab24"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-integration-v2.log",
      "sha256": "a524dafd1c8e4fba1989974e71e685bbec9675d0e01e829ba3d1ae8ded3fd115"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v2.log",
      "sha256": "5382858ad60ae297221f8add7bc77b4d50eb9074c27fa6f3e8155ee26af36d15"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression-v2-final.log",
      "sha256": "a61eff48c3dc0892cf21b53a9a2a7572b00b719ac326dd40809d685fafd99aff"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v2-final.log",
      "sha256": "e3ffbedc9b6ddc8c4c8a629c3e71632a95c6a08f931a44f46a2bab60fd9a1bbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v2.log",
      "sha256": "d630d6bdb8eaed981046f383a4d81490740033d5b40b6f601be361f33191fab7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-checker-v2.log",
      "sha256": "2e5c788b6b78369ca5379b04024a2e5c407d9e72c64e83229aa3f70a59d4a8d4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v2-final.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-finalize-v6.log",
      "sha256": "1c292caf754e8398b08f2b92e161eae3ab82bf7033c05de9229c452d94e99bff"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v2.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v2.log",
      "sha256": "dc43d5c5786a79aea008511c03232d4b0b8efa1d1b0639e0000d83b76117d3a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v2-final.log",
      "sha256": "59ad19385c0d79ae28ec9c6fce67b2229b54bbbddeed27ed7eb6b35c16cf6bb4"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed self-verification evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}
test-results.json — original SHA256 af5299170c139a2bd11d67b522d359497c0d7239a9ff906a0ca1999f1f2c1169; displayed SHA256 0efb752f30c51c37f499fc9866822392e3d9d7ac7b318631734a495e8e78d714 
{
  "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
  "verification_mode": "tdd",
  "refactor_performed": true,
  "scenarios": [
    {
      "id": "M1",
      "requirement": "AC4",
      "required": true,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 release; owned IPv4 loopback S3 and native HTTP",
      "prerequisites": "Copied/hash-bound example; original730 acquisitions/851 pages; Off provider and no geocoder",
      "actions": "Run seed, complete13-view diagnostic and fresh native HTTP after focused checks",
      "expected": "All13 golden views and original42549B HTTP hash; children/listeners retire",
      "failure": "Changed response, missing golden, timeout, external call or leaked process",
      "cleanup": "Runner reaps all children and peer; evidence retained"
    },
    {
      "id": "M2",
      "requirement": "AC1",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Real cache/writer code with injected bounded dependencies",
      "prerequisites": "Two cached town keys and held writer/build futures",
      "actions": "Read unrelated key during acquisition, then abort/panic and overlap a build",
      "expected": "Same pin and zero counters; no stale flight/installation",
      "failure": "Global clearing, recycled live state or stale installation",
      "cleanup": "Test futures join/abort and cache dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M3",
      "requirement": "AC2",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Fixed clocks and full retained corpus",
      "prerequisites": "Golden pure selectors and existing source builders",
      "actions": "Cross minute and exact publication/retention/day/month/future/rewind boundaries",
      "expected": "Reuse only within interval; all13 answers equal reference replay",
      "failure": "Early refold or stale result at equality",
      "cleanup": "Owned peers/cache scopes retired"
    },
    {
      "id": "M4",
      "requirement": "AC3",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Owned catalog peer and final release example",
      "prerequisites": "Complete canonical scope and bounded30s policy",
      "actions": "Renew unchanged; publish newer same-partition acquisition; inject failed LIST",
      "expected": "Zero raw/descriptor/parse/fold unchanged, newer visible after delay, failed check not renewed",
      "failure": "LIST-only stale identity or expired fallback",
      "cleanup": "Peer and Sources dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M5",
      "requirement": "AC5",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Actual staged Git index and final docs",
      "prerequisites": "Exact path declaration and preserved generated metadata",
      "actions": "Check placement, source hashes, docs/diagram, fmt/Clippy and staged artifact policy",
      "expected": "Declared paths, resolvable links, current docs, no new runtime flag/dependency",
      "failure": "Undeclared implementation or generated output staged",
      "cleanup": "Checks read-only, no index/source mutation"
    }
  ],
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "R-key",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "307defeb+isolation-test",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib actual_writer_future_invalidates -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: unrelated Current view count0 instead of1",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-boundary",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-key-fences-before-boundary",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib selector_interval_crosses -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: arbitrary minute expired fold",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-renew",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-boundaries-before-renewal",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic unchanged_controls_renew -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: no real control LIST after bounded interval",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-disk",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-renewal-before-folded-disk",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic process_restart_restores_folded -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: restart parsed1 acquisition instead of0",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-CI-writer",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "cargo test --release --test domestic latest_short_late_first_demand_does_not_replay_missed_slots",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Existing source compatibility failure reproduced exactly: forecast view boundary during in-flight same-key acquisition",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "G-current-library",
      "phase": "green",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --lib forecast_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "16 passed incl real held-writer request-local incomplete identity/no admission and fresh rebuild after retired flight",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-green-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "P-late-publication-v2",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic latest_short_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "6 passed; original unchanged compatibility/cache/S16 assertions",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-publication-v2.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "P-backfill-v2",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic a_backfill_pass_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "2 passed; original unchanged compatibility/cache/S16 assertions",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v2.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "P-concurrent-acquisition-v2",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic concurrent_first_requests_share_one_acquisition_per_publication",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "1 passed; original unchanged compatibility/cache/S16 assertions",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-acquisition-v2.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "P-cache-integration-v2",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic forecast_cache::",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "9 passed; original unchanged compatibility/cache/S16 assertions",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-integration-v2.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "P-summary-v2",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic summary_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "10 passed; original unchanged compatibility/cache/S16 assertions",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v2.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "P-disk-shared",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --lib cache::disk::fault_tests",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "8 shared DiskCache fault/ownership/cap checks passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression-v2-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-clippy",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "cargo clippy --offline --locked --all-targets -- -D warnings",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "All targets pass with warnings denied",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v2-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-fmt",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "cargo fmt --all -- --check",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual exit0 captured as JSON",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v2.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-python",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "python3 -B -m unittest server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "7 pure controls pass",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-checker-v2.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-placement",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "python3 server2/tools/check_placement.py --root . --declaration server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json --base307defeb",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Declared ownership passes after generated metadata archived",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v2-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-archify",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "archify finalize workflow --quality showcase; visual-check --require-provenance",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Artifact/deliver/strict/actual Chrome PASS; visual captures separately generated and graph inspected",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-finalize-v6.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-artifacts",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "python3 scripts/check-artifact-policy.py --staged",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual six-file corrective index policy passes",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v2.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "M-full-v2",
      "phase": "smoke",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "python3 reports/sdlc/issue-2850/run-smoke-v2.py",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Six children0:13 original goldens cold/warm/restored/renewed and independent3h boundary replay; original HTTP hash with/without SSD; zero forecast raw/parse/fold on restore/renew; inputs unchanged/listeners retired",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v2.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "scenario_id": "M1"
    },
    {
      "id": "M-fresh-v2",
      "phase": "smoke",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "command": "domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py --modes seed diagnostic http",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Additional fresh three children0 after focused checks;13 original goldens and original42549B HTTP response hash; loopback peer retired",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v2-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "scenario_id": "M1"
    }
  ],
  "earlier_failures": [
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/integration-retention.log",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "8/9; assertion used Doc root t1h instead of retained currentData.t1h; corrected oracle, release9/9 passed"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention-v2.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-foundation-failed.log",
      "observed": "Original full CI173passed/4failed; exact four compatibility cases pass in corrected runs above; old independent PASS is revision-bound"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-local.log",
      "observed": "Sandbox peer bind denied; setup failure, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-green.log",
      "observed": "Explicit-drop MutexGuard across await compile error; fixed with lexical scope"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-final.log",
      "observed": "Cross-module test NOW/until compile error; corrected test scope"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-final2.log",
      "observed": "Test transport was intentionally unreachable; moved held-writer reconstruction to Empty transport regression"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression-v2.log",
      "observed": "Filter selected zero checks; not credited; correct fault_tests filter passed8"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v2.log",
      "observed": "Generated delivery sidecar outside declaration; archived with matching hash in .archify recovery-v6 before final placement check"
    }
  ]
}
documentation.json — SHA256 db08758324a2dc8c3f0bb6318e5a8ef461f484d7b28cf305ec69dcc3cc8d03a4 
{
  "checked": true,
  "summary": "Transparent internal cache retention/restore optimization preserves every product API/CLI/UI operation and HTTP bytes. No new user workflow or feature surface; existing operator Markdown and architecture/Archify are updated and checked. README/API unchanged. No new screenshot PDF manual applies. Diagram artifact/actual Chrome and viewed light/dark captures passed; metadata preserved locally.",
  "new_feature": false,
  "ux_ui_changed": false,
  "updates": [
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/server2.md",
      "sha256": "7ef7a1fa0e181a3f50342e0effe0e5689721ea0b8a39dc58849e5ac158561121"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/operations/server2-domestic-cache.md",
      "sha256": "e6c49e800df20a1b216752c3119407d508a0d5176c04d628b361990f3c49387c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/evidence/tasks/issue-2850/verification.md",
      "sha256": "7d46f8eb59139a4677c50afcd64ef45e2b19bc3c6565ade15b0a40ff72d7b7c7"
    }
  ],
  "manual": null,
  "correction_note": "Current docs describe transient reconstruction during active writer and deadline-bounded rejoin. Archify v6 automatic/browser/capture checks pass; root viewed1440light/2048dark canvas; added below-fold card text checked through source and automated DOM, not claimed perceptually viewed. Selected evidence binds corrected candidate and52Rust checks."
}
pr-review-receipt.json — SHA256 b31f91bfa2169b547539bc843d4caba4255227f77e3195f1c823efc9a7b642df 
{
  "iteration": 2,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "pr-review deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "f43ba229cbf02a3d8c2a7e3914804058dabbd042d9ab7e6365109e71197b44ca"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "d00916c9131c5c195a8e1aa1daec2c0cdfdabdb9cac5bf7b68aed7ea45443c05"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "bdc59a11e6dd5f31175c2acc1143621fe6b89d7c58dab81feec17811bfbe82e1"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "44042f6b8f596012fce90ff5b235d04def6ee5a0893b00cbab7addbb8e46383c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "af5299170c139a2bd11d67b522d359497c0d7239a9ff906a0ca1999f1f2c1169"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "db08758324a2dc8c3f0bb6318e5a8ef461f484d7b28cf305ec69dcc3cc8d03a4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-green-final.log",
      "sha256": "15aef06ed52d5367a6c7a5003378f0768ad257f2df8a516844b6bf6685cccfb6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-publication-v2.log",
      "sha256": "0868edb4662bcaf5443edab57b472f378100209f04ab0a2be690ee10635a9184"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v2.log",
      "sha256": "25b67f27a287b7d21136f53045bf15d29720175a748966166799f5c3f545bcdf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-acquisition-v2.log",
      "sha256": "fcad485d1c8641390ccf98be073e17416c913ac9c6f649e835d7e43cd52bab24"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-integration-v2.log",
      "sha256": "a524dafd1c8e4fba1989974e71e685bbec9675d0e01e829ba3d1ae8ded3fd115"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v2.log",
      "sha256": "5382858ad60ae297221f8add7bc77b4d50eb9074c27fa6f3e8155ee26af36d15"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression-v2-final.log",
      "sha256": "a61eff48c3dc0892cf21b53a9a2a7572b00b719ac326dd40809d685fafd99aff"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v2-final.log",
      "sha256": "e3ffbedc9b6ddc8c4c8a629c3e71632a95c6a08f931a44f46a2bab60fd9a1bbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v2.log",
      "sha256": "d630d6bdb8eaed981046f383a4d81490740033d5b40b6f601be361f33191fab7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-checker-v2.log",
      "sha256": "2e5c788b6b78369ca5379b04024a2e5c407d9e72c64e83229aa3f70a59d4a8d4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v2-final.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-finalize-v6.log",
      "sha256": "1c292caf754e8398b08f2b92e161eae3ab82bf7033c05de9229c452d94e99bff"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v2.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v2.log",
      "sha256": "dc43d5c5786a79aea008511c03232d4b0b8efa1d1b0639e0000d83b76117d3a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v2-final.log",
      "sha256": "59ad19385c0d79ae28ec9c6fce67b2229b54bbbddeed27ed7eb6b35c16cf6bb4"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "pr-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pr-review.md",
      "sha256": "850f4c287710fd9a4fe0be4fe309946d1f783e9af980b74a513d1f41dfe257a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "fef4a8cd73678caa1c5eb692e79e9e46a4e069a9f0435fcb64d826ffb0e662e1"
    },
    {
      "kind": "additional-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "bc6f9a34b858d127a6480f54ed878c57eefeebfd6bbdb9cf32467c916b44cd72"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-review-return.md",
      "sha256": "c0f0a401225a454b4ae8469c9b9cc6210bbb1734025e1063bc89f0fda636ceb0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-review-return.md",
      "sha256": "13cba5696aa88c6950d5d4b70aca959446f3c679d3c7769269a76f5ff45f0d35"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-execution",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-v2-execution.json",
      "sha256": "779de6cdd05b3f424f4f99c0ac8be006a283857efbf71a443708476599ff3d30"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed pr-review evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  },
  "review": {
    "author_provider": "openai",
    "provider": "anthropic",
    "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
    "context_id": "64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b",
    "independent": true,
    "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
    "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
    "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
    "effort": "medium",
    "requested_effort": "medium",
    "effort_verified": true,
    "requested_mode": "plan",
    "mode": "plan",
    "mode_verified": true,
    "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
    "author_account": "codex-current",
    "account": "paseo-claude-default",
    "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
    "head": "66be97c896f6827b3e334d22e5b5ce231badf25f",
    "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
    "verdict": "PASS",
    "findings": [
      {
        "id": "OAI-001",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Verification",
        "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
        "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
        "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
        "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
        "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
        "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-001",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Correctness/performance",
        "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
        "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
        "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
        "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
        "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
        "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
        "confidence": "medium",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-002",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Documentation",
        "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
        "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
        "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
        "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
        "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
        "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
      }
    ],
    "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6327849481",
    "record_id": "6327849481",
    "reviewer_slot": 1,
    "unavailable_reviewers": [],
    "author_changes_remaining": [],
    "read_only_required": false,
    "read_only_verified": false,
    "read_only_evidence": "Host plan mode observed, boundary enforcement not verified. Native Claude plan file created as returned review output; copied with matching bytes into task evidence. Runtime source hashes and clean tracked tree verified after return.",
    "runtime_session": "5b7058e6-94bc-492f-90f8-68abb67f4025",
    "review_scope": "Full21-path declaration/hash review and complete corrective diff; contextual epoch/writer/build/restore/renewal/overlay callers/spec. Deep unchanged codec/manifest/selector assessment reused from original independent OAI-001 review on exact unchanged module hashes.",
    "verification_limits": [
      "No tests/build/smoke/browser/CI independently rerun by Claude",
      "GeneratedHTML not read; maintainedJSON and existing evidence referenced",
      "Self-effort unavailable; host snapshot independently verifies medium",
      "Reviewer reported cache integration count10; actual retained log is9, coordinator reconciled without inventing execution"
    ]
  },
  "optional_reviews": [
    {
      "author_provider": "openai",
      "provider": "xai",
      "model": "grok-4.7",
      "context_id": "ba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754",
      "independent": true,
      "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
      "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
      "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
      "effort": "high",
      "requested_effort": "high",
      "effort_verified": true,
      "requested_mode": null,
      "mode": null,
      "mode_verified": false,
      "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
      "author_account": "codex-current",
      "account": "paseo-grok-default",
      "candidate": "sha256:2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9",
      "head": "66be97c896f6827b3e334d22e5b5ce231badf25f",
      "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "findings": [
        {
          "id": "OAI-001",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Verification",
          "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
          "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
          "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
          "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
          "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
          "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
        }
      ],
      "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6328033454",
      "record_id": "6328033454",
      "reviewer_slot": null,
      "unavailable_reviewers": [],
      "author_changes_remaining": [],
      "read_only_required": false,
      "read_only_verified": false,
      "read_only_evidence": "Explicit review-only assignment and Claude plan/Grok existing permissions observed; enforcement across filesystem/network not separately verified. Post-return source hash comparison required.",
      "runtime_session": "01a1608b-009d-7820-b31c-f4aa90688478",
      "review_scope": "All21-path declaration/hash review; tests first; corrective diff plus epoch, writer RAII, selector, 30s renewal, manifest, codec and shared DiskCache directly inspected",
      "verification_limits": [
        "No Cargo/tests/build/smoke/browser/live S3/provider/CI independently executed",
        "Read-only git/hash commands personally executed; retained author logs inspected",
        "Host high effort observed; self-effort unavailable; enforced read-only mode unknown"
      ]
    }
  ]
}
pr-review.md — SHA256 850f4c287710fd9a4fe0be4fe309946d1f783e9af980b74a513d1f41dfe257a2 
# Corrected candidate independent review (attempt2)

Head66be97c896f6827b3e334d22e5b5ce231badf25f; base307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f; candidate2272b0f4d6c4b92fd8fa59fd3c99856fe44822b1ead40471749e9679e7b97ba9.
Required Claude Opus5.5, medium, separate64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b: PASS, comment6327849481. Optional Grok4.7, high, separateba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754: PASS, comment6328033454. Actual host model/effort snapshots retained; mode/read-only limitations in configurations. Both ran after explicit AK Anthropic/xAI source/design/evidence sharing approval.
Claude inspected all21 declarations/hashes and corrective diff with contextual fences/overlay; unchanged deep codec/manifest/selector scope reused prior independent review. Grok directly inspected those modules plus tests first and all five axes. Neither executed Cargo/smoke/browser or observed CI; retained logs assessed. Grok personally ran git/hash commands; only allow-once for bounded read commands, no persistent permission change.
OAI-001, CLA-001, CLA-002 all Recommended/Low, not-selected with specific responses in required configuration; no tracking or selected changes. Reviewer count10 cache discrepancy reconciled to actual9. No Required findings. No source changes since review. Both raw returns preserved.
Coordinator subsequent CI39685398826 FAILED: existing own-acquisition S16 identity test (176pass,1fail,2ignored); source PASS is not readiness. New repair will stale this candidate and require renewed review. Exact local release test passed1/1; scheduling-dependent hypothesis pending deterministic test. No merge.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026 •
edited
Loading

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Publication correction: displayed commands now use repository-relative paths instead of the private checkout prefix. Original local receipts and their original SHA256s are unchanged; changed blocks also give the displayed-copy SHA256. Candidate, results, findings and dispositions are unchanged.

Current c7d2a5d verification receipts (independent re-review / full Linux CI still pending; no readiness claim). Candidate sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab. Full raw receipts retained here beyond CI artifact expiry. Local full-suite transport failures are recorded, not relabeled passing;53focused Rust,7Python and6child real smoke pass.

candidate.json — SHA256 c09e116fa9f876c500f2749d16453fdbe2efd46247a314a5411309af685752fe 
{
  "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "runtime_and_verification_files": {
    "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8",
    "server2/src/cache/disk.rs": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2",
    "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8",
    "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f",
    "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9",
    "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
  },
  "scope": "Runtime/test/tool/declaration bytes; preserves immutable request-local overlay completeness independently of concurrent backfill; canonical gates unchanged. Prior candidates retained revision-v1/revision-v2."
}
candidate-commit.json — SHA256 b517b98935550a581fa12a58a2e65edc12f99e961b0610c742142a5f072a402b 
{
  "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
  "head": "c7d2a5d2adffba7fa25f85008632743941731879",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "committed_source_hashes_match": true,
  "working_tree_clean": true,
  "pr_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851"
}
self-verification-receipt.json — SHA256 e417af64d7d21266e5ac1ffcb514f44d490e54083089669c09c9fc9f764ec66e 
{
  "iteration": 4,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "self-verification deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "962a8153377498b6c92e580ed924443c5f6169ef57bcaeead68ff37dda27ce80"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "7b607c253a84011d73c6d6692ea13426f6147674f25b63daa6437e1144798e37"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "33cb0f2600eec0b402f80941c0923c0f4fb3a3af9060bdf691e47d4deb9774c5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "f4a7dfac3283fa81ab30daa4d46b48db451c23ee9c49717cf56af5bee7aa8302"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "cf27c2537093c90b04998ef440df0e3cfb8116d1935252f469de55b9960e2d36"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/domestic-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bb0b2141e76063af7e7159520288080424a61407555ad7330c5524fa32102c6a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/domestic-v3-serial.log",
      "sha256": "0b265fdc2cdf45b8f42a38149f0fee3ca2acad8b08d84eda1ba4667c9b5eb2c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed self-verification evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}
test-results.json — original SHA256 f4a7dfac3283fa81ab30daa4d46b48db451c23ee9c49717cf56af5bee7aa8302; displayed SHA256 b6861b84eec3dde3a56d09c0f320225c80459be817ffcf7c4d8fbdfdee56579c 
{
  "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
  "verification_mode": "tdd",
  "refactor_performed": true,
  "scenarios": [
    {
      "id": "M1",
      "requirement": "AC4",
      "required": true,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 release; owned IPv4 loopback S3 and native HTTP",
      "prerequisites": "Copied/hash-bound example; original730 acquisitions/851 pages; Off provider and no geocoder",
      "actions": "Run seed, complete13-view diagnostic and fresh native HTTP after focused checks",
      "expected": "All13 golden views and original42549B HTTP hash; children/listeners retire",
      "failure": "Changed response, missing golden, timeout, external call or leaked process",
      "cleanup": "Runner reaps all children and peer; evidence retained"
    },
    {
      "id": "M2",
      "requirement": "AC1",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Real cache/writer code with injected bounded dependencies",
      "prerequisites": "Two cached town keys and held writer/build futures",
      "actions": "Read unrelated key during acquisition, then abort/panic and overlap a build",
      "expected": "Same pin and zero counters; no stale flight/installation",
      "failure": "Global clearing, recycled live state or stale installation",
      "cleanup": "Test futures join/abort and cache dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M3",
      "requirement": "AC2",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Fixed clocks and full retained corpus",
      "prerequisites": "Golden pure selectors and existing source builders",
      "actions": "Cross minute and exact publication/retention/day/month/future/rewind boundaries",
      "expected": "Reuse only within interval; all13 answers equal reference replay",
      "failure": "Early refold or stale result at equality",
      "cleanup": "Owned peers/cache scopes retired"
    },
    {
      "id": "M4",
      "requirement": "AC3",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Owned catalog peer and final release example",
      "prerequisites": "Complete canonical scope and bounded30s policy",
      "actions": "Renew unchanged; publish newer same-partition acquisition; inject failed LIST",
      "expected": "Zero raw/descriptor/parse/fold unchanged, newer visible after delay, failed check not renewed",
      "failure": "LIST-only stale identity or expired fallback",
      "cleanup": "Peer and Sources dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M5",
      "requirement": "AC5",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Actual staged Git index and final docs",
      "prerequisites": "Exact path declaration and preserved generated metadata",
      "actions": "Check placement, source hashes, docs/diagram, fmt/Clippy and staged artifact policy",
      "expected": "Declared paths, resolvable links, current docs, no new runtime flag/dependency",
      "failure": "Undeclared implementation or generated output staged",
      "cleanup": "Checks read-only, no index/source mutation"
    }
  ],
  "earlier_failures": [
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/integration-retention.log",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "8/9; assertion used Doc root t1h instead of retained currentData.t1h; corrected oracle, release9/9 passed"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention-v2.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-foundation-failed.log",
      "observed": "Original full CI173passed/4failed; exact four compatibility cases pass in corrected runs above; old independent PASS is revision-bound"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-local.log",
      "observed": "Sandbox peer bind denied; setup failure, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-green.log",
      "observed": "Explicit-drop MutexGuard across await compile error; fixed with lexical scope"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-final.log",
      "observed": "Cross-module test NOW/until compile error; corrected test scope"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-final2.log",
      "observed": "Test transport was intentionally unreachable; moved held-writer reconstruction to Empty transport regression"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression-v2.log",
      "observed": "Filter selected zero checks; not credited; correct fault_tests filter passed8"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v2.log",
      "observed": "Generated delivery sidecar outside declaration; archived with matching hash in .archify recovery-v6 before final placement check"
    }
  ],
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "R-key",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "307defeb+isolation-test",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib actual_writer_future_invalidates -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: unrelated Current view count0 instead of1",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-boundary",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-key-fences-before-boundary",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib selector_interval_crosses -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: arbitrary minute expired fold",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-renew",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-boundaries-before-renewal",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic unchanged_controls_renew -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: no real control LIST after bounded interval",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-disk",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-renewal-before-folded-disk",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic process_restart_restores_folded -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: restart parsed1 acquisition instead of0",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-CI-writer",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "cargo test --release --test domestic latest_short_late_first_demand_does_not_replay_missed_slots",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Existing source compatibility failure reproduced exactly: forecast view boundary during in-flight same-key acquisition",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-overlay",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "66be97c8+overlay-regression-test",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --lib overlay_preserves_complete_parent_identity_during_same_key_backfill",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Expected assertion failure: complete immutable parent lost completeness under held same-key writer",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "G-overlay-module",
      "phase": "green",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --lib domestic::kma::source::forecast",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "16 passed, including complete overlay parent and partial-parent/no-admission controls",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-clippy-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh clippy --offline --locked --all-targets -- -D warnings",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-fmt-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh fmt --all -- --check",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-example-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh build --release --offline --locked --example domestic_warm_cache_smoke",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-unit-v3-final",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --lib forecast_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "17passed including unchanged Mid compatibility and new overlay regression",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-late-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic latest_short_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "6passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-backfill-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic a_backfill_pass_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "2passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-concurrent-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic concurrent_first_requests_share_one_acquisition_per_publication",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "1passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-cache-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic forecast_cache::",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "9passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-summary-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic summary_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "10passed including unchanged own-acquisition S16 identity",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-disk-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "sh reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --lib cache::disk::fault_tests",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "8 shared DiskCache checks passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-python-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 -B -m unittest server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "7 Python checks passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-placement-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 server2/tools/check_placement.py --root . --declaration server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json --base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "M-full-v3",
      "phase": "smoke",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 -B server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py --binary reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin-v3/domestic_warm_cache_smoke --output reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3 --build-variant release --modes seed diagnostic http disk http-disk disk-boundary",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Six children exit0; 13original goldens, original42549B HTTP hash, restore/renew0raw/parse/fold and independent3h replay preserved",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "scenario_id": "M1"
    },
    {
      "id": "V-staged-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "python3 scripts/check-artifact-policy.py --staged",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Actual two-file staged index",
      "observed": "PASS; intended staged source and maintained evidence only",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    }
  ],
  "retained_failed_runs": [
    {
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --test domestic",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "148pass/29fail/2ignored; predominantly local publish/seed Transport/Ambiguous across unrelated modules. Serial scheduling also failed140pass/37fail/2ignored, predominantly publish/seed Transport.24283TIME_WAIT peak; no test assertions or OS settings changed. Separate serial log retained.",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/domestic-v3.log"
    }
  ],
  "exact_original_reproduction": "Original CI own-acquisition test passed locally once before correction; deterministic Red comes from held-writer overlay test, not that complete scenario."
}
documentation.json — SHA256 cf27c2537093c90b04998ef440df0e3cfb8116d1935252f469de55b9960e2d36 
{
  "checked": true,
  "summary": "Transparent internal cache retention/restore optimization preserves every product API/CLI/UI operation and HTTP bytes. No new user workflow or feature surface; existing operator Markdown and architecture/Archify are updated and checked. README/API unchanged. No new screenshot PDF manual applies. Diagram artifact/actual Chrome and viewed light/dark captures passed; metadata preserved locally.",
  "new_feature": false,
  "ux_ui_changed": false,
  "updates": [
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/server2.md",
      "sha256": "7ef7a1fa0e181a3f50342e0effe0e5689721ea0b8a39dc58849e5ac158561121"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/operations/server2-domestic-cache.md",
      "sha256": "e6c49e800df20a1b216752c3119407d508a0d5176c04d628b361990f3c49387c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/evidence/tasks/issue-2850/verification.md",
      "sha256": "c675c7014bbb52aa973c9577a0fe5901cd446391a80cb8ca467ac30a6ea3f528"
    }
  ],
  "manual": null,
  "correction_note": "Overlay repair restores existing immutable-parent identity contract. Unchanged diagram/operator/architecture hashes and actual Archifyv6 evidence reused. Selected evidence labels old measurement run and new repair. No new user-facing feature/UX."
}

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Independent required re-review — Claude Opus5.5 / Anthropic, host-verified medium effort, separate context64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b.

Head c7d2a5d2adffba7fa25f85008632743941731879; base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f; candidate sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab. PASS, full Linux CI still pending.

Required — CI-002 / High / resolved in source and focused tests: final canonical fence incorrectly removed immutable request-local overlay S16 IDs during same-key backfill. Restricting downgrade to non-overlay construction restores base behavior. Complete parent IDs survive; partial parent stays incomplete; all overlays remain excluded from memory/SSD, canonical writer/epoch/control gates unchanged. Deterministic held-writer Red101 then Green, original own-acquisition integration10/10 passed. Claude personally verified the two-file diff, relevant gates/RAII/base behavior,21declared paths and12committedhashes, and read actual Red,unit17,summary10 logs. Other reported checks were coordinator evidence, not reviewer execution.19unchanged paths reuse prior actual reviews.

Recommended — OAI-001, CLA-001, CLA-002 / Low: unchanged, not selected, no follow-up. Author reasons remain in prior attributed review and current configuration.

Limits: no Cargo/smoke/Python/Clippy/browser/CI run by reviewer; enforced read-only boundary not verified (plan mode observed). Local full-suite failures remain failures; port exhaustion hypothesis unproven. Red panic line1738 versus final1746 reflects rustfmt line expansion and comments; assertion unchanged, no final-form Red rerun claimed. Linux complete CI, especially original S16 case, must pass before readiness. No GitHub approval/merge.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Independent additional re-review — Grok4.7 / xAI, host-verified high effort, separate contextba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754.

Head c7d2a5d2adffba7fa25f85008632743941731879; base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f; candidate sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab. PASS.

Required — CI-002 / resolved: final canonical fence previously stripped complete request-local overlay S16 identity during same-key backfill. The repair preserves immutable parent identity while partial parents stay partial; canonical writer/epoch/control/restore/renewal gates and overlay exclusion from memory/SSD remain. Grok inspected new complete/partial-parent test, original own-acquisition assertion/caller and relevant gates; independently recalculated12candidate hashes, confirmed21declared paths,clean head/base and two-file diff.19unchanged paths reuse prior full review. No new GROK findings.

Recommended — OAI-001, CLA-001, CLA-002 / Low: unchanged and not selected, no follow-up.

Grok read author logs showing53Rust/7Python,Clippy/fmt/placement/artifact and6childsmoke success; personally ran read-only git/hash inspection, no Cargo/smoke/browser/provider/CI execution. Full local normal/serial failures remain failures; TIME_WAIT peak supports an unproven port-resource hypothesis. Host high effort observed; self-effort/mode and enforced read-only boundary unavailable. Linux full CI pending: this is source review, not GitHub approval or readiness/merge authorization.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Current c7d2a5d independent review/correction receipts. Claude6328373974 and Grok6328398007 PASS; CI-002Required resolved in source/focused tests,3Lowrecommendations not selected. Full LinuxCI still pending, no readiness claim. Verification receipts: #2851 (comment)

pr-review-receipt.json — SHA256 eeed1bb4878d583076ced6a330815bd9e6d408a55c86d6db5aef45e017aded42 
{
  "iteration": 3,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "pr-review deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "962a8153377498b6c92e580ed924443c5f6169ef57bcaeead68ff37dda27ce80"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "7b607c253a84011d73c6d6692ea13426f6147674f25b63daa6437e1144798e37"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "33cb0f2600eec0b402f80941c0923c0f4fb3a3af9060bdf691e47d4deb9774c5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "f4a7dfac3283fa81ab30daa4d46b48db451c23ee9c49717cf56af5bee7aa8302"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "cf27c2537093c90b04998ef440df0e3cfb8116d1935252f469de55b9960e2d36"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/domestic-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bb0b2141e76063af7e7159520288080424a61407555ad7330c5524fa32102c6a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/domestic-v3-serial.log",
      "sha256": "0b265fdc2cdf45b8f42a38149f0fee3ca2acad8b08d84eda1ba4667c9b5eb2c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "pr-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pr-review.md",
      "sha256": "ee751f025c8501749cc5ede6d374458b42d6007b3b623826b24d4a4e1d46a99c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "1f3a739f9f4c6e70fcb5744e019cb7bffdc5311bdc67f1dd3eef997a9d0e4e19"
    },
    {
      "kind": "additional-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-reviewer-configuration-v3.json",
      "sha256": "a847e3fd3d5f6963aa94f39db8b2cac1d94e0ede669891bb1a02fc1884ff8df5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-review-return-v3.md",
      "sha256": "338aab8afca98cb4b207be26e98c71ab7456e25f494f4c8b6f9354806927e7cd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-review-return-v3.md",
      "sha256": "6b96d892f3810c867fd0621ca7b8376cf150d9f2c4c15d631fce0a9338dc0ef4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-v3-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "4d3a92384e17e5f51b078465997a48727f0c05caa3f43f9546f2f0be91e8336f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-v3-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "adfc1f9ccc6f920fb27acd5aa8e7a95e4032a62ea40413936097d948ac453e47"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed pr-review evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  },
  "review": {
    "author_provider": "openai",
    "provider": "anthropic",
    "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
    "context_id": "64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b",
    "independent": true,
    "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
    "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
    "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
    "effort": "medium",
    "requested_effort": "medium",
    "effort_verified": true,
    "requested_mode": "plan",
    "mode": "plan",
    "mode_verified": true,
    "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
    "author_account": "codex-current",
    "account": "paseo-claude-default",
    "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
    "head": "c7d2a5d2adffba7fa25f85008632743941731879",
    "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
    "verdict": "PASS",
    "findings": [
      {
        "id": "OAI-001",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Verification",
        "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
        "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
        "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
        "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
        "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
        "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-001",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Correctness/performance",
        "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
        "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
        "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
        "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
        "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
        "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
        "confidence": "medium",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-002",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Documentation",
        "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
        "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
        "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
        "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
        "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
        "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
      },
      {
        "id": "CI-002",
        "classification": "required",
        "severity": "HIGH",
        "category": "Correctness",
        "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
        "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
        "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
        "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
        "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
        "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "fixed",
        "author_action": "applied",
        "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
        "resolved": true,
        "reviewer_resolution": "Claude explicitly reclassified CI-002 Required/High correctness regression and confirmed this source/focused-test repair resolves it; full LinuxCI remains independent readiness gate."
      }
    ],
    "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6328373974",
    "record_id": "6328373974",
    "reviewer_slot": 1,
    "unavailable_reviewers": [],
    "author_changes_remaining": [],
    "read_only_required": false,
    "read_only_verified": false,
    "read_only_evidence": "Host plan mode observed, boundary enforcement not verified. Native Claude plan file created as returned review output; copied with matching bytes into task evidence. Runtime source hashes and clean tracked tree verified after return.",
    "runtime_session": "5b7058e6-94bc-492f-90f8-68abb67f4025",
    "review_scope": "Full21path declarations and12committedhashes; entire2file corrective diff/new test; contextual finalcanonical gate/join/RAII and originalbase overlay behavior.19unchanged paths reuse prior actual reviews.",
    "verification_limits": [
      "Personally inspected git hashes, scope/diff and related source plus actual overlayRed,unit17,summary10 logs, diagnosis",
      "No Cargo/Python/Clippy/smoke/browser/CI independently executed",
      "Other receipts/logs not opened in current review: counts main verified, no reviewer execution claim",
      "Red line shift1738to1746 is rustfmt-expanded overlay expression plus runtime comments; assertion unchanged; no final-form Red rerun claimed",
      "Localfullnormal148pass29fail andserial140pass37fail remain failures; port hypothesis not independently proved",
      "Push-after range check not independently read; no beforepush range PASS claim"
    ]
  },
  "optional_reviews": [
    {
      "author_provider": "openai",
      "provider": "xai",
      "model": "grok-4.7",
      "context_id": "ba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754",
      "independent": true,
      "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
      "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
      "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
      "effort": "high",
      "requested_effort": "high",
      "effort_verified": true,
      "requested_mode": null,
      "mode": null,
      "mode_verified": false,
      "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
      "author_account": "codex-current",
      "account": "paseo-grok-default",
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "head": "c7d2a5d2adffba7fa25f85008632743941731879",
      "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "findings": [
        {
          "id": "OAI-001",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Verification",
          "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
          "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
          "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
          "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
          "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
          "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
        },
        {
          "id": "CLA-001",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Correctness/performance",
          "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
          "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
          "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
          "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
          "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
          "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
          "confidence": "medium",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
        },
        {
          "id": "CLA-002",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Documentation",
          "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
          "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
          "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
          "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
          "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
          "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
        },
        {
          "id": "CI-002",
          "classification": "required",
          "severity": "HIGH",
          "category": "Correctness",
          "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
          "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
          "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
          "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
          "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
          "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "fixed",
          "author_action": "applied",
          "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
          "resolved": true,
          "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok explicitly confirm CI-002 Required correctness regression resolved by this immutable-parent overlay repair and focused tests; LinuxCI still separate mandatory gate."
        }
      ],
      "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6328398007",
      "record_id": "6328398007",
      "reviewer_slot": null,
      "unavailable_reviewers": [],
      "author_changes_remaining": [],
      "read_only_required": false,
      "read_only_verified": false,
      "read_only_evidence": "Explicit review-only assignment and Claude plan/Grok existing permissions observed; enforcement across filesystem/network not separately verified. Post-return source hash comparison required.",
      "runtime_session": "01a1608b-009d-7820-b31c-f4aa90688478",
      "review_scope": "Direct12file hash/compact candidate/head/base/clean/21declaredpath inspection; complete2file repair diff, overlay/finalcanonical/join/caller/newtest/original S16 identity assertion;19unchanged paths reuse prior fullsource review.",
      "verification_limits": [
        "Read-only git/hash personally executed; actual code and listed author logs/receipts inspected",
        "No Cargo/Python/Clippy/smoke/browser/realS3/provider/CI independently run",
        "Golden/HTTP hash equality from coordinator preserved report, not independently rehashed",
        "Localfullfailures acknowledged;24283TIME_WAIT supports but does not prove each OS failure",
        "Actual host finalsnapshot high effort; self-effort/mode unavailable; enforced readonly unknown"
      ]
    }
  ]
}
pr-review.md — SHA256 ee751f025c8501749cc5ede6d374458b42d6007b3b623826b24d4a4e1d46a99c 
# Final candidate independent review (attempt3)

Head c7d2a5d2adffba7fa25f85008632743941731879; base307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f; candidate sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab.
Required Claude Opus5.5medium, context64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b PASS, PR comment6328373974. Additional Grok4.7high, contextba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754 PASS, comment6328398007. Both exact final host snapshots verify configured/effective effort/model, same authenticated personal routes after explicit AK sharing approval. Claude plan mode observed; Grokmode unknown; enforced read-only boundary unverified for both. Review-only assignment; no implementation/test-build delegation. One Grok bounded diff/hash shell read approved allow-once; no persistent permissions.

All21declared paths and12source hashes checked, complete corrective2file diff/test and finalgate/join/overlaycaller/originalbase behavior read.19unchanged paths reuse prior independent actual reviews (Grok prior full codec/manifest/selector/cache); current review concentrates on overlay fix and stored identity. Source bytes and tracked clean tree unchanged after returns. Five quality axes source assessment PASS. Claude read actualRed/unit17/summary10 and diagnosis; other current receipts/counts not independently opened byClaude. Grok read53Rust/checks/smoke-execution/artifact logs and code; golden/HTTP hashes referenced coordinator report, not independently rehashed. Neither ranCargo/smoke/Python/Clippy/browser/liveS3/provider/CI. Raw full returns and actual host snapshots retained in v3 files.

Required CI-002 correctness/High resolved explicitly by both reviewers: canonical final downgrade now excludes immutable parent overlay, complete parentoriginal IDs preserved, partial parent stays partial, no overlay map/SSD; unchanged canonical fences remain. Deterministic held-writer Red101 then Green17 and originalsummary10. Redpanic line1738 versus1746 due rustfmt expanding long test expressions and two runtime comment lines, assertion unchanged; no final-form Red rerun claimed. Existing complete integration was intermittent and passed once before fix; not called deterministicRed.

OAI-001, CLA-001, CLA-002 Recommended/Low all not-selected; author reasons retained in configuration, no follow-up created. No unresolved mandatory finding or author-selected source change. Localfullnormal148pass29fail andserial140pass37fail each2ignored remain failures before seed/publish;24283TIME_WAIT supports unproven local port-resource hypothesis. Focused53+7and6childsmoke pass. Current LinuxCI39689501091 remains mandatory/pending, especially originalS16 identity test; source PASS is not readiness or GitHub approval.

Actual two-file staged artifactpolicy passed beforecommit; prior2outgoing passed beforethispush. Initial3range invocation wrong flagsfailed; actual3commit --range success ran afterpush, no beforepushrange claim. Full current SVreceipts archived6328353466 and readback exact. Historical original/v2receipts6327952117/6328066130 superseded, not current readiness. No merge/auto/queue/deployment authorization.
correction-receipt.json — SHA256 83d457b3e14b9643484ac1305ec2c75cec2e38b36d877382c4f42df007383c58 
{
  "iteration": 2,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "correction deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "962a8153377498b6c92e580ed924443c5f6169ef57bcaeead68ff37dda27ce80"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "7b607c253a84011d73c6d6692ea13426f6147674f25b63daa6437e1144798e37"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "9f8083e033436e03c9ad69904916f77ea1e37b22a0db60e52bcbe96cd68e5fa7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "33cb0f2600eec0b402f80941c0923c0f4fb3a3af9060bdf691e47d4deb9774c5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "f4a7dfac3283fa81ab30daa4d46b48db451c23ee9c49717cf56af5bee7aa8302"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "cf27c2537093c90b04998ef440df0e3cfb8116d1935252f469de55b9960e2d36"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/domestic-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bb0b2141e76063af7e7159520288080424a61407555ad7330c5524fa32102c6a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/domestic-v3-serial.log",
      "sha256": "0b265fdc2cdf45b8f42a38149f0fee3ca2acad8b08d84eda1ba4667c9b5eb2c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    },
    {
      "kind": "pr-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pr-review.md",
      "sha256": "ee751f025c8501749cc5ede6d374458b42d6007b3b623826b24d4a4e1d46a99c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "1f3a739f9f4c6e70fcb5744e019cb7bffdc5311bdc67f1dd3eef997a9d0e4e19"
    },
    {
      "kind": "additional-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-reviewer-configuration-v3.json",
      "sha256": "a847e3fd3d5f6963aa94f39db8b2cac1d94e0ede669891bb1a02fc1884ff8df5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-review-return-v3.md",
      "sha256": "338aab8afca98cb4b207be26e98c71ab7456e25f494f4c8b6f9354806927e7cd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-review-return-v3.md",
      "sha256": "6b96d892f3810c867fd0621ca7b8376cf150d9f2c4c15d631fce0a9338dc0ef4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-v3-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "4d3a92384e17e5f51b078465997a48727f0c05caa3f43f9546f2f0be91e8336f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-v3-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "adfc1f9ccc6f920fb27acd5aa8e7a95e4032a62ea40413936097d948ac453e47"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "correction",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/correction.md",
      "sha256": "3b60ed8e7a627398cd55f41b8f4cf71c2c69a626fa8042b1b256c9aef4dba627"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed correction evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}
correction.md — SHA256 3b60ed8e7a627398cd55f41b8f4cf71c2c69a626fa8042b1b256c9aef4dba627 
# Final correction disposition

Headc7d2a5d2adffba7fa25f85008632743941731879, candidateb81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab, base307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f.
Both current independent reviews PASS: Claude6328373974 and Grok6328398007. CI-002Required/High applied and explicitly resolved by both: immutable complete parent overlay IDs preserved while partial parent stays partial; all canonical map/SSD/control/writer/generation gates unchanged. DeterministicRed101/Green17 and originalsummary10 verified. No additional source changes selected after either PASS; current source hashes and clean tree unchanged.
OAI-001RecommendedLow coverage, CLA-001RecommendedLow churn cost, CLA-002RecommendedLow spec sentence remain not-selected with preserved author reasons and reviewer classifications. No follow-up issue/owner/reminder/tracking created. Stable IDs retained across all attempts.
Local full-suite transport/seed failures remain failed, not waived or hidden. Current focused53Rust+7Python and6mode loopbacksmoke pass. Final Linux fullCI39689501091 still mandatory/pending; complete readiness remains blocked until actualCI pass and freshremote state. Currentreceipt schema corrections fixed enum author_action=applied (not fixed), preserving finding meaning; originalrejectedreceipt logs retained. No merge/auto/queue/deployment.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Current CI blocker on c7d2a5d2 (run 39689501091): library 171 passed; domestic 177 passed / 0 failed / 2 ignored, including the original S16 own-acquisition identity case. runtime_services reached 47 passed / 1 failed / 3 ignored: the strict factory national prose fixture returned four child errors. This head is not ready.

The unchanged fixture also fails on base 307defeb locally; the base Linux run stopped before this suite, so Linux attribution remains unproved. Fixed-time diagnostics identify forecast-flight admission refusal. Sequential city preparation removes that failure in individual runs, but repetition exposes loopback S3 Transport errors; separate telemetry observed six refusals at the test peer's connection limit. Test-only correction and independent root-cause analysis remain in progress. Runtime bounds and strict expected responses are unchanged; the full Linux workflow must pass after a reviewed correction. No merge, auto-merge, queue or deployment is authorized.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Candidate evidence archive — 24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec — verification-v4-evidence (1/2). Full structured records retained beyond ephemeral CI artifacts. CI/review status is separate; this is not merge authorization.

candidate.json

Original SHA256 b5aa24f61cf440fbb219769c317dd524b735c4d780b76fdbb972ba4bc5f30e5b; display SHA256 b5aa24f61cf440fbb219769c317dd524b735c4d780b76fdbb972ba4bc5f30e5b. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "runtime_and_verification_files": {
    "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8",
    "server2/src/cache/disk.rs": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2",
    "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8",
    "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f",
    "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9",
    "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38",
    "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs": "1aa293716ea4af0eded33af798e774dd930a8ad4620eb720402ba318cb77b548"
  },
  "scope": "Original runtime implementation at c7d2 unchanged;13declared runtime/test/tool files including scoped factory test. Per-phase current-thread runtime tears down owners/pool; bounded persistent peer and2strict city passes preserve original oracle. Base new-fixture Capacity not attributed or claimed repaired."
}
candidate-commit.json

Original SHA256 c14e82f6bba60b062afac78b00716502b8a4029bb61819c059b97c6a85a015da; display SHA256 c14e82f6bba60b062afac78b00716502b8a4029bb61819c059b97c6a85a015da. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "head": "24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
  "clean": true,
  "committed_hash_mismatches": 0
}
build-receipt.json

Original SHA256 e7146e2daa9da3b4a3081576dc6d4b69d1d2010e94b8f11e97241b1c0983f417; display SHA256 e7146e2daa9da3b4a3081576dc6d4b69d1d2010e94b8f11e97241b1c0983f417. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "iteration": 5,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "build deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "52ab659c5c0c85daed16a350a7931845b6bd558045d4ef538e3c6fe103178302"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "050ae36ef8dbd8804e27084f365c248da1a52ff4c09608bc8162e1bd60d39c01"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs",
      "sha256": "1aa293716ea4af0eded33af798e774dd930a8ad4620eb720402ba318cb77b548"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed build evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}
self-verification-receipt.json

Original SHA256 e6d70a7ffc0fe7fa2740613d3a5c8f044f3dafb23d657fe059631d5763823cd2; display SHA256 e6d70a7ffc0fe7fa2740613d3a5c8f044f3dafb23d657fe059631d5763823cd2. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "iteration": 5,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "self-verification deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "52ab659c5c0c85daed16a350a7931845b6bd558045d4ef538e3c6fe103178302"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "050ae36ef8dbd8804e27084f365c248da1a52ff4c09608bc8162e1bd60d39c01"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs",
      "sha256": "1aa293716ea4af0eded33af798e774dd930a8ad4620eb720402ba318cb77b548"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "b1a6a179b3427cf8fa385638812cbf831de32b5e559666b348b218d0c89ecafc"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "2a2bc74a308953b6733023b7457ff76f7631630702ac4f12ad8954f2f944eab8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "0db1437eb24a188eabb19f78aef851cdbd8f80d43c41f664e5c2a0d5f0c72562"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v4.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.json",
      "sha256": "102a05efcd084b35b5c059d230e6df298bbc1002df27c998a39e9d81b23e78b0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d4ac4516e4ad3fd3414ba4769d8c5757d58a4d475d63a4b2761dfb4a0f5a1dc7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/city-repeat-runtime-v4.json",
      "sha256": "893bdd9de84ee95342deff68e6c3922409685d17024a69211187b563957f6389"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v4.log",
      "sha256": "7ccf486a724766163aef4c6345f884ae8b0ed68d044557fba730f7dfa8db455f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v4-execution.json",
      "sha256": "f45fd2a578669564203f10af0a5db16ef3e675867055c6644a30213fec3615e8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.json",
      "sha256": "6a3d01c2bf3049c181a6b25000ef83acfd22b24d21976d4aa6119b70014e31c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.log",
      "sha256": "0e6ebe7165c483c2cbca07a1b722896871327b052054cf08cc5f90c24c421e41"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/nation-baseline-v4.log",
      "sha256": "7e75eea8872e15f6b8b04796fae550ea95b79686c243d70cc685bdb4e225e02b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/nation-red-v4.log",
      "sha256": "ebf8b68201e1a4d50ae577b170ce05349f8821faa1ce06fb5bbb400804325cf7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v4.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v4.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v4.json",
      "sha256": "5372a23bfd74a7be07783c03bcf542c894274d0d2314dc1bcce8ff29d875f030"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v4.log",
      "sha256": "227e3b87e51be27c50388ff58acb36e35c0bca0ba60f70b758388a99b1d160b9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-probe-v4.json",
      "sha256": "1c72a2fed6076cc115070171e101b7d446fb1b9f719cd2d5e5dfcac7b2b576de"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-probe-v4.log",
      "sha256": "b7442ad516d19d21c0f3d03716b8b6f38c5767e6fd7979a6e9a2fbff1d376054"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-v4.log",
      "sha256": "cca9412561d8b558c49f5281bb6720fcc6b9073154364a4cc720651345e362c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v4-execution.json",
      "sha256": "f37b2f84aaae96b3b93f6db436e60931a7ae0e290ade3fa0092dab563d9d717a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d5fb196239dc3e34b873a82b804b243d14d8877d244f9bd041d4a1dbcd02017d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed self-verification evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}
test-results.json

Original SHA256 2a2bc74a308953b6733023b7457ff76f7631630702ac4f12ad8954f2f944eab8; display SHA256 55b6489a8944aa2f354c412b203877a684b998d82db2fefa06e807c2ed10ee4b. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
  "verification_mode": "tdd",
  "refactor_performed": false,
  "scenarios": [
    {
      "id": "M1",
      "requirement": "AC4",
      "required": true,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 release; owned IPv4 loopback S3 and native HTTP",
      "prerequisites": "Copied/hash-bound example; original730 acquisitions/851 pages; Off provider and no geocoder",
      "actions": "Run seed, complete13-view diagnostic and fresh native HTTP after focused checks",
      "expected": "All13 golden views and original42549B HTTP hash; children/listeners retire",
      "failure": "Changed response, missing golden, timeout, external call or leaked process",
      "cleanup": "Runner reaps all children and peer; evidence retained"
    },
    {
      "id": "M2",
      "requirement": "AC1",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Real cache/writer code with injected bounded dependencies",
      "prerequisites": "Two cached town keys and held writer/build futures",
      "actions": "Read unrelated key during acquisition, then abort/panic and overlap a build",
      "expected": "Same pin and zero counters; no stale flight/installation",
      "failure": "Global clearing, recycled live state or stale installation",
      "cleanup": "Test futures join/abort and cache dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M3",
      "requirement": "AC2",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Fixed clocks and full retained corpus",
      "prerequisites": "Golden pure selectors and existing source builders",
      "actions": "Cross minute and exact publication/retention/day/month/future/rewind boundaries",
      "expected": "Reuse only within interval; all13 answers equal reference replay",
      "failure": "Early refold or stale result at equality",
      "cleanup": "Owned peers/cache scopes retired"
    },
    {
      "id": "M4",
      "requirement": "AC3",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Owned catalog peer and final release example",
      "prerequisites": "Complete canonical scope and bounded30s policy",
      "actions": "Renew unchanged; publish newer same-partition acquisition; inject failed LIST",
      "expected": "Zero raw/descriptor/parse/fold unchanged, newer visible after delay, failed check not renewed",
      "failure": "LIST-only stale identity or expired fallback",
      "cleanup": "Peer and Sources dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M5",
      "requirement": "AC5",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Actual staged Git index and final docs",
      "prerequisites": "Exact path declaration and preserved generated metadata",
      "actions": "Check placement, source hashes, docs/diagram, fmt/Clippy and staged artifact policy",
      "expected": "Declared paths, resolvable links, current docs, no new runtime flag/dependency",
      "failure": "Undeclared implementation or generated output staged",
      "cleanup": "Checks read-only, no index/source mutation"
    }
  ],
  "earlier_failures": [
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/integration-retention.log",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "8/9; assertion used Doc root t1h instead of retained currentData.t1h; corrected oracle, release9/9 passed"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention-v2.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-foundation-failed.log",
      "observed": "Original full CI173passed/4failed; exact four compatibility cases pass in corrected runs above; old independent PASS is revision-bound"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-local.log",
      "observed": "Sandbox peer bind denied; setup failure, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-green.log",
      "observed": "Explicit-drop MutexGuard across await compile error; fixed with lexical scope"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-final.log",
      "observed": "Cross-module test NOW/until compile error; corrected test scope"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-final2.log",
      "observed": "Test transport was intentionally unreachable; moved held-writer reconstruction to Empty transport regression"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression-v2.log",
      "observed": "Filter selected zero checks; not credited; correct fault_tests filter passed8"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v2.log",
      "observed": "Generated delivery sidecar outside declaration; archived with matching hash in .archify recovery-v6 before final placement check"
    }
  ],
  "retained_failed_runs": [
    {
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --test domestic",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "148pass/29fail/2ignored; predominantly local publish/seed Transport/Ambiguous across unrelated modules. Serial scheduling also failed140pass/37fail/2ignored, predominantly publish/seed Transport.24283TIME_WAIT peak; no test assertions or OS settings changed. Separate serial log retained.",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/domestic-v3.log"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-v4.log",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "47 pass/1 factory fail/3 ignored; panic detail suppressed; retained separately, not erased by later pass."
    }
  ],
  "exact_original_reproduction": "Original CI own-acquisition test passed locally once before correction; deterministic Red comes from held-writer overlay test, not that complete scenario.",
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "R-key",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "307defeb+isolation-test",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib actual_writer_future_invalidates -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: unrelated Current view count0 instead of1",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-boundary",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-key-fences-before-boundary",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib selector_interval_crosses -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: arbitrary minute expired fold",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-renew",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-boundaries-before-renewal",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic unchanged_controls_renew -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: no real control LIST after bounded interval",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-disk",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-renewal-before-folded-disk",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic process_restart_restores_folded -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: restart parsed1 acquisition instead of0",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-CI-writer",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "cargo test --release --test domestic latest_short_late_first_demand_does_not_replay_missed_slots",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Existing source compatibility failure reproduced exactly: forecast view boundary during in-flight same-key acquisition",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-overlay",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "66be97c8+overlay-regression-test",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --lib overlay_preserves_complete_parent_identity_during_same_key_backfill",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Expected assertion failure: complete immutable parent lost completeness under held same-key writer",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "G-factory-suite-v4",
      "phase": "green",
      "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --test runtime_services",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "48 passed /0 failed /3 ignored in default parallel suite; exact final test source",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v4.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "clippy-v4",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh clippy --offline --locked --all-targets -- -D warnings",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v4.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "fmt-v4",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh fmt --all -- --check",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v4-execution.json",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "python-v4",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 -B -m unittest server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v4.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "placement-v4",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 server2/tools/check_placement.py --root . --declaration server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json --base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v4.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "artifact-staged-v4",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
      "command": "python3 scripts/check-artifact-policy.py --staged",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v4.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "M1-six-mode-v4",
      "phase": "smoke",
      "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
      "command": "python3 -B server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py --binary ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin-v3/domestic_warm_cache_smoke --output ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v4 --build-variant release --modes seed diagnostic http disk http-disk disk-boundary",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Six owned children exit0; original13 goldens and42549B HTTP hash; restore/renew0raw/parse/fold; three-hour boundary replay",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v4.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "scenario_id": "M1",
      "executed_runtime_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Fresh task smoke on unchanged c7d2 runtime/example/tools binary; later changes exclusively test/declaration/docs."
    }
  ],
  "reused_checks": [
    {
      "id": "G-overlay-module",
      "phase": "green",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --lib domestic::kma::source::forecast",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "16 passed, including complete overlay parent and partial-parent/no-admission controls",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-clippy-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh clippy --offline --locked --all-targets -- -D warnings",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-fmt-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh fmt --all -- --check",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-example-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh build --release --offline --locked --example domestic_warm_cache_smoke",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-unit-v3-final",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --lib forecast_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "17passed including unchanged Mid compatibility and new overlay regression",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-late-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic latest_short_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "6passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-backfill-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic a_backfill_pass_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "2passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-concurrent-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic concurrent_first_requests_share_one_acquisition_per_publication",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "1passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-cache-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic forecast_cache::",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "9passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-summary-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic summary_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "10passed including unchanged own-acquisition S16 identity",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-disk-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --lib cache::disk::fault_tests",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "8 shared DiskCache checks passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-python-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 -B -m unittest server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "7 Python checks passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-placement-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 server2/tools/check_placement.py --root . --declaration server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json --base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "M-full-v3",
      "phase": "smoke",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 -B server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py --binary ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin-v3/domestic_warm_cache_smoke --output ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3 --build-variant release --modes seed diagnostic http disk http-disk disk-boundary",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Six children exit0; 13original goldens, original42549B HTTP hash, restore/renew0raw/parse/fold and independent3h replay preserved",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "scenario_id": "M1",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-staged-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "python3 scripts/check-artifact-policy.py --staged",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Actual two-file staged index",
      "observed": "PASS; intended staged source and maintained evidence only",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    }
  ],
  "fixture_qualification": {
    "head_isolated": "10/10,40 nation attempt0,0 peer refusals; scratch test before final diagnostic-only wrapper/comments",
    "negative_control": "reader disconnected: exact stored-prose assertion fails101; runtime restored hash-exact",
    "base_new_fixture": "first run city502; separate probe raw storage Capacity,0peer refusals; internal origin unknown; no base10 pass claimed",
    "full_parallel_history": "Initial main selected fixture47pass/1factoryfail/3ignored, no panic detail. Temporary source diagnostic then48pass/0fail/3ignored; restored source exact. Final diagnostic wrapper preserves panic and prints reason, city assertion retains body. No claim that initial intermittent failure was causally resolved."
  },
  "refactor_note": "Current corrective iteration completed fixture restructuring before its final Green. No further refactor followed that Green; original runtime post-refactor executions remain in qualified reused_checks and prior receipts."
}
documentation.json

Original SHA256 0db1437eb24a188eabb19f78aef851cdbd8f80d43c41f664e5c2a0d5f0c72562; display SHA256 0db1437eb24a188eabb19f78aef851cdbd8f80d43c41f664e5c2a0d5f0c72562. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "checked": true,
  "summary": "Transparent internal cache retention/restore optimization preserves every product API/CLI/UI operation and HTTP bytes. No new user workflow or feature surface; existing operator Markdown and architecture/Archify are updated and checked. README/API unchanged. No new screenshot PDF manual applies. Diagram artifact/actual Chrome and viewed light/dark captures passed; metadata preserved locally.",
  "new_feature": false,
  "ux_ui_changed": false,
  "updates": [
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/server2.md",
      "sha256": "7ef7a1fa0e181a3f50342e0effe0e5689721ea0b8a39dc58849e5ac158561121"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/operations/server2-domestic-cache.md",
      "sha256": "e6c49e800df20a1b216752c3119407d508a0d5176c04d628b361990f3c49387c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/evidence/tasks/issue-2850/verification.md",
      "sha256": "3962708c063be6556b47e790d2eea5a761806156d9a08fc6b3be6bc21496564d"
    }
  ],
  "manual": null,
  "correction_note": "Test-only factory preparation/runtime teardown; runtime source and Archify/operator contract unchanged; original performance remains explicitly historic. Selected evidence includes baseline limitations and parallel failure history."
}

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Candidate evidence archive — 24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec — verification-v4-evidence (2/2). Full structured records retained beyond ephemeral CI artifacts. CI/review status is separate; this is not merge authorization.

self-verification.md

Original SHA256 b1a6a179b3427cf8fa385638812cbf831de32b5e559666b348b218d0c89ecafc; display SHA256 b1a6a179b3427cf8fa385638812cbf831de32b5e559666b348b218d0c89ecafc. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

# Current fixture candidate self-verification

sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f, base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f. Only declaration, inventory test and selected evidence changed sincec7d2; unchanged runtime hash proof in candidate.json. Actual current full runtime_services48passed/0failed/3ignored; all-targetClippy-Dwarnings,fmt,Python7,placement and staged artifact checks passed. Required smokeM1:1/1 fresh six-mode run on hash-bound unchanged runtime binary. Prior53focusedRust checks and c7d2Linux domestic177pass are qualified reuse, not newly run commands.

Initial selected main full parallel47/1/3 had no panic detail; temporary diagnostic full suite then48/0/3 and exact source restoration; final wrapper preserves panic result and exposes errors. Initial intermittent cause remains unproved. Head isolated10/10 gave40nation attempt0/0peer rejects. Reader-disconnection negative control fails exact-prose assertion; restored runtime hash. Base selected fixture fails city502/Capacity with0peer rejects, internal Capacity source unknown; no base10/backport claim. Original base fixture4Busy failures separately preserved.

Original strict oracle and runtime limits remain. Additional functional six-mode smoke preserves13goldens/originalHTTP SHAa6462aba8ad9ec34d8efdcab4ccd2f37b00339a301fd17caa7c1e5485d45b283; restore/renew no forecast raw/descriptor GET/parse/fold;3hboundary replay. Real loopback only, provider/geocoder0. Started blocking work can delay Runtime drop outside15sec phase guard; isolated runs short, not a proof of no hang.

AC1keyfences/overlay,AC2selector,AC3identityrenewal,AC4disk/fault/restart,AC5docs/placement assessed through unchanged qualified evidence and current checks. Archifyv6 JSON/HTML/browser/visual evidence reused hash-identical; no UI feature/manualPDF applies. Selected performance tables remain66be measurement. Full Linux CI and renewed exact-head independent reviews pending; no readiness/merge/deployment claim. Logs/binaries/recovery retained, shared target pending all consumers.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Independent required review: Claude Opus 5.5, medium — source PASS for 24fb0fbc / base 307defeb, candidate 9e43307f…. Host observed plan mode; enforced read-only isolation unverified. All13committed hashes and22declaredpaths checked;11runtime/test/tool files unchanged fromc7d2. Final fixture diff and selected logs examined; no new Required finding. CI-002 remains resolved. This is an attributed agent source review, not GitHub approval or CI readiness.

Recommended / Low CLA-004: add a message/helper for the duplicated city guard polling block. Author: not selected; current bounded panic diagnostics preserve assertion details, no correctness defect. OAI-001/CLA-001/CLA-002 remain unselected; no follow-up tracking. Full Linux CI remains required. Initial parallel failure and base Capacity retain unknown causes.

Full independent return

Showing 1 of 127 activities (limited to 1)

판정

소스 리뷰 기준 PASS입니다. 새 Required finding은 없고, 가독성 관련 Recommended/Low 1건만 새로 남깁니다. 24fb의 Linux 전체 CI는 아직 pending이고 머지 전에 반드시 통과해야 합니다. 이 판정은 CI 통과나 GitHub 승인을 뜻하지 않습니다.

  • HEAD: 24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec (직접 확인, working tree clean)
  • BASE: 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f
  • Candidate: sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f
  • 리뷰어: Claude Opus 5.5 (claude-opus-5-5). effort 값은 제게 보이지 않아 적지 않습니다.

직접 확인한 것

  • Candidate 해시: candidate.json의 13개 파일 sha256을 git show HEAD:<path>로 다시 계산했고 불일치는 0건입니다.
  • runtime 동일성: 테스트 파일과 task 선언을 뺀 나머지 11개 파일은 c7d2와 diff가 없습니다. 그래서 runtime 코드에 대한 이전 소스 PASS는 그대로 재사용할 수 있습니다.
  • 변경 범위: c7d2..HEAD에서 바뀐 파일은 inventory.rs, ForecastRetention2850.json, verification.md 세 개뿐입니다. 307defeb..HEAD는 22개 경로이고, 선언에 inventory.rs가 추가되어 그 범위를 설명합니다.
  • fixture diff: 전문을 읽었습니다.

로그로만 확인한 것 (실행하지 않음)

  • runtime-full-final-v4.log: 최종 소스로 48 통과, 0 실패, 3 ignored입니다.
  • runtime-full-v4.log: 47 통과, 1 실패입니다. 원인 미상으로 남아 있고, 해소된 것으로 다시 분류되지 않았습니다.
  • city-head-runtime-v4-*.log: 10/10 통과했고, attempt=0 READY가 40건입니다.
  • head-negative-v4: reader 연결을 끊으면 "exact stored prose" assertion에서 실패합니다. setup 단계 실패가 아니고, 원본으로 복원된 것도 해시로 확인됩니다.
  • 나머지 로그는 열지 않았습니다. checks-v4, smoke-v4, nation-baseline-v4, base-reason-v4의 내용은 요청문에 적힌 내용만 근거로 합니다.

fixture 리뷰 (5개 축)

  • 정확성과 oracle 유지:
    • 15개 도시 nation 응답, 저장된 prose와의 정확한 일치, assert_response, 두 버전, 4회 상한, 15초 guard가 모두 유지됩니다.
    • 가상 시간 고정은 assert_eq!(Instant::now(), virtual_before)로 오히려 강해졌습니다.
    • city 준비는 같은 router를 쓰고, 버전마다 2 pass를 돌며, 모든 응답에 200을 엄격히 요구합니다.
    • 2-pass의 이유(Writer eviction과 one-shot claim)가 주석에 적혀 있습니다.
  • 재구성 검증:
    • phase마다 current_thread runtime, services, router를 새로 만들고, persistent peer(S3 정본)는 두 phase가 공유합니다. 메모리를 잃은 상태에서의 재구성 검증이 더 엄격해졌습니다.
    • prose는 nation의 narrative::attach에서만 붙습니다. child 결과의 forecastNarrative는 제거되므로 warm-up이 이 검증을 대신 통과시키지 못합니다. negative control 결과도 이와 맞습니다.
  • panic 처리: catch_unwind로 실패 이유를 출력한 뒤 resume_unwind로 원래 실패 결과를 그대로 유지합니다. 다른 테스트가 panic hook을 바꿔도 이유가 남습니다.
  • 오류 진단 출력: city 오류 본문은 2048바이트까지만 출력합니다. fixture 데이터라서 비밀값은 없습니다.
  • city 경로 인코딩: nation과 달리 -_.~도 퍼센트 인코딩하지만, 디코딩하면 같으므로 영향이 없습니다.
  • 보안과 성능: 해당 사항 없습니다. 테스트 전용 변경이고 runtime bound는 바뀌지 않았습니다.

Findings

  • CLA-004 — Recommended / Low / readability
    • 위치: inventory.rs의 city 준비 poll_fn
    • 내용: 15초 guard assertion assert!(phase_started.elapsed() < Duration::from_secs(15))에 메시지가 없습니다. nation 쪽에는 "factory fixture did not complete" 메시지가 있습니다. 또 self-wake poll 블록이 두 번 중복됩니다.
    • 수정: 메시지를 추가하거나 helper로 뽑습니다.
    • 처리: 선택은 작성자 판단입니다. 동작 결함은 아닙니다.

기존 finding 승계

  • CI-002 — Required / High: c7d2에서 해소된 상태를 유지합니다. Linux S16 테스트와 domestic 177개가 통과했습니다.
  • OAI-001, CLA-001, CLA-002 — Recommended / Low: 미선택이고 follow-up도 없습니다. 이번 diff는 runtime을 바꾸지 않으므로 분류가 그대로입니다.
  • CLA-003: 만들지 않았습니다. base 실패가 확인됐고, base-reason의 세부 원인은 미확정이기 때문입니다.

남은 한계

  • 최종 바이트로 한 실행은 한 번뿐입니다.
    • 10회 반복과 negative control은 최종 주석과 진단 wrapper를 넣기 전의 테스트 바이트로 실행됐습니다. 해당 테스트 sha256은 b53eb922…이고, HEAD의 테스트는 1aa29371…입니다.
    • 차이는 panic 경로의 wrapper와 주석뿐이라 의미상 결과가 이어진다고 봅니다. 그래도 최종 바이트로 실행한 것은 전체 runtime 1회(48/0)뿐입니다. Linux CI가 최종 바이트를 실행합니다.
  • Runtime Drop 시간: current_thread runtime을 drop할 때 blocking 작업을 기다리는 시간은 15초 guard 밖에 있습니다. 이미 잔여 한계로 기록돼 있습니다.
  • 원인 미상으로 남은 것: runtime-full-v4의 1회 실패와 base 신규 fixture의 Capacity 오류는 원인 미상입니다. 둘 다 해소로 다시 분류하지 말아야 합니다.

이번에도 파일 수정, 빌드, 네트워크 사용, 게시, 위임은 하지 않았습니다.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Independent additional review: Grok4.7, high — source PASS for 24fb0fbc / base 307defeb, candidate 9e43307f…. Actual mode unknown, enforced isolation unverified. All13file hashes,22declaredpaths and3file correction diff checked;11unchanged runtime/tool/test files reuse previous source PASS. No new GROK finding; CI-002 remains resolved, prior Low recommendations unselected. No checks independently executed or live CI queried. Full Linux CI remains required. This is an attributed source review, not GitHub approval/readiness.

Full independent return

Showing 1 of 284 activities (limited to 1)

PASS. 소스 리뷰 기준입니다. GitHub 승인이나 머지 준비 완료가 아닙니다. 24fb0fbc의 Linux CI 39698560229는 로컬 스냅샷에서 foundation이 진행 중이고, goldens만 성공입니다. 라이브 재조회는 하지 않았습니다.

검토자: Grok 4.7. 모드 id는 이 세션에서 보지 못했습니다. mode_verified는 false입니다. 선택적 Grok 리뷰이며 필수 리뷰어를 대체하지 않습니다. 소스, 빌드, Cargo, 네트워크, 발행, 커밋은 하지 않았습니다.

신원과 해시

HEAD 24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec, base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f, 작업 트리는 clean입니다. candidate sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f를 13개 파일의 정렬 compact JSON으로 다시 계산해 일치했습니다. 작업 트리와 HEAD 바이트도 선언 해시 13개와 모두 일치합니다. candidate-commit.json은 clean, mismatch 0입니다.

c7d2a5d2..HEAD는 3파일입니다. inventory.rs, ForecastRetention2850.json, verification.md. base..HEAD는 22경로입니다. 런타임·도구 11개 파일은 c7d2a5d2와 SHA-256이 같습니다. forecast_cache.rs는 12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554입니다. 이전 런타임 PASS는 이 11개에만 재사용합니다. 새 fixture에는 재사용하지 않습니다.

다섯 축

정확성. 엄격 오라클은 유지됩니다. nation::CITIES 15개, 버전 v000903/v000901, 국가 요청 최대 4회, 실시간 15초 guard, tokio::time::pause 뒤 가상시각 동일 단언, forecastNarrative 동등 비교와 assert_response. 버전마다 도시 200을 두 번 요구합니다. 500은 기존처럼 getWeather가 있는 child 오류만 워밍업으로 넘깁니다. catch_unwind는 String/&str 이유를 stderr에 남기고 resume_unwind합니다. 실패를 삼키지 않습니다. Peer::persistent()는 같은 프로세스의 canonical S3를 유지하고, phase마다 current-thread runtime을 드롭합니다. observability::spawn은 그 runtime의 tokio::spawn입니다. 제품 scheduler, admission, owner 한도는 이 diff에 없습니다. persistent peer는 HTTP/1.1 재사용이며 socket/admission 상한을 바꾸지 않습니다.

가독성. phase 주석이 두 번의 도시 준비와 runtime 교체 이유를 설명합니다. 함수가 길지만 테스트 한 건입니다.

구조. 선언 server2_paths에 inventory.rs가 들어갔고 outside 9경로와 합쳐 22입니다. 배치 로그는 PASS입니다. 제품 모듈로 로직이 새지 않습니다.

보안. 새 비밀은 없습니다. 도시 실패 본문 진단은 2048바이트로 잘립니다.

성능. 추가 요청은 이 테스트와 15초 실시간 guard 안입니다. 제품 한도는 그대로입니다.

직접 본 입력과 로그만 본 항목

소스로 본 것: 위 diff, Peer::persistent, catalog_peer.py의 --persistent, CITIES, observability::spawn, 해시 재계산.

로그에서 결과 줄을 확인한 것:

  • runtime-full-final-v4.log: factory_national_prose... ok, 48 passed; 0 failed; 3 ignored; finished in 35.67s. JSON의 inventory 해시는 최종 1aa29371…과 같습니다. JSON elapsed 136초는 이 테스트 시간과 다릅니다.
  • runtime-full-v4.log: 47 passed; 1 failed; 3 ignored; finished in 35.77s. 실패 목록은 factory 테스트 이름뿐이고 panic 본문이 없습니다. 원인은 미상입니다. 이후 통과로 해소된 것이 아닙니다.
  • runtime-full-probe-v4.log: 48 passed; 0 failed; 3 ignored; finished in 35.54s. TASK2850_PEER_SLOT_REJECT 9줄은 다른 테스트 출력 사이에 있고, factory용 TASK2850_FULL_FAILED_REASON/TASK2850_FULL_PANIC은 없습니다. factory에 귀속하지 않습니다. probe 스크립트는 backend.rs와 inventory.rs를 실행 후 원본 해시로 복구합니다.
  • city-head-runtime-v4-1..10.log: 각 1 passed, FACTORY_PROSE_READY 4줄이 모두 attempt=0. 합계 40. peer slot 거절 문자열 0. panic wrapper 문구 없음. 최종 주석·진단 wrapper 이전 scratch입니다. 같은 JSON의 city-base-runtime-v4-1은 exit 101이라 10회 헤드 통과와 분리합니다.
  • head-negative-v4.log: exit 101, factory must attach exact stored prose, phase 0, v000903, left None, right에 저장된 prose. 도시 setup 실패가 아닙니다. peer 거절 0. 복구 파일 gateway/runtime.rs 해시 a8500199…는 c7d2 및 현재 HEAD와 같습니다. 이 실행의 inventory 해시는 b53eb922…로, 최종 1aa29371…와 다릅니다. 최종 소스에도 같은 prose 단언이 있습니다.
  • nation-baseline-v4.log: 원래 inventory 825a81a8…(c7d2)에서 child500이 attempt 0–3으로 4번 난 뒤 strict-positive 단언에서 실패합니다. 로그에 Busy 문자열은 없습니다. Busy는 fixture-diagnosis-v4.md가 forecast view unavailable 프로브를 bounded flight와 연결한 진단입니다.
  • base-reason-v4.log: forecast cache: raw storage: Capacity, 도시 충청북도/청주시 502, peer 거절 0. 내부 Capacity의 정확한 출처는 이 로그로 확정되지 않습니다. S3 gate 1/2 귀속은 철회된 상태입니다. base 10회 통과, #2850이 base Capacity를 고쳤다는 주장, backport 주장은 하지 않습니다.
  • base CI 39243883911은 dependency-ci-v4.json의 307defeb 실패입니다. 보존 로그는 domestic 169 passed; 4 failed; 2 ignored에서 끝나고 runtime_services 실행이 없습니다.
  • CI-002의 Linux 근거는 ci-v3-failed.log입니다. c7d2a5d2 실행에서 the_requests_own_acquisition_keeps_its_stored_identity가 ok이고 domestic 177 passed; 0 failed; 2 ignored입니다. 그 다음 옛 factory fixture가 47/1/3으로 실패했습니다.
  • Clippy 로그는 Finished dev profile. fmt는 receipt exit 0이고 fmt-v4.log는 비어 있습니다. Python은 Ran 7 tests OK. placement는 PASS. staged artifact는 1 snapshot(s) 통과, outgoing은 4 snapshot(s) 통과입니다.
  • smoke-v4.log 6모드 exit 0. 바이너리 b51244fc…는 bin-v3이며 smoke-v3-execution.json과 같습니다. documentation.json의 verification.md 해시는 작업 트리와 일치합니다.

재실행하지 않은 것: 53개 focused Rust, c7d2 Linux domestic 177, 6모드 smoke의 이전 측정. 런타임 해시가 같아 재사용 자격만 인정합니다. 새 실행이 아닙니다.

기존 지적

ID 심각도 축 위치 처분
CI-002 Required / High 정확성 forecast_cache.rs overlay fence, S16 summary_s3 c7d2에서 해소 유지. Linux에서 S16 ok와 domestic 177을 확인. 런타임 해시 불변. 재오픈하지 않음
OAI-001 Recommended / Low 검증 forecast_cache.rs / manifest 테스트 not-selected, follow-up 없음. 새 fixture가 이 공백을 메우지 않음
CLA-001 Recommended / Low 정확성/성능 forecast_cache.rs rejoin not-selected. 같은 파일 해시. 재시도 상한은 선택하지 않음
CLA-002 Recommended / Low 문서 specs/issue-2850.md AC1 not-selected. 이번 diff는 spec 문장을 바꾸지 않음

새 GROK 지적 없음. CLA-003 없음.

한계

Runtime drop은 15초 poll_fn guard 밖에서 일어납니다. 격리 실행은 약 2초였고, drop이 막히지 않는다는 증명은 아닙니다. 제품 결함으로 올리지는 않습니다. 초기 47/1/3의 원인, base 502 Capacity의 내부 출처는 미상입니다. 24fb Linux CI가 끝나기 전에는 준비 완료가 아닙니다.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Candidate evidence archive — 24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec — review-v4-evidence (1/2). Full structured records retained beyond ephemeral CI artifacts. CI/review status is separate; this is not merge authorization.

pr-review-receipt.json

Original SHA256 9c996272202c90a3440b4af6ee4391ff8c5981e8a4b43a35073b0094118d9b93; display SHA256 9c996272202c90a3440b4af6ee4391ff8c5981e8a4b43a35073b0094118d9b93. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "iteration": 4,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "pr-review deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "52ab659c5c0c85daed16a350a7931845b6bd558045d4ef538e3c6fe103178302"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "050ae36ef8dbd8804e27084f365c248da1a52ff4c09608bc8162e1bd60d39c01"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs",
      "sha256": "1aa293716ea4af0eded33af798e774dd930a8ad4620eb720402ba318cb77b548"
    },
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "b1a6a179b3427cf8fa385638812cbf831de32b5e559666b348b218d0c89ecafc"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "2a2bc74a308953b6733023b7457ff76f7631630702ac4f12ad8954f2f944eab8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "0db1437eb24a188eabb19f78aef851cdbd8f80d43c41f664e5c2a0d5f0c72562"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v4.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.json",
      "sha256": "102a05efcd084b35b5c059d230e6df298bbc1002df27c998a39e9d81b23e78b0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d4ac4516e4ad3fd3414ba4769d8c5757d58a4d475d63a4b2761dfb4a0f5a1dc7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/city-repeat-runtime-v4.json",
      "sha256": "893bdd9de84ee95342deff68e6c3922409685d17024a69211187b563957f6389"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v4.log",
      "sha256": "7ccf486a724766163aef4c6345f884ae8b0ed68d044557fba730f7dfa8db455f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v4-execution.json",
      "sha256": "f45fd2a578669564203f10af0a5db16ef3e675867055c6644a30213fec3615e8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.json",
      "sha256": "6a3d01c2bf3049c181a6b25000ef83acfd22b24d21976d4aa6119b70014e31c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.log",
      "sha256": "0e6ebe7165c483c2cbca07a1b722896871327b052054cf08cc5f90c24c421e41"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/nation-baseline-v4.log",
      "sha256": "7e75eea8872e15f6b8b04796fae550ea95b79686c243d70cc685bdb4e225e02b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/nation-red-v4.log",
      "sha256": "ebf8b68201e1a4d50ae577b170ce05349f8821faa1ce06fb5bbb400804325cf7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v4.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v4.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v4.json",
      "sha256": "5372a23bfd74a7be07783c03bcf542c894274d0d2314dc1bcce8ff29d875f030"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v4.log",
      "sha256": "227e3b87e51be27c50388ff58acb36e35c0bca0ba60f70b758388a99b1d160b9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-probe-v4.json",
      "sha256": "1c72a2fed6076cc115070171e101b7d446fb1b9f719cd2d5e5dfcac7b2b576de"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-probe-v4.log",
      "sha256": "b7442ad516d19d21c0f3d03716b8b6f38c5767e6fd7979a6e9a2fbff1d376054"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-v4.log",
      "sha256": "cca9412561d8b558c49f5281bb6720fcc6b9073154364a4cc720651345e362c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v4-execution.json",
      "sha256": "f37b2f84aaae96b3b93f6db436e60931a7ae0e290ade3fa0092dab563d9d717a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d5fb196239dc3e34b873a82b804b243d14d8877d244f9bd041d4a1dbcd02017d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "pr-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pr-review.md",
      "sha256": "1ffe99218a0cfc9c5896df9956a67b217d95ef9756ac188f9843f82e017bd6cc"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "6b45280d8161240e113814900eb63bddf80fb6ca42ab1860050eb38e4cc1ffcc"
    },
    {
      "kind": "additional-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-reviewer-configuration-v4.json",
      "sha256": "f0c61040ffb7d079486f30917894ad3f545451605fba553a872ee0acfbaeed4f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-review-return-v4.md",
      "sha256": "2d5adcdab49616dc946bebc3effb833cf306e8302555e3daf098f7fc7eda1d5d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-review-return-v4.md",
      "sha256": "c6b3676f2ac7c4f86e39ae5c9a06f4206c910fef6a532decc172e76e813deb20"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-v4-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "76c14cfe6b5e35937c0ee45df283cc84ad3bc23fcb3a3017b0eb38042058b7e0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-v4-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "3860e0438068a6373e179869c8c80b4badac94948f4c4a01ff124feb0124965a"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed pr-review evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  },
  "review": {
    "author_provider": "openai",
    "provider": "anthropic",
    "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
    "context_id": "64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b",
    "independent": true,
    "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
    "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
    "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
    "effort": "medium",
    "requested_effort": "medium",
    "effort_verified": true,
    "requested_mode": "plan",
    "mode": "plan",
    "mode_verified": true,
    "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
    "author_account": "codex-current",
    "account": "paseo-claude-default",
    "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
    "head": "24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec",
    "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
    "verdict": "PASS",
    "findings": [
      {
        "id": "OAI-001",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Verification",
        "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
        "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
        "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
        "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
        "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
        "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-001",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Correctness/performance",
        "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
        "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
        "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
        "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
        "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
        "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
        "confidence": "medium",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-002",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Documentation",
        "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
        "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
        "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
        "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
        "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
        "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
      },
      {
        "id": "CI-002",
        "classification": "required",
        "severity": "HIGH",
        "category": "Correctness",
        "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
        "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
        "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
        "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
        "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
        "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "fixed",
        "author_action": "applied",
        "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
        "resolved": true,
        "reviewer_resolution": "Claude explicitly reclassified CI-002 Required/High correctness regression and confirmed this source/focused-test repair resolves it; full LinuxCI remains independent readiness gate."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-004",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Readability",
        "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs city preparation poll_fn",
        "finding": "Add a city guard message or extract duplicate self-waking poll helper.",
        "evidence": "City15sec assertion has no custom message; nation poll block duplicates it with a message.",
        "impact": "Diagnostic/readability improvement only; no behavior defect.",
        "verification": "Optional diagnostic/helper clarification without relaxing oracle.",
        "requirement": "Test readability and failure diagnosis",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Not selected. Catch/rethrow preserves original assertion details and city error body is bounded; helper extraction is optional and unnecessary for current correctness. No follow-up tracking.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer classified Recommended/Low and returned source PASS; no selected correction remains."
      }
    ],
    "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329530332",
    "record_id": "6329530332",
    "reviewer_slot": 1,
    "unavailable_reviewers": [],
    "author_changes_remaining": [],
    "read_only_required": false,
    "read_only_verified": false,
    "read_only_evidence": "Host plan mode observed; enforced boundary unverified. No source edits observed;13tracked source hashes match after return. Review-only prompt, no builds/network/publication/delegation allowed.",
    "runtime_session": "5b7058e6-94bc-492f-90f8-68abb67f4025",
    "review_scope": "Full3file c7d2..24fb correction diff,22declaredpaths/13committedhashes;11unchanged runtime/test/tool files reuse prior source review. Exact final48/0/3 and initial47/1 logs, isolated10/10 and negativecontrol examined, not executed.",
    "verification_limits": [
      "No checks executed by reviewer; selected raw logs read only",
      "checks-v4/smoke-v4/base reason logs not opened; counts main execution evidence only",
      "Final full suite executed once at exact final bytes; prior isolated10 and negative use pre-diagnostic source",
      "Initial full parallel failure and baseCapacity internal cause remain unknown",
      "Runtime drop waits blocking tasks outside15sec guard",
      "Current Linux CI mandatory and pending"
    ]
  },
  "optional_reviews": [
    {
      "author_provider": "openai",
      "provider": "xai",
      "model": "grok-4.7",
      "context_id": "ba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754",
      "independent": true,
      "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
      "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
      "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
      "effort": "high",
      "requested_effort": "high",
      "effort_verified": true,
      "requested_mode": null,
      "mode": null,
      "mode_verified": false,
      "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
      "author_account": "codex-current",
      "account": "paseo-grok-default",
      "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
      "head": "24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec",
      "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "findings": [
        {
          "id": "OAI-001",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Verification",
          "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
          "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
          "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
          "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
          "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
          "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
        },
        {
          "id": "CLA-001",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Correctness/performance",
          "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
          "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
          "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
          "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
          "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
          "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
          "confidence": "medium",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
        },
        {
          "id": "CLA-002",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Documentation",
          "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
          "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
          "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
          "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
          "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
          "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
        },
        {
          "id": "CI-002",
          "classification": "required",
          "severity": "HIGH",
          "category": "Correctness",
          "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
          "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
          "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
          "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
          "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
          "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "fixed",
          "author_action": "applied",
          "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
          "resolved": true,
          "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok explicitly confirm CI-002 Required correctness regression resolved by this immutable-parent overlay repair and focused tests; LinuxCI still separate mandatory gate."
        }
      ],
      "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329642011",
      "record_id": "6329642011",
      "reviewer_slot": null,
      "unavailable_reviewers": [],
      "author_changes_remaining": [],
      "read_only_required": false,
      "read_only_verified": false,
      "read_only_evidence": "Actualmode unknown; no verified tool/network isolation.13tracked source hashes and clean tree unchanged after read-only assignment; no source edits observed.",
      "runtime_session": "01a1608b-009d-7820-b31c-f4aa90688478",
      "review_scope": "Entire3file fixture correction;22declaredpaths,13working/committed/declared hashes;11runtime/test/tool files identicalc7d2. Selected final/full/negative/base/Clippy/Python/smoke logs read, no executions.",
      "verification_limits": [
        "No build/Cargo/liveCI independently executed",
        "Final exact-source full suite once; isolated10 and negative before finaldiagnostic wrapper",
        "Initial fullparallelfailure and baseCapacity remain unknown",
        "RuntimeDrop outside15sec guard; blocking waits not disproved",
        "Current LinuxCI still required/pending"
      ]
    }
  ]
}
reviewer-configuration.json

Original SHA256 6b45280d8161240e113814900eb63bddf80fb6ca42ab1860050eb38e4cc1ffcc; display SHA256 6b45280d8161240e113814900eb63bddf80fb6ca42ab1860050eb38e4cc1ffcc. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "author_provider": "openai",
  "provider": "anthropic",
  "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
  "context_id": "64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b",
  "independent": true,
  "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
  "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
  "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
  "effort": "medium",
  "requested_effort": "medium",
  "effort_verified": true,
  "requested_mode": "plan",
  "mode": "plan",
  "mode_verified": true,
  "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
  "author_account": "codex-current",
  "account": "paseo-claude-default",
  "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
  "head": "24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "verdict": "PASS",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "OAI-001",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Verification",
      "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
      "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
      "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
      "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
      "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
      "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-001",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Correctness/performance",
      "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
      "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
      "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
      "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
      "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
      "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-002",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Documentation",
      "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
      "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
      "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
      "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
      "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
      "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
    },
    {
      "id": "CI-002",
      "classification": "required",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "category": "Correctness",
      "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
      "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
      "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
      "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
      "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
      "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "fixed",
      "author_action": "applied",
      "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
      "resolved": true,
      "reviewer_resolution": "Claude explicitly reclassified CI-002 Required/High correctness regression and confirmed this source/focused-test repair resolves it; full LinuxCI remains independent readiness gate."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-004",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Readability",
      "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs city preparation poll_fn",
      "finding": "Add a city guard message or extract duplicate self-waking poll helper.",
      "evidence": "City15sec assertion has no custom message; nation poll block duplicates it with a message.",
      "impact": "Diagnostic/readability improvement only; no behavior defect.",
      "verification": "Optional diagnostic/helper clarification without relaxing oracle.",
      "requirement": "Test readability and failure diagnosis",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Not selected. Catch/rethrow preserves original assertion details and city error body is bounded; helper extraction is optional and unnecessary for current correctness. No follow-up tracking.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer classified Recommended/Low and returned source PASS; no selected correction remains."
    }
  ],
  "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329530332",
  "record_id": "6329530332",
  "reviewer_slot": 1,
  "unavailable_reviewers": [],
  "author_changes_remaining": [],
  "read_only_required": false,
  "read_only_verified": false,
  "read_only_evidence": "Host plan mode observed; enforced boundary unverified. No source edits observed;13tracked source hashes match after return. Review-only prompt, no builds/network/publication/delegation allowed.",
  "runtime_session": "5b7058e6-94bc-492f-90f8-68abb67f4025",
  "review_scope": "Full3file c7d2..24fb correction diff,22declaredpaths/13committedhashes;11unchanged runtime/test/tool files reuse prior source review. Exact final48/0/3 and initial47/1 logs, isolated10/10 and negativecontrol examined, not executed.",
  "verification_limits": [
    "No checks executed by reviewer; selected raw logs read only",
    "checks-v4/smoke-v4/base reason logs not opened; counts main execution evidence only",
    "Final full suite executed once at exact final bytes; prior isolated10 and negative use pre-diagnostic source",
    "Initial full parallel failure and baseCapacity internal cause remain unknown",
    "Runtime drop waits blocking tasks outside15sec guard",
    "Current Linux CI mandatory and pending"
  ]
}
grok-reviewer-configuration-v4.json

Original SHA256 f0c61040ffb7d079486f30917894ad3f545451605fba553a872ee0acfbaeed4f; display SHA256 f0c61040ffb7d079486f30917894ad3f545451605fba553a872ee0acfbaeed4f. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "author_provider": "openai",
  "provider": "xai",
  "model": "grok-4.7",
  "context_id": "ba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754",
  "independent": true,
  "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
  "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
  "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
  "effort": "high",
  "requested_effort": "high",
  "effort_verified": true,
  "requested_mode": null,
  "mode": null,
  "mode_verified": false,
  "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
  "author_account": "codex-current",
  "account": "paseo-grok-default",
  "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
  "head": "24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "verdict": "PASS",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "OAI-001",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Verification",
      "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
      "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
      "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
      "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
      "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
      "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-001",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Correctness/performance",
      "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
      "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
      "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
      "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
      "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
      "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-002",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Documentation",
      "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
      "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
      "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
      "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
      "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
      "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
    },
    {
      "id": "CI-002",
      "classification": "required",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "category": "Correctness",
      "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
      "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
      "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
      "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
      "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
      "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "fixed",
      "author_action": "applied",
      "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
      "resolved": true,
      "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok explicitly confirm CI-002 Required correctness regression resolved by this immutable-parent overlay repair and focused tests; LinuxCI still separate mandatory gate."
    }
  ],
  "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329642011",
  "record_id": "6329642011",
  "reviewer_slot": null,
  "unavailable_reviewers": [],
  "author_changes_remaining": [],
  "read_only_required": false,
  "read_only_verified": false,
  "read_only_evidence": "Actualmode unknown; no verified tool/network isolation.13tracked source hashes and clean tree unchanged after read-only assignment; no source edits observed.",
  "runtime_session": "01a1608b-009d-7820-b31c-f4aa90688478",
  "review_scope": "Entire3file fixture correction;22declaredpaths,13working/committed/declared hashes;11runtime/test/tool files identicalc7d2. Selected final/full/negative/base/Clippy/Python/smoke logs read, no executions.",
  "verification_limits": [
    "No build/Cargo/liveCI independently executed",
    "Final exact-source full suite once; isolated10 and negative before finaldiagnostic wrapper",
    "Initial fullparallelfailure and baseCapacity remain unknown",
    "RuntimeDrop outside15sec guard; blocking waits not disproved",
    "Current LinuxCI still required/pending"
  ]
}

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Candidate evidence archive — 24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec — review-v4-evidence (2/2). Full structured records retained beyond ephemeral CI artifacts. CI/review status is separate; this is not merge authorization.

correction-receipt.json

Original SHA256 9b6c1568f37a4df4bb2d192fa6f080b549668792dbc88574da4efd3d78685684; display SHA256 9b6c1568f37a4df4bb2d192fa6f080b549668792dbc88574da4efd3d78685684. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "iteration": 3,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "correction deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:9e43307f6252a9036378635c96cf77c4c6cb80bb809d19357852f75326c7e81f",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "52ab659c5c0c85daed16a350a7931845b6bd558045d4ef538e3c6fe103178302"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "050ae36ef8dbd8804e27084f365c248da1a52ff4c09608bc8162e1bd60d39c01"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs",
      "sha256": "1aa293716ea4af0eded33af798e774dd930a8ad4620eb720402ba318cb77b548"
    },
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "b1a6a179b3427cf8fa385638812cbf831de32b5e559666b348b218d0c89ecafc"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "2a2bc74a308953b6733023b7457ff76f7631630702ac4f12ad8954f2f944eab8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "0db1437eb24a188eabb19f78aef851cdbd8f80d43c41f664e5c2a0d5f0c72562"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v4.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.json",
      "sha256": "102a05efcd084b35b5c059d230e6df298bbc1002df27c998a39e9d81b23e78b0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d4ac4516e4ad3fd3414ba4769d8c5757d58a4d475d63a4b2761dfb4a0f5a1dc7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/city-repeat-runtime-v4.json",
      "sha256": "893bdd9de84ee95342deff68e6c3922409685d17024a69211187b563957f6389"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v4.log",
      "sha256": "7ccf486a724766163aef4c6345f884ae8b0ed68d044557fba730f7dfa8db455f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v4-execution.json",
      "sha256": "f45fd2a578669564203f10af0a5db16ef3e675867055c6644a30213fec3615e8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.json",
      "sha256": "6a3d01c2bf3049c181a6b25000ef83acfd22b24d21976d4aa6119b70014e31c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.log",
      "sha256": "0e6ebe7165c483c2cbca07a1b722896871327b052054cf08cc5f90c24c421e41"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/nation-baseline-v4.log",
      "sha256": "7e75eea8872e15f6b8b04796fae550ea95b79686c243d70cc685bdb4e225e02b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/nation-red-v4.log",
      "sha256": "ebf8b68201e1a4d50ae577b170ce05349f8821faa1ce06fb5bbb400804325cf7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v4.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v4.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v4.json",
      "sha256": "5372a23bfd74a7be07783c03bcf542c894274d0d2314dc1bcce8ff29d875f030"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v4.log",
      "sha256": "227e3b87e51be27c50388ff58acb36e35c0bca0ba60f70b758388a99b1d160b9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-probe-v4.json",
      "sha256": "1c72a2fed6076cc115070171e101b7d446fb1b9f719cd2d5e5dfcac7b2b576de"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-probe-v4.log",
      "sha256": "b7442ad516d19d21c0f3d03716b8b6f38c5767e6fd7979a6e9a2fbff1d376054"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-v4.log",
      "sha256": "cca9412561d8b558c49f5281bb6720fcc6b9073154364a4cc720651345e362c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v4-execution.json",
      "sha256": "f37b2f84aaae96b3b93f6db436e60931a7ae0e290ade3fa0092dab563d9d717a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d5fb196239dc3e34b873a82b804b243d14d8877d244f9bd041d4a1dbcd02017d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    },
    {
      "kind": "pr-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pr-review.md",
      "sha256": "1ffe99218a0cfc9c5896df9956a67b217d95ef9756ac188f9843f82e017bd6cc"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "6b45280d8161240e113814900eb63bddf80fb6ca42ab1860050eb38e4cc1ffcc"
    },
    {
      "kind": "additional-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-reviewer-configuration-v4.json",
      "sha256": "f0c61040ffb7d079486f30917894ad3f545451605fba553a872ee0acfbaeed4f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-review-return-v4.md",
      "sha256": "2d5adcdab49616dc946bebc3effb833cf306e8302555e3daf098f7fc7eda1d5d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-review-return-v4.md",
      "sha256": "c6b3676f2ac7c4f86e39ae5c9a06f4206c910fef6a532decc172e76e813deb20"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-v4-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "76c14cfe6b5e35937c0ee45df283cc84ad3bc23fcb3a3017b0eb38042058b7e0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-v4-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "3860e0438068a6373e179869c8c80b4badac94948f4c4a01ff124feb0124965a"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "correction",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/correction.md",
      "sha256": "6b54e6e332556e9c1aafa9fd337231a6ea87f7c8bb33cff90716887cf87062f0"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed correction evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}
correction.md

Original SHA256 6b54e6e332556e9c1aafa9fd337231a6ea87f7c8bb33cff90716887cf87062f0; display SHA256 6b54e6e332556e9c1aafa9fd337231a6ea87f7c8bb33cff90716887cf87062f0. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

# Current review disposition

24fb0fbc / candidate9e43307f. Both independent source reviews PASS, no newRequired. CI-002RequiredHigh was applied/resolvedc7d2; unchangedruntime and originalLinuxS16PASS evidence carried. Finalfixture declaredbeforeedit and strictoracle preserved; sourcehashes unchangedafterreviews.

OAI001,CLA001,CLA002RecommendedLow retain priornot-selected responses. CLA004RecommendedLow guard-message/helper readability: notselected. Catch/rethrow alreadypreservesassertiondetails and boundedcitybody; extractinghelper isoptional withoutcurrentcorrectnessdefect. No followupissue/owner/reminder/tracking. No CLA003ornewGrokfinding. No selectedsourcechanges remain.

Initialparallel47/1/3 and basenewfixtureCapacity remainunexplainedobservations; notresolvedfindings. Exactfinalfullparallel48/0/3 and priorqualifiedrepeated/negativecontrols documented. CurrentLinuxfullCI stillmandatory; no merge/deployment/readyclaim.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

CI 39698560229 on 24fb0fbc failed at the factory prose fixture: domestic177/0/2 and the original S16 case passed; runtime47/1/3. Phase0 v000903 produced its strict positive on attempt0, then repeating city preparation for v000901 exceeded the15-second phase guard. No CI rerun was requested.

The next test-only correction prepares canonical weather twice once per phase, then retains both version-specific national oracles. The versions share23input stages/cache keys; their icon-tail difference is output formatting. The15-second guard,4attempt ceiling,15cities,exact prose and runtime bounds stay unchanged. Local final-source repetition/full-suite validation and a new Linux CI are pending. Prior source PASS is not readiness; no merge.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Independent required source review: Claude Opus5.5, medium — PASS for 0c163912 / base 307defeb, candidate 7d0e891a…. Plan mode observed; enforced isolation unverified.13committed hashes and22declaredpaths checked;11runtime files unchangedc7d2. CI-003 Required/Medium source repair accepted, actual Linux CI39701583980 still required. CLA-004 guard-message improvement applied/resolved; helper optional/unselected. CI-002 remains resolved; OAI-001/CLA-001/CLA-002 remain unselected, no follow-up.

Final source10/10functionalPASS and40nationattempt0;5unattributedpeerrefusals are recorded, not zero. The extra diagnostic harness stop is retained. Runtime full-suite test log reports35.68s; JSON35.79s measures the entire Cargo command. Author narrative's inherited zero-refusal sentence was corrected via SV7 with originals preserved; source and test results unchanged. Actual pinned source review is reused after this evidence-only amendment, not rerun or represented as new execution. Linux CI pending; no GitHub approval/readiness/merge claim.

Full independent source return

Showing 1 of 150 activities (limited to 1)

판정

소스 리뷰 기준 PASS입니다. 새 Required finding은 없습니다.

Linux 전체 CI 39701583980은 아직 pending입니다. CI-003이 실제로 해소됐는지와 머지 준비 여부는 이 CI 결과로만 판단할 수 있습니다. 이 PASS는 CI 통과, GitHub 승인, 머지 준비 완료를 뜻하지 않습니다.

  • HEAD: 0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd (직접 확인, working tree clean)
  • BASE: 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f
  • Candidate: sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9
  • 리뷰어: Claude Opus 5.5 (claude-opus-5-5). effort 값은 제게 보이지 않아 적지 않습니다.

직접 확인한 것

  • Candidate 해시: candidate.json의 13개 파일 sha256을 git show HEAD:<path>로 다시 계산했고 불일치는 0건입니다.
  • runtime 동일성: c7d2 이후 바뀐 파일은 inventory.rs와 task 선언 두 개뿐입니다. 나머지 runtime 11개 파일은 c7d2와 같습니다.
  • 선언과 경로: task 선언은 24fb와 같고, 307defeb..HEAD는 22개 경로입니다.
  • inventory.rs: HEAD의 sha256은 10399ff0…이고, factory-repeat-v5.json에 기록된 10회 실행의 해시와 같습니다.
  • diff: 24fb..HEAD의 inventory.rs diff 전체를 읽었습니다. chain.rs:355-367(두 버전이 앞 23단계를 공유하는 부분)은 이전 턴에서 읽은 내용을 근거로 합니다.

로그 확인 (집계는 직접 했고, 실행은 하지 않았습니다)

  • factory-final-v5-1..10.log: 10회 모두 1 passed입니다. READY attempt=0이 40건, TASK2850_PEER_SLOT_REJECT가 5건입니다. 10회 모두 exit 0이고, 같은 inventory.rs 해시로 실행됐으며 거절 합계도 5건이라 기록과 맞습니다.
  • runtime-full-final-v5.log: 48 통과, 0 실패, 3 ignored, 35.68초입니다. 요청문에는 35.79초로 적혀 있어 수치가 다르니 json과 대조해 주세요.
  • ci-v4-full-failed.log: phase 0의 v000903 READY 직후 :747 guard에서 실패했고, runtime 결과는 47/1입니다. CI-003 설명과 맞습니다.
  • 열지 않은 파일: checks-v5, smoke-v5, artifact-staged/outgoing-v5, diagnosis-v5.md, claude-peer-qualification-v5.md, 그리고 build/self-verification/test-results/documentation 파일은 열지 않았습니다. 이 결과들은 요청문에 적힌 내용만 근거로 합니다.

5개 축 (fixture 변경분)

  • 정확성:
    • city 준비는 phase마다 v000903으로, 엄격한 2 pass를 한 번만 합니다.
    • 그 뒤의 nation 루프는 두 버전 모두 그대로입니다: 15개 도시, 정확한 prose 일치, assert_response, 4회 상한, 15초 phase guard, 가상 시간 고정 assertion.
    • 두 버전이 앞 23단계 입력을 공유하므로 forecast cache key가 같습니다. 그래서 v000901 준비는 중복이었고, 빼도 oracle이 약해지지 않습니다.
  • 가독성: guard 메시지와 elapsed_ms 출력이 추가돼 진단이 좋아졌습니다.
    • 사소한 점: _pass가 실제로 쓰이므로 밑줄 없는 pass가 관례에 맞습니다. Clippy 기본 설정은 이를 경고하지 않으므로 선택 사항입니다.
  • 아키텍처: 테스트 파일만 바뀌었고 runtime bound는 그대로입니다. 선언된 경로 안의 변경입니다.
  • 보안: 해당 사항 없습니다. 출력되는 오류 본문은 2048바이트까지이고 fixture 데이터입니다.
  • 성능: phase당 준비 횟수가 절반이 됐습니다. 로컬에서 phase당 604–782ms입니다.

Findings

  • CI-003 — Required / Medium / test-correctness: 소스 수준에서 해소됐습니다.
    • 원인: 24fb에서 버전마다 반복한 city 준비가 Linux에서 15초 phase guard를 넘겼습니다.
    • 이번 수정은 그 원인에 직접 대응하고 oracle도 유지합니다.
    • 실제 해소 여부는 Linux CI 39701583980이 통과해야 확정됩니다. 그 전까지는 "소스 수준 해소, CI pending"으로 기록해야 합니다.
  • CLA-004 — Recommended / Low / readability: 선택되어 적용됐습니다. 준비 단계 guard에 phase/city/pass 메시지가 생겼고, 성공 시 elapsed_ms를 출력합니다. 해소로 인정합니다. helper 추출은 미선택이며 그대로 둬도 됩니다.
  • CI-002 — Required / High: c7d2에서 해소된 상태를 유지합니다. runtime이 그 뒤로 바뀌지 않았습니다.
  • OAI-001, CLA-001, CLA-002 — Recommended / Low: 미선택이고 follow-up도 없습니다. 이번 diff로 분류가 바뀌지 않습니다.
  • CLA-003: 만들지 않았습니다.

남은 한계 (finding 아님)

  • peer 거절: 통과한 10회 실행에서 귀속되지 않은 거절이 5건 있었습니다.
    • 이것은 flake 위험 신호이지 기능 결함이 아닙니다. 원래 oracle에는 거절 0건 조건이 없습니다.
    • 거절 0건이었다거나, 거절이 백그라운드에서만 났다고 주장하면 안 됩니다.
    • 처음 harness가 3회 후 멈춘 기록(factory-initialmatrix-v5.json)도 보존해야 합니다.
    • 실제 Transport로 기능이 실패하면, fallback을 넣기 전에 원인부터 진단해야 합니다.
  • negative control: 이전 테스트 바이트(b53e…)로 실행한 결과를 재사용합니다. 엄격한 prose 검사는 같지만, 현재 바이트로 다시 실행한 것은 아닙니다.
  • Runtime Drop: blocking 작업을 기다리는 시간이 15초 guard 밖에 있습니다.
  • 원인 미상으로 남은 것: 이전 로컬 실행의 47/1 실패와 새 fixture에서 base가 낸 Capacity 오류는 원인 미상입니다. 둘 다 해소로 다시 분류하지 말아야 합니다.
  • artifact checker 순서: outgoing checker의 실행 순서는 검증되지 않았습니다. 두 checker 모두 최종적으로 PASS였지만, push 전에 끝났다고 주장할 수 없습니다.

이번에도 파일 수정, 빌드, 네트워크 사용, 게시, 위임은 하지 않았습니다.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Candidate evidence archive — 0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd — verification-v5-evidence (1/2). Full structured records retained beyond ephemeral CI artifacts. CI/review status is separate; this is not merge authorization.

candidate.json

Original SHA256 4c27e736349e1d858e189f4dd1467d7fb09cee42f73b39b4fa9b35bbbd750879; display SHA256 4c27e736349e1d858e189f4dd1467d7fb09cee42f73b39b4fa9b35bbbd750879. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "runtime_and_verification_files": {
    "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406",
    "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8",
    "server2/src/cache/disk.rs": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2",
    "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8",
    "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f",
    "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9",
    "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38",
    "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs": "10399ff06dff447be58ae14671dbe33b6509920783b0a48ab6d6e9662c37030b"
  },
  "scope": "Original runtime implementation at c7d2 unchanged;13declared runtime/test/tool files including scoped factory test. Per-phase current-thread runtime tears down owners/pool; bounded persistent peer and2strict city passes preserve original oracle. Base new-fixture Capacity not attributed or claimed repaired."
}
candidate-commit.json

Original SHA256 63f1c33996d95e2b8d296d6296feea9b9ef99a12fc66c191ea365c3bf135e889; display SHA256 63f1c33996d95e2b8d296d6296feea9b9ef99a12fc66c191ea365c3bf135e889. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "head": "0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "clean": true,
  "committed_hash_mismatches": 0
}
build-receipt.json

Original SHA256 6cde7c00ce7b27f6d44e3828cfbabdfa9b1a3152f896941e1dbb2de3786a09eb; display SHA256 6cde7c00ce7b27f6d44e3828cfbabdfa9b1a3152f896941e1dbb2de3786a09eb. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "iteration": 6,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "build deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "0800a4c41ed570b1927ccd7ca610fee47cfb2cac54a9de5fed5dd4a132cf6fba"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "7f1019fc71d2e833b1034e2536f5d160eac99318817321b18c55b7667ea3d288"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs",
      "sha256": "10399ff06dff447be58ae14671dbe33b6509920783b0a48ab6d6e9662c37030b"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed build evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}
self-verification-receipt.json

Original SHA256 d3c113f265120d2bdeaf4cd7ad6e8d81935a5ca80666474e29ff03703d95315b; display SHA256 d3c113f265120d2bdeaf4cd7ad6e8d81935a5ca80666474e29ff03703d95315b. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "iteration": 7,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "Narrative stale count corrected to actual5, unchanged candidate and actual execution results reassessed",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "next_action": "Accept same pinned independent source reviews and await actual LinuxCI; no source changes",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "0800a4c41ed570b1927ccd7ca610fee47cfb2cac54a9de5fed5dd4a132cf6fba"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "7f1019fc71d2e833b1034e2536f5d160eac99318817321b18c55b7667ea3d288"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs",
      "sha256": "10399ff06dff447be58ae14671dbe33b6509920783b0a48ab6d6e9662c37030b"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "ef646d6752fa59ffd0128e10ebc96dc5ee1ea75ab23b75d415216ed8b4b5a231"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "08ad1976cb10c2072934258cc14a1605b57b0a25a9d4220e9005602e93504542"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "d3f59ac2d01c7acb7830dfe2be67fed4ed0132a864631b287f510138c2983d34"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v5.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d4ac4516e4ad3fd3414ba4769d8c5757d58a4d475d63a4b2761dfb4a0f5a1dc7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-v4-full-failed.log",
      "sha256": "7cc4f23b00d751d08b3c5e7ce8a860e477b83678c9e1df356e7000d590da204c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-guard-diagnosis-v5.md",
      "sha256": "46376a6eb88bbdded4cac0f12c019c8f9a5e90cf60a5c3227e6e1473b4ea6024"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-peer-qualification-v5.md",
      "sha256": "298048891461e017e4b25b435a6ec78e8f50085f96ffdcb9838a0536a3f9f367"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v5.log",
      "sha256": "8124217857682ae56c2fcacb18cd071094de9ce33f44b630277d33b34bfe01df"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v5.md",
      "sha256": "558223ede67e58749a774edc713f3c40605f511d5382cbde13c5da3ad4a030a5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-1.log",
      "sha256": "3bc7d7dc64eb8c2b2eb9de6de1382b1ad65ea07f3dca7d2c3cf38d4ab9bac6c5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-10.log",
      "sha256": "d870ddb72049ea5ab97333995f127e0a3b425d6cddd66a4bb6055692e4bf9291"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-2.log",
      "sha256": "237dd650bfd6035bd0b5f3a411727eaeee3d2d5dad92a14c214518ef507a67a0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-3.log",
      "sha256": "6b20290108eaf9a1ef86883b0dbef3daffeb29a55be8c903fc88d59d254f4f50"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-4.log",
      "sha256": "794fc3e1f858527249e4e9cea51b13cbcd3813ff2fc026b2ac61ac6dbca19299"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-5.log",
      "sha256": "1904df457c5f1fa504f082ca72d2a3cbd6375d818506225a46f8e452c642561e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-6.log",
      "sha256": "2733c81350a4713ac3e40f29c3cbd9a1df6e21583bcba5aefaec3c0a787c61ff"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-7.log",
      "sha256": "026f3b4171b7528e93fe3ba817b4eb3b127a76a56a194af661ab97de617cd9f1"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-8.log",
      "sha256": "6a3161ccaa57eb7a2a02944478d7960b7b119c42d1d645f5715327a041909f2e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-9.log",
      "sha256": "57366d0b0d16d59901622142f4605f223c34b34096c4e95d0e36dcdb81502269"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-initialmatrix-v5.json",
      "sha256": "51a686e98fab690012a80fe788ed0f213482e217c9b951d41faadd12288c34bf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-repeat-v5.json",
      "sha256": "918d42183cce64e71a609c656c4eb60d986797b0fe948ce413de4ad6c1462332"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v5-execution.json",
      "sha256": "0117e00e1218a1d3d391cf97f9ab6b6c72c883012ed95ebe6183984921da82d6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.json",
      "sha256": "6a3d01c2bf3049c181a6b25000ef83acfd22b24d21976d4aa6119b70014e31c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.log",
      "sha256": "0e6ebe7165c483c2cbca07a1b722896871327b052054cf08cc5f90c24c421e41"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v5.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v5.log",
      "sha256": "e7caabddae0c9524357f4cb13489a704c398750bf42888f9468d1a3ba8768222"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v5.json",
      "sha256": "504000acbb96b68040941a2225e89405e5902e8534974ef2b09333e39ff61bbd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v5.log",
      "sha256": "397c89b35c710b8cc5824f2ae5abb905e2f8a3de22291f51d4d0685d0676c622"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-v4.log",
      "sha256": "cca9412561d8b558c49f5281bb6720fcc6b9073154364a4cc720651345e362c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5-execution.json",
      "sha256": "e768163e175aff481c903afc703448ed9630db01ed38bcd6ddf30a1253184a9b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5.log",
      "sha256": "3f2ffc40a398bfb80a7ce681b4976514c3b17ec74cff608588b2b6ac84acff35"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-v5-zero-refusal-diagnostic.py",
      "sha256": "fc50c127b767cc452f2cc6e58f1ab9c52065cdfacbf0b7df5081fac6016211df"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed self-verification evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Candidate evidence archive — 0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd — verification-v5-evidence (2/2). Full structured records retained beyond ephemeral CI artifacts. CI/review status is separate; this is not merge authorization.

test-results.json

Original SHA256 08ad1976cb10c2072934258cc14a1605b57b0a25a9d4220e9005602e93504542; display SHA256 c4f16307e0b08e464109342956af9f15f5c6e471f1024feac50d061a736a60be. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "verification_mode": "tdd",
  "refactor_performed": false,
  "scenarios": [
    {
      "id": "M1",
      "requirement": "AC4",
      "required": true,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 release; owned IPv4 loopback S3 and native HTTP",
      "prerequisites": "Copied/hash-bound example; original730 acquisitions/851 pages; Off provider and no geocoder",
      "actions": "Run seed, complete13-view diagnostic and fresh native HTTP after focused checks",
      "expected": "All13 golden views and original42549B HTTP hash; children/listeners retire",
      "failure": "Changed response, missing golden, timeout, external call or leaked process",
      "cleanup": "Runner reaps all children and peer; evidence retained"
    },
    {
      "id": "M2",
      "requirement": "AC1",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Real cache/writer code with injected bounded dependencies",
      "prerequisites": "Two cached town keys and held writer/build futures",
      "actions": "Read unrelated key during acquisition, then abort/panic and overlap a build",
      "expected": "Same pin and zero counters; no stale flight/installation",
      "failure": "Global clearing, recycled live state or stale installation",
      "cleanup": "Test futures join/abort and cache dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M3",
      "requirement": "AC2",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Fixed clocks and full retained corpus",
      "prerequisites": "Golden pure selectors and existing source builders",
      "actions": "Cross minute and exact publication/retention/day/month/future/rewind boundaries",
      "expected": "Reuse only within interval; all13 answers equal reference replay",
      "failure": "Early refold or stale result at equality",
      "cleanup": "Owned peers/cache scopes retired"
    },
    {
      "id": "M4",
      "requirement": "AC3",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Owned catalog peer and final release example",
      "prerequisites": "Complete canonical scope and bounded30s policy",
      "actions": "Renew unchanged; publish newer same-partition acquisition; inject failed LIST",
      "expected": "Zero raw/descriptor/parse/fold unchanged, newer visible after delay, failed check not renewed",
      "failure": "LIST-only stale identity or expired fallback",
      "cleanup": "Peer and Sources dropped"
    },
    {
      "id": "M5",
      "requirement": "AC5",
      "required": false,
      "environment": "Actual staged Git index and final docs",
      "prerequisites": "Exact path declaration and preserved generated metadata",
      "actions": "Check placement, source hashes, docs/diagram, fmt/Clippy and staged artifact policy",
      "expected": "Declared paths, resolvable links, current docs, no new runtime flag/dependency",
      "failure": "Undeclared implementation or generated output staged",
      "cleanup": "Checks read-only, no index/source mutation"
    }
  ],
  "earlier_failures": [
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/integration-retention.log",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "8/9; assertion used Doc root t1h instead of retained currentData.t1h; corrected oracle, release9/9 passed"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-retention-v2.log",
      "observed": "Test-module qualification compile error, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-foundation-failed.log",
      "observed": "Original full CI173passed/4failed; exact four compatibility cases pass in corrected runs above; old independent PASS is revision-bound"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-local.log",
      "observed": "Sandbox peer bind denied; setup failure, not intended Red"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-green.log",
      "observed": "Explicit-drop MutexGuard across await compile error; fixed with lexical scope"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-final.log",
      "observed": "Cross-module test NOW/until compile error; corrected test scope"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v2-final2.log",
      "observed": "Test transport was intentionally unreachable; moved held-writer reconstruction to Empty transport regression"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-regression-v2.log",
      "observed": "Filter selected zero checks; not credited; correct fault_tests filter passed8"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v2.log",
      "observed": "Generated delivery sidecar outside declaration; archived with matching hash in .archify recovery-v6 before final placement check"
    }
  ],
  "retained_failed_runs": [
    {
      "candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --test domestic",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "148pass/29fail/2ignored; predominantly local publish/seed Transport/Ambiguous across unrelated modules. Serial scheduling also failed140pass/37fail/2ignored, predominantly publish/seed Transport.24283TIME_WAIT peak; no test assertions or OS settings changed. Separate serial log retained.",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/domestic-v3.log"
    },
    {
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-v4.log",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "observed": "47 pass/1 factory fail/3 ignored; panic detail suppressed; retained separately, not erased by later pass."
    }
  ],
  "exact_original_reproduction": "Original CI own-acquisition test passed locally once before correction; deterministic Red comes from held-writer overlay test, not that complete scenario.",
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "R-key",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "307defeb+isolation-test",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib actual_writer_future_invalidates -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: unrelated Current view count0 instead of1",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-boundary",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-key-fences-before-boundary",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --lib selector_interval_crosses -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: arbitrary minute expired fold",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-renew",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-boundaries-before-renewal",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic unchanged_controls_renew -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: no real control LIST after bounded interval",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-disk",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "issue2850-renewal-before-folded-disk",
      "command": "cargo test --locked --offline --test domestic process_restart_restores_folded -- --nocapture",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64, Rust1.99.0; release except recorded initial development runs; bounded test dependencies",
      "observed": "Expected failure: restart parsed1 acquisition instead of0",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-CI-writer",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "sha256:afffa182a520e1eb46d69cfa242e7e3dd303e198dd46182f0c5da51b3c77abc9",
      "command": "cargo test --release --test domestic latest_short_late_first_demand_does_not_replay_missed_slots",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo, bounded owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Existing source compatibility failure reproduced exactly: forecast view boundary during in-flight same-key acquisition",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-overlay",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "66be97c8+overlay-regression-test",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --lib overlay_preserves_complete_parent_identity_during_same_key_backfill",
      "exit_code": 101,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Expected assertion failure: complete immutable parent lost completeness under held same-key writer",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "R-CI003-phase-guard",
      "phase": "red",
      "candidate": "24fb0fbc6960430c67415f95241331fa686404ec",
      "command": "GitHub Server2 workflow39698560229 foundation full workspace tests",
      "exit_code": 1,
      "environment": "GitHub hosted Linux; real bounded loopback test peer",
      "observed": "Exact intended before-correction failure: factory city preparation exceeds15second phaseguard after firstversion strictpositive. domestic177passed includingS16.",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-v4-full-failed.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "intended_failure": true
    },
    {
      "id": "G-final-repeat-v5",
      "phase": "green",
      "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
      "command": "10 exact filtered runtime_services executions, main final source unchanged",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Exact finalsource10399ff0 runs1..10 actualtestPASS,40nationattempt0,phase604\u2013782ms;5unattributedpeerrefusals recorded separately. Originalzero-refusaldiagnosticharnessstoppedafter3actualPASS; preserved and remaining7samebytescompleted without changingoriginalfunctionaloracle.",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-repeat-v5.json",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "G-factory-suite-v5",
      "phase": "green",
      "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --test runtime_services",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "48 passed /0 failed /3 ignored in default parallel suite; exact final test source",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v5.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "clippy-v5",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh clippy --offline --locked --all-targets -- -D warnings",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v5.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "fmt-v5",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh fmt --all -- --check",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v5-execution.json",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "python-v5",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 -B -m unittest server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v5.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "placement-v5",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 server2/tools/check_placement.py --root . --declaration server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json --base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v5.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "artifact-staged-v5",
      "phase": "regression",
      "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
      "command": "python3 scripts/check-artifact-policy.py --staged",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Actual exit0; detailed output/metadata retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v5.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed"
    },
    {
      "id": "M1-six-mode-v5",
      "phase": "smoke",
      "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
      "command": "python3 -B server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py --binary ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin-v3/domestic_warm_cache_smoke --output ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5 --build-variant release --modes seed diagnostic http disk http-disk disk-boundary",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; owned loopback peers and denied provider stubs; no production",
      "observed": "Six owned children exit0; original13 goldens and42549B HTTP hash; restore/renew0raw/parse/fold; three-hour boundary replay",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "scenario_id": "M1",
      "executed_runtime_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Fresh task smoke on unchanged c7d2 runtime/example/tools binary; later changes exclusively test/declaration/docs."
    }
  ],
  "reused_checks": [
    {
      "id": "G-overlay-module",
      "phase": "green",
      "command": "cargo test --release --offline --locked --lib domestic::kma::source::forecast",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "16 passed, including complete overlay parent and partial-parent/no-admission controls",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-clippy-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh clippy --offline --locked --all-targets -- -D warnings",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-fmt-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh fmt --all -- --check",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-example-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh build --release --offline --locked --example domestic_warm_cache_smoke",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-unit-v3-final",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --lib forecast_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "17passed including unchanged Mid compatibility and new overlay regression",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-late-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic latest_short_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "6passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-backfill-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic a_backfill_pass_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "2passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-concurrent-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic concurrent_first_requests_share_one_acquisition_per_publication",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "1passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-cache-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic forecast_cache::",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "9passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-summary-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --test domestic summary_",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "10passed including unchanged own-acquisition S16 identity",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-disk-v3",
      "phase": "post-refactor",
      "command": "sh ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh test --release --offline --locked --lib cache::disk::fault_tests",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "8 shared DiskCache checks passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-python-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 -B -m unittest server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "7 Python checks passed",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-placement-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 server2/tools/check_placement.py --root . --declaration server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json --base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Actual command exit0; stdout retained",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "M-full-v3",
      "phase": "smoke",
      "command": "/opt/homebrew/bin/python3 -B server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py --binary ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin-v3/domestic_warm_cache_smoke --output ${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3 --build-variant release --modes seed diagnostic http disk http-disk disk-boundary",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Darwin ARM64 Rust1.99 release; offline Cargo; bounded injected dependencies and owned loopback peers; no real AWS/provider",
      "observed": "Six children exit0; 13original goldens, original42549B HTTP hash, restore/renew0raw/parse/fold and independent3h replay preserved",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "scenario_id": "M1",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "V-staged-v3",
      "phase": "regression",
      "command": "python3 scripts/check-artifact-policy.py --staged",
      "exit_code": 0,
      "environment": "Actual two-file staged index",
      "observed": "PASS; intended staged source and maintained evidence only",
      "evidence": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "execution_kind": "real",
      "status": "passed",
      "executed_candidate": "sha256:b81fd394848a38f4fa56a36f06169e2c37c9a2b9a9ee6a2cefdb19f170e41cab",
      "reuse_rationale": "Runtime, domestic tests and smoke tooling byte-identical to c7d2; current changes only declaration, factory test and selected documentation. Original command/result retained, not newly executed."
    }
  ],
  "refactor_note": "Fixture setup movement completed before final Green, no post-Green refactor; original runtime post-refactor logs retained as qualified reuse.",
  "fixture_qualification": {
    "head_isolated": "Exact finalsource10399ff0 runs1..10 actualtestPASS,40nationattempt0,phase604\u2013782ms;5unattributedpeerrefusals recorded separately. Originalzero-refusaldiagnosticharnessstoppedafter3actualPASS; preserved and remaining7samebytescompleted without changingoriginalfunctionaloracle.",
    "negative_control": "reader disconnected: exact stored-prose assertion fails101; runtime restored hash-exact",
    "base_new_fixture": "first run city502; separate probe raw storage Capacity,0peer refusals; internal origin unknown; no base10 pass claimed",
    "full_parallel_history": "Initial main selected fixture47pass/1factoryfail/3ignored, no panic detail. Temporary source diagnostic then48pass/0fail/3ignored; restored source exact. Final diagnostic wrapper preserves panic and prints reason, city assertion retains body. No claim that initial intermittent failure was causally resolved.",
    "current_ci_red": "CI39698560229 on24fb domestic177pass/S16ok; runtime47/1/3,phase0v903positive then duplicatev901cityprep15secguard. Newonceperphaseprep removesthatredundancy; sameguard/strictbothversionoracles/runtimebounds. CurrentLinuxpending."
  }
}
documentation.json

Original SHA256 d3f59ac2d01c7acb7830dfe2be67fed4ed0132a864631b287f510138c2983d34; display SHA256 d3f59ac2d01c7acb7830dfe2be67fed4ed0132a864631b287f510138c2983d34. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "checked": true,
  "summary": "Transparent internal cache retention/restore optimization preserves every product API/CLI/UI operation and HTTP bytes. No new user workflow or feature surface; existing operator Markdown and architecture/Archify are updated and checked. README/API unchanged. No new screenshot PDF manual applies. Diagram artifact/actual Chrome and viewed light/dark captures passed; metadata preserved locally.",
  "new_feature": false,
  "ux_ui_changed": false,
  "updates": [
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/server2.md",
      "sha256": "7ef7a1fa0e181a3f50342e0effe0e5689721ea0b8a39dc58849e5ac158561121"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/operations/server2-domestic-cache.md",
      "sha256": "e6c49e800df20a1b216752c3119407d508a0d5176c04d628b361990f3c49387c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "maintained-document",
      "path": "docs/evidence/tasks/issue-2850/verification.md",
      "sha256": "f7a2fa8f1b8e06404613dd3281882cae4cfb1b3b6f6cb550f9071d46ece3d76d"
    }
  ],
  "manual": null,
  "correction_note": "Test-only factory preparation/runtime teardown; runtime source and Archify/operator contract unchanged; original performance remains explicitly historic. Selected evidence includes baseline limitations and parallel failure history."
}
self-verification.md

Original SHA256 ef646d6752fa59ffd0128e10ebc96dc5ee1ea75ab23b75d415216ed8b4b5a231; display SHA256 ef646d6752fa59ffd0128e10ebc96dc5ee1ea75ab23b75d415216ed8b4b5a231. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

# Current fixture candidate self-verification

sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9, base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f. Only declaration, inventory test and selected evidence changed sincec7d2; unchanged runtime hash proof in candidate.json. Actual current full runtime_services48passed/0failed/3ignored; all-targetClippy-Dwarnings,fmt,Python7,placement and staged artifact checks passed. Required smokeM1:1/1 fresh six-mode run on hash-bound unchanged runtime binary. Prior53focusedRust checks and c7d2Linux domestic177pass are qualified reuse, not newly run commands.

Initial selected main full parallel47/1/3 had no panic detail; temporary diagnostic full suite then48/0/3 and exact source restoration; final wrapper preserves panic result and exposes errors. Initial intermittent cause remains unproved. Final exact-source head10/10 gives40nation attempt0 and5unattributedpeerrefusals; phase elapsed604–782ms. Zero-refusal is not claimed. Reader-disconnection negative control fails exact-prose assertion; restored runtime hash. Base selected fixture fails city502/Capacity with0peer rejects, internal Capacity source unknown; no base10/backport claim. Original base fixture4Busy failures separately preserved.

Original strict oracle and runtime limits remain. Additional functional six-mode smoke preserves13goldens/originalHTTP SHAa6462aba8ad9ec34d8efdcab4ccd2f37b00339a301fd17caa7c1e5485d45b283; restore/renew no forecast raw/descriptor GET/parse/fold;3hboundary replay. Real loopback only, provider/geocoder0. Started blocking work can delay Runtime drop outside15sec phase guard; isolated runs short, not a proof of no hang.

AC1keyfences/overlay,AC2selector,AC3identityrenewal,AC4disk/fault/restart,AC5docs/placement assessed through unchanged qualified evidence and current checks. Archifyv6 JSON/HTML/browser/visual evidence reused hash-identical; no UI feature/manualPDF applies. Selected performance tables remain66be measurement. Full Linux CI and renewed exact-head independent reviews pending; no readiness/merge/deployment claim. Logs/binaries/recovery retained, shared target pending all consumers.

Current refinement: once-per-phase2citypasses via903 then bothnationversions. CI-003 Required/Medium is the actual24fb Linux15secduplicate-setupfailure; source correction and currentlocaltests pass, newCIstillpending. CLA004guardmessage applied (helperoptionalunselected). Exact finalsource10/10/40nationattempt0,phase604–782ms;5peerrefusalsunattributed, diagnosticthresholdstop preserved; nozerorefusalclaim. Earlierisolated10zerorefusals belongsolderrevision. Finalfull48/0/3 and freshsixmodev5smoke pass.

Narrative erratum: a stale sentence was corrected to5; raw10run logs, test-results.json and explicit current-count appendix already said5. OriginalSV6 narrative/receipt preserved inrevision-v5-sv6; source/commits/candidate/check results unchanged. No new execution claimed.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Independent additional source review: Grok4.7, high — PASS for 0c163912 / base 307defeb, candidate 7d0e891a…. Mode unknown; enforced isolation unverified.13hashes,22paths and2file correction diff verified. No new GROK finding. CI-003 source repair and CLA-004 selected diagnostics accepted; actual full LinuxCI39701583980 remains required. CI-002 resolved; OAI-001/CLA-001/CLA-002 unselected, no follow-up.

Actual10/10functionalPASS,40nationattempt0,5unattributedpeerrefusals; zero is not claimed. Initial extra diagnostic-threshold stop retained. Grok read the SV7 corrected narrative: administrative review5BLOCKED addressed an author report count error, not source behavior. Current source PASS is accepted under review6 with the same pin; no duplicate execution claimed. Full runtime test35.68s versus whole Cargo command35.79s distinguished. No GitHub approval/readiness/merge claim.

Full independent return

Showing 1 of 357 activities (limited to 1)

PASS. 소스 판정입니다. GitHub 승인도 머지 준비 완료도 아닙니다. Linux CI 39701583980은 아직 별도 조건입니다. SV7이 고친 서술을 읽었습니다. review5의 BLOCKED는 소스 판정이 아니라, 예전 문장이 peer 거절을 0건으로 적은 보고서 오류입니다.

검토자: Grok 4.7. 이 세션에서 모드 id는 보지 못했고 mode_verified는 false입니다. 선택적 Grok 리뷰이며 필수 리뷰어를 대체하지 않습니다. 소스, Cargo, 빌드, 네트워크, 발행은 하지 않았습니다.

신원

HEAD 0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd, base 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f, 작업 트리는 clean입니다. candidate sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9를 13개 파일의 정렬 compact JSON으로 다시 계산해 일치했습니다. inventory.rs는 10399ff06dff447be58ae14671dbe33b6509920783b0a48ab6d6e9662c37030b입니다. 24fb..HEAD는 inventory.rs와 verification.md뿐입니다. 선언 cff3073b…는 24fb와 같고, 런타임·도구 11개 파일은 c7d2a5d2와 같습니다. forecast_cache.rs는 12eb79e1…입니다. 선언 경로는 22개입니다. verification.md 해시 f7a2fa8f…는 documentation.json과 같습니다.

다섯 축

정확성. phase마다 v000903으로 15도시를 200으로 두 번만 준비합니다. 이어서 v000903과 v000901의 국가 응답을 그대로 검사합니다. 정확한 prose, assert_response, 최대 4회, 같은 phase_started의 15초 guard, pause 후 가상시각 동일 단언이 남아 있습니다. ForecastKey::Grid는 family와 격자만 쓰고 API 버전은 없습니다. current/shortest backfill reach는 23입니다. 아이콘 표기만 IconCase::Lower(v000903)와 Upper(v000901)로 다릅니다. 그래서 두 번째 버전의 도시 준비를 반복하지 않는 수정은 관측된 15초 초과와 맞습니다. guard는 늘리거나 리셋하지 않았습니다.

가독성. 도시 15초 단언 문구에 phase, city, pass가 있고, 국가 성공 로그에 elapsed_ms가 있습니다. helper 추출은 없습니다.

구조. 제품 scheduler, admission, owner 한도는 이 diff에 없습니다. persistent peer는 canonical S3를 유지하고, phase runtime drop은 테스트 harness입니다.

보안. 새 비밀은 없습니다. 도시 오류 본문 진단은 2048바이트로 잘립니다.

성능. 추가 요청은 이 테스트와 15초 실시간 guard 안입니다. Runtime drop은 그 guard 밖에 있으며, drop이 막히지 않는다는 증명은 아닙니다.

직접 본 것과 로그만 본 것

소스로 본 것: 위 2파일 diff, cache key, backfill 23, IconCase, 해시 재계산.

로그에서 결과 줄을 센 것:

  • ci-v4-full-failed.log: domestic 177 passed; 0 failed; 2 ignored, S16 own-acquisition ok. 그 뒤 FACTORY_PROSE_READY phase=0 version=v000903 attempt=0, inventory.rs:747에서 phase_started.elapsed() < 15s 실패, runtime 47 passed; 1 failed; 3 ignored. 이것이 CI-003입니다. 24fb 소스의 lifecycle PASS는 이 CI 준비 완료가 아니었습니다.
  • factory-final-v5-1..10.log: 10/10 기능 통과, READY 40줄 모두 attempt=0, elapsed_ms 604–782. TASK2850_PEER_SLOT_REJECT는 3회차 2, 4회차 2, 8회차 1, 합계 5입니다. 0건도 아니고 백그라운드 전용으로 단정하지도 않습니다. stderr와 stdout 순서는 소유 구간을 증명하지 않습니다.
  • factory-initialmatrix-v5.json: 같은 inventory 해시로 1·2회차는 거절 0, 3회차는 기능 통과 뒤 거절 2에서 멈춥니다. test-v5-zero-refusal-diagnostic.py의 peer_refusals==0은 원래 oracle이 아닌 추가 조건입니다. 이 조기 종료는 숨기지 않습니다. 나머지 7회는 같은 기능 oracle로 기록되었습니다.
  • runtime-full-final-v5.log: factory ok, 48 passed; 0 failed; 3 ignored; finished in 35.68s. JSON elapsed는 35.79초이고 inventory 해시는 10399ff0…입니다.
  • Clippy는 Finished. Python은 Ran 7 tests OK. placement는 PASS. staged artifact는 1 snapshot(s), outgoing은 5 snapshot(s) 통과입니다. outgoing 로그에는 완료 시각이 없어, PTY 10초 반환 뒤 push가 폴링보다 먼저 시작했다는 순서 주장은 확인하지 못했습니다. 두 검사의 최종 exit 0만 확인했습니다.
  • smoke-v5.log 6모드 exit 0. 바이너리 b51244fc…는 bin-v3이며 c7d2 런타임에 묶입니다.

재실행하지 않은 것: 53개 focused Rust, c7d2 Linux domestic 177, 이전 smoke 측정.

안정 지적

ID 심각도 축 위치 처분
CI-003 Required / Medium 테스트 정확성 24fb inventory.rs:747, Linux 39698560229 소스에서 해소. 도시 준비는 phase당 v000903 두 번이고, 두 버전 국가 oracle은 유지. 로컬 10/10과 48/0/3은 확인. Linux 39701583980이 끝나기 전에는 CI 종료가 아님
CLA-004 Recommended / Low 가독성 도시 15초 단언과 READY elapsed_ms 선택분이 소스에 반영됨. phase/city/pass와 성공 elapsed를 확인. helper 추출은 미선택 유지
CI-002 Required / High 정확성 forecast_cache.rs, S16 c7d2에서 해소 유지. 런타임 해시 불변. 재오픈하지 않음
OAI-001 Recommended / Low 검증 manifest/cache 테스트 not-selected, follow-up 없음
CLA-001 Recommended / Low 정확성 rejoin not-selected. 같은 런타임 해시
CLA-002 Recommended / Low 문서 specs/issue-2850.md AC1 not-selected. spec은 이번 diff에 없음

새 GROK 지적 없음. CLA-003 없음. peer 거절 5건은 flake 신호입니다. 기능 Transport 실패가 확인되기 전에는 fallback queue를 요구하지 않습니다.

서술 정정

현재 self-verification.md 5행과 11행은 최종 10회에 대해 국가 attempt 0이 40이고 peer 거절은 5건이며 귀속되지 않는다고 적습니다. 0건 주장은 하지 않습니다. revision-v5-sv6/self-verification.md 5행에는 이전의 0peer rejects 문장이 보존되어 있습니다. 원본 로그와 test-results.json의 5건 집계가 맞습니다. base 502/Capacity의 내부 출처는 미상이고, base 10회, backport, #2850의 Capacity 수정 주장은 없습니다. 이전 reader disconnect의 exact prose 101과 복구 해시 a8500199…는 b53eb922… 테스트 바이트에 대한 재사용 근거이며, 현재 prose 단언은 같은 조건입니다.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Candidate evidence archive — 0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd — review-v5-evidence (1/2). Full structured records retained beyond ephemeral CI artifacts. CI/review status is separate; this is not merge authorization.

pr-review-receipt.json

Original SHA256 01a8c641c5ec584142735bbd89bb6a8c0e1e49f688b7f024d37a4467f3be133a; display SHA256 01a8c641c5ec584142735bbd89bb6a8c0e1e49f688b7f024d37a4467f3be133a. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "iteration": 6,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "pr-review deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "0800a4c41ed570b1927ccd7ca610fee47cfb2cac54a9de5fed5dd4a132cf6fba"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "7f1019fc71d2e833b1034e2536f5d160eac99318817321b18c55b7667ea3d288"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs",
      "sha256": "10399ff06dff447be58ae14671dbe33b6509920783b0a48ab6d6e9662c37030b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "ef646d6752fa59ffd0128e10ebc96dc5ee1ea75ab23b75d415216ed8b4b5a231"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "08ad1976cb10c2072934258cc14a1605b57b0a25a9d4220e9005602e93504542"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "d3f59ac2d01c7acb7830dfe2be67fed4ed0132a864631b287f510138c2983d34"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v5.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d4ac4516e4ad3fd3414ba4769d8c5757d58a4d475d63a4b2761dfb4a0f5a1dc7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-v4-full-failed.log",
      "sha256": "7cc4f23b00d751d08b3c5e7ce8a860e477b83678c9e1df356e7000d590da204c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-guard-diagnosis-v5.md",
      "sha256": "46376a6eb88bbdded4cac0f12c019c8f9a5e90cf60a5c3227e6e1473b4ea6024"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-peer-qualification-v5.md",
      "sha256": "298048891461e017e4b25b435a6ec78e8f50085f96ffdcb9838a0536a3f9f367"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v5.log",
      "sha256": "8124217857682ae56c2fcacb18cd071094de9ce33f44b630277d33b34bfe01df"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v5.md",
      "sha256": "558223ede67e58749a774edc713f3c40605f511d5382cbde13c5da3ad4a030a5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-1.log",
      "sha256": "3bc7d7dc64eb8c2b2eb9de6de1382b1ad65ea07f3dca7d2c3cf38d4ab9bac6c5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-10.log",
      "sha256": "d870ddb72049ea5ab97333995f127e0a3b425d6cddd66a4bb6055692e4bf9291"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-2.log",
      "sha256": "237dd650bfd6035bd0b5f3a411727eaeee3d2d5dad92a14c214518ef507a67a0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-3.log",
      "sha256": "6b20290108eaf9a1ef86883b0dbef3daffeb29a55be8c903fc88d59d254f4f50"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-4.log",
      "sha256": "794fc3e1f858527249e4e9cea51b13cbcd3813ff2fc026b2ac61ac6dbca19299"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-5.log",
      "sha256": "1904df457c5f1fa504f082ca72d2a3cbd6375d818506225a46f8e452c642561e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-6.log",
      "sha256": "2733c81350a4713ac3e40f29c3cbd9a1df6e21583bcba5aefaec3c0a787c61ff"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-7.log",
      "sha256": "026f3b4171b7528e93fe3ba817b4eb3b127a76a56a194af661ab97de617cd9f1"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-8.log",
      "sha256": "6a3161ccaa57eb7a2a02944478d7960b7b119c42d1d645f5715327a041909f2e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-9.log",
      "sha256": "57366d0b0d16d59901622142f4605f223c34b34096c4e95d0e36dcdb81502269"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-initialmatrix-v5.json",
      "sha256": "51a686e98fab690012a80fe788ed0f213482e217c9b951d41faadd12288c34bf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-repeat-v5.json",
      "sha256": "918d42183cce64e71a609c656c4eb60d986797b0fe948ce413de4ad6c1462332"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v5-execution.json",
      "sha256": "0117e00e1218a1d3d391cf97f9ab6b6c72c883012ed95ebe6183984921da82d6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.json",
      "sha256": "6a3d01c2bf3049c181a6b25000ef83acfd22b24d21976d4aa6119b70014e31c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.log",
      "sha256": "0e6ebe7165c483c2cbca07a1b722896871327b052054cf08cc5f90c24c421e41"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v5.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v5.log",
      "sha256": "e7caabddae0c9524357f4cb13489a704c398750bf42888f9468d1a3ba8768222"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v5.json",
      "sha256": "504000acbb96b68040941a2225e89405e5902e8534974ef2b09333e39ff61bbd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v5.log",
      "sha256": "397c89b35c710b8cc5824f2ae5abb905e2f8a3de22291f51d4d0685d0676c622"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-v4.log",
      "sha256": "cca9412561d8b558c49f5281bb6720fcc6b9073154364a4cc720651345e362c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5-execution.json",
      "sha256": "e768163e175aff481c903afc703448ed9630db01ed38bcd6ddf30a1253184a9b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5.log",
      "sha256": "3f2ffc40a398bfb80a7ce681b4976514c3b17ec74cff608588b2b6ac84acff35"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-v5-zero-refusal-diagnostic.py",
      "sha256": "fc50c127b767cc452f2cc6e58f1ab9c52065cdfacbf0b7df5081fac6016211df"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "pr-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pr-review.md",
      "sha256": "7debc8c24ea8eecd1ae1cb05bac8d65ed811a120065d89579828dda0594e6e30"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "f06672bde84f10bfda2cfee2861f0e62a802047282cf2bc8f26f05767d104232"
    },
    {
      "kind": "additional-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-reviewer-configuration-v5.json",
      "sha256": "025d25ca53d1dca9a853f7b30de3b4e296fa171e8496c01776e26cdf0fbce133"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-review-return-v5.md",
      "sha256": "e7fe1a227fe1ba3458fa9f2f2f81b57398ca2c9884e5e25048c1482a261230c6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-review-return-v5.md",
      "sha256": "ddd3bef8cb197ad322bb732d534880c4fc51423afe996df7944b8b6dbcb103ee"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-v5-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "06d121193cf7e5badf5a7568490b5ff7585790f3dffcb0633cc9ad1b11ef9ab7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-v5-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "72a420b7a71714e33f436517bfcf2f041289c4ae998abe982af07cad6dc02e50"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed pr-review evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  },
  "review": {
    "author_provider": "openai",
    "provider": "anthropic",
    "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
    "context_id": "64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b",
    "independent": true,
    "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
    "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
    "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
    "effort": "medium",
    "requested_effort": "medium",
    "effort_verified": true,
    "requested_mode": "plan",
    "mode": "plan",
    "mode_verified": true,
    "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
    "author_account": "codex-current",
    "account": "paseo-claude-default",
    "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
    "head": "0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd",
    "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
    "verdict": "PASS",
    "findings": [
      {
        "id": "OAI-001",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Verification",
        "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
        "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
        "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
        "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
        "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
        "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-001",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Correctness/performance",
        "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
        "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
        "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
        "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
        "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
        "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
        "confidence": "medium",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-002",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Documentation",
        "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
        "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
        "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
        "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
        "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
        "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "not-selected",
        "author_action": "not-selected",
        "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
      },
      {
        "id": "CI-002",
        "classification": "required",
        "severity": "HIGH",
        "category": "Correctness",
        "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
        "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
        "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
        "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
        "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
        "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "fixed",
        "author_action": "applied",
        "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
        "resolved": true,
        "reviewer_resolution": "Claude explicitly reclassified CI-002 Required/High correctness regression and confirmed this source/focused-test repair resolves it; full LinuxCI remains independent readiness gate."
      },
      {
        "id": "CLA-004",
        "classification": "recommended",
        "severity": "Low",
        "category": "Readability",
        "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs city preparation poll_fn",
        "finding": "Add a city guard message or extract duplicate self-waking poll helper.",
        "evidence": "City15sec assertion has no custom message; nation poll block duplicates it with a message.",
        "impact": "Diagnostic/readability improvement only; no behavior defect.",
        "verification": "Optional diagnostic/helper clarification without relaxing oracle.",
        "requirement": "Test readability and failure diagnosis",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "fixed",
        "author_action": "applied",
        "author_response": "Applied city guard phase/city/pass diagnostic and successful phase elapsed output in0c163912; optional helper extraction not selected.",
        "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok explicitly recognize selected guard diagnostic repair; optional helper remains unselected.",
        "resolved": true
      },
      {
        "id": "CI-003",
        "classification": "required",
        "severity": "Medium",
        "category": "Test correctness",
        "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs:747 at24fb",
        "finding": "Redundant city setup per API version exceeded original15second phaseguard onLinux after first strictnation passed.",
        "evidence": "CI39698560229 domestic177pass/S16ok, runtime47/1/3; phase0v903READY then cityguard assertion. Exact newsource10pass/currentfull48/0/3.",
        "impact": "Blocks fullLinux CI validation of factory prose reconstruction.",
        "verification": "Once-perphase2strictcitypasses with both versionnationoracles; currentfullLinux39701583980 remains separate required readiness gate.",
        "requirement": "Strict original15city/exactprose/two-version/four-attempt/15second fixture and fullCI",
        "confidence": "high",
        "disposition": "fixed",
        "author_action": "applied",
        "author_response": "Preparecanonical weather2passes onceperphase via903, sincecommon23inputstages/cachekeys; do notreset/increase15secguard or runtime bounds. Both originalnationversionchecks retained.",
        "resolved": true,
        "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok source-level resolved; actualCI readiness must be confirmed by currentLinuxrun, no sourcePASS substitutes for it."
      }
    ],
    "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329966117",
    "record_id": "6329966117",
    "reviewer_slot": 1,
    "unavailable_reviewers": [],
    "author_changes_remaining": [],
    "read_only_required": false,
    "read_only_verified": false,
    "read_only_evidence": "Actual requested/observed host settings retained in v5-runtime snapshot; boundary isolation unverified.13sourcehashes/clean tree unchanged after return; no source edits observed.",
    "runtime_session": "5b7058e6-94bc-492f-90f8-68abb67f4025",
    "review_scope": "Exact2file24fb..0c correction,13committedhashes/22declaredpaths,11runtimefilesunchangedc7d2. Actualsamepinnedsource-review5returns acceptedunderadministrativereview6 afterSV7 count-onlyerratum; no duplicatedexecution claimed.",
    "verification_limits": [
      "No Cargo/build/network/liveCI independently executed",
      "Final exactsource10/10/40nationattempt0,5unattributedpeerrefusals; initialdiagnosticharnessstop preserved",
      "Negativecontrol qualifiedreuseatoldertestbytes; strictpredicate unchanged",
      "Initiallocal47/1 andbaseCapacityunknown; RuntimeDrop outside15secguard",
      "35.68sec libtest vs35.79wholeCargo command distinguished",
      "OutgoingchecksfinalPASS, pre-push completionordering notverified",
      "CI003source-resolved, actualcurrentLinuxCI still mandatory"
    ],
    "execution_reuse": "Sameactualpinned independent source return, no newreviewexecution after author narrative-onlyerratum; Grok explicitlyreadcorrectedSV7 narrative. Claude countedactual5refusalsdirectly; correctedauthornarrative notclaimed personallyread."
  },
  "optional_reviews": [
    {
      "author_provider": "openai",
      "provider": "xai",
      "model": "grok-4.7",
      "context_id": "ba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754",
      "independent": true,
      "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
      "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
      "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
      "effort": "high",
      "requested_effort": "high",
      "effort_verified": true,
      "requested_mode": null,
      "mode": null,
      "mode_verified": false,
      "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
      "author_account": "codex-current",
      "account": "paseo-grok-default",
      "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
      "head": "0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd",
      "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
      "verdict": "PASS",
      "findings": [
        {
          "id": "OAI-001",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Verification",
          "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
          "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
          "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
          "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
          "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
          "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
        },
        {
          "id": "CLA-001",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Correctness/performance",
          "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
          "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
          "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
          "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
          "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
          "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
          "confidence": "medium",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
        },
        {
          "id": "CLA-002",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Documentation",
          "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
          "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
          "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
          "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
          "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
          "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "not-selected",
          "author_action": "not-selected",
          "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
        },
        {
          "id": "CI-002",
          "classification": "required",
          "severity": "HIGH",
          "category": "Correctness",
          "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
          "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
          "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
          "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
          "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
          "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "fixed",
          "author_action": "applied",
          "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
          "resolved": true,
          "reviewer_resolution": "Claude explicitly reclassified CI-002 Required/High correctness regression and confirmed this source/focused-test repair resolves it; full LinuxCI remains independent readiness gate."
        },
        {
          "id": "CLA-004",
          "classification": "recommended",
          "severity": "Low",
          "category": "Readability",
          "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs city preparation poll_fn",
          "finding": "Add a city guard message or extract duplicate self-waking poll helper.",
          "evidence": "City15sec assertion has no custom message; nation poll block duplicates it with a message.",
          "impact": "Diagnostic/readability improvement only; no behavior defect.",
          "verification": "Optional diagnostic/helper clarification without relaxing oracle.",
          "requirement": "Test readability and failure diagnosis",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "fixed",
          "author_action": "applied",
          "author_response": "Applied city guard phase/city/pass diagnostic and successful phase elapsed output in0c163912; optional helper extraction not selected.",
          "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok explicitly recognize selected guard diagnostic repair; optional helper remains unselected.",
          "resolved": true
        },
        {
          "id": "CI-003",
          "classification": "required",
          "severity": "Medium",
          "category": "Test correctness",
          "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs:747 at24fb",
          "finding": "Redundant city setup per API version exceeded original15second phaseguard onLinux after first strictnation passed.",
          "evidence": "CI39698560229 domestic177pass/S16ok, runtime47/1/3; phase0v903READY then cityguard assertion. Exact newsource10pass/currentfull48/0/3.",
          "impact": "Blocks fullLinux CI validation of factory prose reconstruction.",
          "verification": "Once-perphase2strictcitypasses with both versionnationoracles; currentfullLinux39701583980 remains separate required readiness gate.",
          "requirement": "Strict original15city/exactprose/two-version/four-attempt/15second fixture and fullCI",
          "confidence": "high",
          "disposition": "fixed",
          "author_action": "applied",
          "author_response": "Preparecanonical weather2passes onceperphase via903, sincecommon23inputstages/cachekeys; do notreset/increase15secguard or runtime bounds. Both originalnationversionchecks retained.",
          "resolved": true,
          "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok source-level resolved; actualCI readiness must be confirmed by currentLinuxrun, no sourcePASS substitutes for it."
        }
      ],
      "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329983525",
      "record_id": "6329983525",
      "reviewer_slot": null,
      "unavailable_reviewers": [],
      "author_changes_remaining": [],
      "read_only_required": false,
      "read_only_verified": false,
      "read_only_evidence": "Actual requested/observed host settings retained in v5-runtime snapshot; boundary isolation unverified.13sourcehashes/clean tree unchanged after return; no source edits observed.",
      "runtime_session": "01a1608b-009d-7820-b31c-f4aa90688478",
      "review_scope": "Exact2file24fb..0c correction,13committedhashes/22declaredpaths,11runtimefilesunchangedc7d2. Actualsamepinnedsource-review5returns acceptedunderadministrativereview6 afterSV7 count-onlyerratum; no duplicatedexecution claimed.",
      "verification_limits": [
        "No Cargo/build/network/liveCI independently executed",
        "Final exactsource10/10/40nationattempt0,5unattributedpeerrefusals; initialdiagnosticharnessstop preserved",
        "Negativecontrol qualifiedreuseatoldertestbytes; strictpredicate unchanged",
        "Initiallocal47/1 andbaseCapacityunknown; RuntimeDrop outside15secguard",
        "35.68sec libtest vs35.79wholeCargo command distinguished",
        "OutgoingchecksfinalPASS, pre-push completionordering notverified",
        "CI003source-resolved, actualcurrentLinuxCI still mandatory"
      ],
      "execution_reuse": "Sameactualpinned independent source return, no newreviewexecution after author narrative-onlyerratum; Grok explicitlyreadcorrectedSV7 narrative."
    }
  ]
}
reviewer-configuration.json

Original SHA256 f06672bde84f10bfda2cfee2861f0e62a802047282cf2bc8f26f05767d104232; display SHA256 f06672bde84f10bfda2cfee2861f0e62a802047282cf2bc8f26f05767d104232. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "author_provider": "openai",
  "provider": "anthropic",
  "model": "claude-opus-5-5",
  "context_id": "64b24da9-f6d5-43dc-8404-48d114f7ae5b",
  "independent": true,
  "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
  "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
  "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
  "effort": "medium",
  "requested_effort": "medium",
  "effort_verified": true,
  "requested_mode": "plan",
  "mode": "plan",
  "mode_verified": true,
  "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
  "author_account": "codex-current",
  "account": "paseo-claude-default",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "head": "0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "verdict": "PASS",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "OAI-001",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Verification",
      "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
      "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
      "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
      "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
      "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
      "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-001",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Correctness/performance",
      "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
      "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
      "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
      "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
      "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
      "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-002",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Documentation",
      "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
      "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
      "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
      "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
      "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
      "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
    },
    {
      "id": "CI-002",
      "classification": "required",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "category": "Correctness",
      "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
      "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
      "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
      "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
      "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
      "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "fixed",
      "author_action": "applied",
      "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
      "resolved": true,
      "reviewer_resolution": "Claude explicitly reclassified CI-002 Required/High correctness regression and confirmed this source/focused-test repair resolves it; full LinuxCI remains independent readiness gate."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-004",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Readability",
      "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs city preparation poll_fn",
      "finding": "Add a city guard message or extract duplicate self-waking poll helper.",
      "evidence": "City15sec assertion has no custom message; nation poll block duplicates it with a message.",
      "impact": "Diagnostic/readability improvement only; no behavior defect.",
      "verification": "Optional diagnostic/helper clarification without relaxing oracle.",
      "requirement": "Test readability and failure diagnosis",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "fixed",
      "author_action": "applied",
      "author_response": "Applied city guard phase/city/pass diagnostic and successful phase elapsed output in0c163912; optional helper extraction not selected.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok explicitly recognize selected guard diagnostic repair; optional helper remains unselected.",
      "resolved": true
    },
    {
      "id": "CI-003",
      "classification": "required",
      "severity": "Medium",
      "category": "Test correctness",
      "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs:747 at24fb",
      "finding": "Redundant city setup per API version exceeded original15second phaseguard onLinux after first strictnation passed.",
      "evidence": "CI39698560229 domestic177pass/S16ok, runtime47/1/3; phase0v903READY then cityguard assertion. Exact newsource10pass/currentfull48/0/3.",
      "impact": "Blocks fullLinux CI validation of factory prose reconstruction.",
      "verification": "Once-perphase2strictcitypasses with both versionnationoracles; currentfullLinux39701583980 remains separate required readiness gate.",
      "requirement": "Strict original15city/exactprose/two-version/four-attempt/15second fixture and fullCI",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "fixed",
      "author_action": "applied",
      "author_response": "Preparecanonical weather2passes onceperphase via903, sincecommon23inputstages/cachekeys; do notreset/increase15secguard or runtime bounds. Both originalnationversionchecks retained.",
      "resolved": true,
      "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok source-level resolved; actualCI readiness must be confirmed by currentLinuxrun, no sourcePASS substitutes for it."
    }
  ],
  "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329966117",
  "record_id": "6329966117",
  "reviewer_slot": 1,
  "unavailable_reviewers": [],
  "author_changes_remaining": [],
  "read_only_required": false,
  "read_only_verified": false,
  "read_only_evidence": "Actual requested/observed host settings retained in v5-runtime snapshot; boundary isolation unverified.13sourcehashes/clean tree unchanged after return; no source edits observed.",
  "runtime_session": "5b7058e6-94bc-492f-90f8-68abb67f4025",
  "review_scope": "Exact2file24fb..0c correction,13committedhashes/22declaredpaths,11runtimefilesunchangedc7d2. Actualsamepinnedsource-review5returns acceptedunderadministrativereview6 afterSV7 count-onlyerratum; no duplicatedexecution claimed.",
  "verification_limits": [
    "No Cargo/build/network/liveCI independently executed",
    "Final exactsource10/10/40nationattempt0,5unattributedpeerrefusals; initialdiagnosticharnessstop preserved",
    "Negativecontrol qualifiedreuseatoldertestbytes; strictpredicate unchanged",
    "Initiallocal47/1 andbaseCapacityunknown; RuntimeDrop outside15secguard",
    "35.68sec libtest vs35.79wholeCargo command distinguished",
    "OutgoingchecksfinalPASS, pre-push completionordering notverified",
    "CI003source-resolved, actualcurrentLinuxCI still mandatory"
  ],
  "execution_reuse": "Sameactualpinned independent source return, no newreviewexecution after author narrative-onlyerratum; Grok explicitlyreadcorrectedSV7 narrative. Claude countedactual5refusalsdirectly; correctedauthornarrative notclaimed personallyread."
}

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Candidate evidence archive — 0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd — review-v5-evidence (2/2). Full structured records retained beyond ephemeral CI artifacts. CI/review status is separate; this is not merge authorization.

grok-reviewer-configuration-v5.json

Original SHA256 025d25ca53d1dca9a853f7b30de3b4e296fa171e8496c01776e26cdf0fbce133; display SHA256 025d25ca53d1dca9a853f7b30de3b4e296fa171e8496c01776e26cdf0fbce133. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "author_provider": "openai",
  "provider": "xai",
  "model": "grok-4.7",
  "context_id": "ba68c20a-fabc-4701-9797-c95313dba754",
  "independent": true,
  "model_selection_source": "Observed actual Paseo provider catalog: latest release/default plus inspect_provider and returned runtime snapshot",
  "model_selection_time": "2026-10-21T22:18:59.655Z",
  "latest_ga_model_verified": true,
  "effort": "high",
  "requested_effort": "high",
  "effort_verified": true,
  "requested_mode": null,
  "mode": null,
  "mode_verified": false,
  "builder_context_id": "dc21955b-4f41-4394-94ee-e06ef46e7684 /root",
  "author_account": "codex-current",
  "account": "paseo-grok-default",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "head": "0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "verdict": "PASS",
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "OAI-001",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Verification",
      "location": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs:626; forecast_manifest.rs:64; forecast_cache.rs:557",
      "finding": "Add deterministic coverage for a newly populated latest Mid month after fallback and an external identity change between raw loading and final identity comparison.",
      "evidence": "Current external-change test covers an existing partition update and failed LIST; reviewer found the implementation defenses but no directly pinned tests for these two schedules.",
      "impact": "Future removal of searched-month or final identity defenses may escape regression checks; no current behavior defect reproduced.",
      "verification": "Barrier-driven owned-peer scenarios could test rebuild and refusal of memory/disk admission or complete S16 identity on changed controls.",
      "requirement": "AC3: searched-month scope and cold-build final revalidation",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Retain as an optional review recommendation. The current guards were verified by inspection and no defect was reproduced; existing required acceptance and functional evidence passes. No source change or follow-up tracking is selected.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified this as Recommended/Low and returned PASS; an unselected recommendation needs no re-review."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-001",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Correctness/performance",
      "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:366-373",
      "finding": "Repeated epoch churn can cause repeated full read/fold attempts until the original caller deadline.",
      "evidence": "get retries forecast view boundary with yield_now; same-key latest/backfill writers each advance epoch on entry/drop. No failure or unbounded execution was reproduced.",
      "impact": "Additional CPU/IO under churn, still bounded by caller deadline and existing owner/CPU/workspace limits.",
      "verification": "Optional deterministic epoch-churn test or explicit retry cap; avoid restoring the original compatibility failure.",
      "requirement": "AC1 and bounded-cost policy",
      "confidence": "medium",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Not selected. Original deadline, two-owner/two-CPU and workspace bounds remain; a speculative retry-count cap can recreate the observed availability regression. Existing exact compatibility tests pass and no new defect was reproduced.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-002",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Documentation",
      "location": "specs/issue-2850.md:16-24",
      "finding": "Formal AC1 spec could explicitly repeat active-writer transient reconstruction, incomplete IDs/no admission and original-deadline retry.",
      "evidence": "Architecture/operator/Archify current docs state the rule; spec currently says writers block admission and preserves original deadlines, without the expanded sentence.",
      "impact": "Potential reader ambiguity; no contradictory behavior contract identified.",
      "verification": "Optional one-sentence clarification in AC1.",
      "requirement": "AGENTS documentation contract",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "not-selected",
      "author_action": "not-selected",
      "author_response": "Not selected. Existing AC1 already defines the admission fence and preserves deadlines; architecture, operator guide and maintained design explicitly document the corrected transient rule. No contradiction was found. Recommendation retained without follow-up tracking.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Reviewer explicitly classified Recommended/Low and returned PASS; no selected change or current defect. No follow-up review required."
    },
    {
      "id": "CI-002",
      "classification": "required",
      "severity": "HIGH",
      "category": "Correctness",
      "location": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs:628",
      "finding": "Final canonical fence incorrectly stripped complete immutable request-local overlay identity when same-key backfill runs",
      "evidence": "CI39685398826 existing own-acquisition S16 failed atsummary_inputs; deterministic held-writer test Red101, Green17 and originalsummary10 pass",
      "impact": "S16 summary_inputs becomes None despite complete parent and own stored acquisition; violates preserved identity contract",
      "verification": "Deterministic complete/partial-parent overlay controls and unchanged original summary integration; full Linux CI separately mandatory",
      "requirement": "AC1 preserved own-write overlay and original S16 identities",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "fixed",
      "author_action": "applied",
      "author_response": "Restrict canonical downgrade to _parent.is_none; overlay inherits complete parent and original IDs, partial stays partial; nooverlay map/SSD. Canonical admission gates unchanged.",
      "resolved": true,
      "reviewer_resolution": "Claude explicitly reclassified CI-002 Required/High correctness regression and confirmed this source/focused-test repair resolves it; full LinuxCI remains independent readiness gate."
    },
    {
      "id": "CLA-004",
      "classification": "recommended",
      "severity": "Low",
      "category": "Readability",
      "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs city preparation poll_fn",
      "finding": "Add a city guard message or extract duplicate self-waking poll helper.",
      "evidence": "City15sec assertion has no custom message; nation poll block duplicates it with a message.",
      "impact": "Diagnostic/readability improvement only; no behavior defect.",
      "verification": "Optional diagnostic/helper clarification without relaxing oracle.",
      "requirement": "Test readability and failure diagnosis",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "fixed",
      "author_action": "applied",
      "author_response": "Applied city guard phase/city/pass diagnostic and successful phase elapsed output in0c163912; optional helper extraction not selected.",
      "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok explicitly recognize selected guard diagnostic repair; optional helper remains unselected.",
      "resolved": true
    },
    {
      "id": "CI-003",
      "classification": "required",
      "severity": "Medium",
      "category": "Test correctness",
      "location": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs:747 at24fb",
      "finding": "Redundant city setup per API version exceeded original15second phaseguard onLinux after first strictnation passed.",
      "evidence": "CI39698560229 domestic177pass/S16ok, runtime47/1/3; phase0v903READY then cityguard assertion. Exact newsource10pass/currentfull48/0/3.",
      "impact": "Blocks fullLinux CI validation of factory prose reconstruction.",
      "verification": "Once-perphase2strictcitypasses with both versionnationoracles; currentfullLinux39701583980 remains separate required readiness gate.",
      "requirement": "Strict original15city/exactprose/two-version/four-attempt/15second fixture and fullCI",
      "confidence": "high",
      "disposition": "fixed",
      "author_action": "applied",
      "author_response": "Preparecanonical weather2passes onceperphase via903, sincecommon23inputstages/cachekeys; do notreset/increase15secguard or runtime bounds. Both originalnationversionchecks retained.",
      "resolved": true,
      "reviewer_resolution": "Claude and Grok source-level resolved; actualCI readiness must be confirmed by currentLinuxrun, no sourcePASS substitutes for it."
    }
  ],
  "record_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329983525",
  "record_id": "6329983525",
  "reviewer_slot": null,
  "unavailable_reviewers": [],
  "author_changes_remaining": [],
  "read_only_required": false,
  "read_only_verified": false,
  "read_only_evidence": "Actual requested/observed host settings retained in v5-runtime snapshot; boundary isolation unverified.13sourcehashes/clean tree unchanged after return; no source edits observed.",
  "runtime_session": "01a1608b-009d-7820-b31c-f4aa90688478",
  "review_scope": "Exact2file24fb..0c correction,13committedhashes/22declaredpaths,11runtimefilesunchangedc7d2. Actualsamepinnedsource-review5returns acceptedunderadministrativereview6 afterSV7 count-onlyerratum; no duplicatedexecution claimed.",
  "verification_limits": [
    "No Cargo/build/network/liveCI independently executed",
    "Final exactsource10/10/40nationattempt0,5unattributedpeerrefusals; initialdiagnosticharnessstop preserved",
    "Negativecontrol qualifiedreuseatoldertestbytes; strictpredicate unchanged",
    "Initiallocal47/1 andbaseCapacityunknown; RuntimeDrop outside15secguard",
    "35.68sec libtest vs35.79wholeCargo command distinguished",
    "OutgoingchecksfinalPASS, pre-push completionordering notverified",
    "CI003source-resolved, actualcurrentLinuxCI still mandatory"
  ],
  "execution_reuse": "Sameactualpinned independent source return, no newreviewexecution after author narrative-onlyerratum; Grok explicitlyreadcorrectedSV7 narrative."
}
correction-receipt.json

Original SHA256 200351f0ad1e2681c6dc3c50b9f76799f60055711fad403f9a8d519a8c088f73; display SHA256 200351f0ad1e2681c6dc3c50b9f76799f60055711fad403f9a8d519a8c088f73. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "iteration": 4,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "correction deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "0800a4c41ed570b1927ccd7ca610fee47cfb2cac54a9de5fed5dd4a132cf6fba"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "7f1019fc71d2e833b1034e2536f5d160eac99318817321b18c55b7667ea3d288"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs",
      "sha256": "10399ff06dff447be58ae14671dbe33b6509920783b0a48ab6d6e9662c37030b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "ef646d6752fa59ffd0128e10ebc96dc5ee1ea75ab23b75d415216ed8b4b5a231"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "08ad1976cb10c2072934258cc14a1605b57b0a25a9d4220e9005602e93504542"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "d3f59ac2d01c7acb7830dfe2be67fed4ed0132a864631b287f510138c2983d34"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v5.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d4ac4516e4ad3fd3414ba4769d8c5757d58a4d475d63a4b2761dfb4a0f5a1dc7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-v4-full-failed.log",
      "sha256": "7cc4f23b00d751d08b3c5e7ce8a860e477b83678c9e1df356e7000d590da204c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-guard-diagnosis-v5.md",
      "sha256": "46376a6eb88bbdded4cac0f12c019c8f9a5e90cf60a5c3227e6e1473b4ea6024"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-peer-qualification-v5.md",
      "sha256": "298048891461e017e4b25b435a6ec78e8f50085f96ffdcb9838a0536a3f9f367"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v5.log",
      "sha256": "8124217857682ae56c2fcacb18cd071094de9ce33f44b630277d33b34bfe01df"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v5.md",
      "sha256": "558223ede67e58749a774edc713f3c40605f511d5382cbde13c5da3ad4a030a5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-1.log",
      "sha256": "3bc7d7dc64eb8c2b2eb9de6de1382b1ad65ea07f3dca7d2c3cf38d4ab9bac6c5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-10.log",
      "sha256": "d870ddb72049ea5ab97333995f127e0a3b425d6cddd66a4bb6055692e4bf9291"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-2.log",
      "sha256": "237dd650bfd6035bd0b5f3a411727eaeee3d2d5dad92a14c214518ef507a67a0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-3.log",
      "sha256": "6b20290108eaf9a1ef86883b0dbef3daffeb29a55be8c903fc88d59d254f4f50"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-4.log",
      "sha256": "794fc3e1f858527249e4e9cea51b13cbcd3813ff2fc026b2ac61ac6dbca19299"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-5.log",
      "sha256": "1904df457c5f1fa504f082ca72d2a3cbd6375d818506225a46f8e452c642561e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-6.log",
      "sha256": "2733c81350a4713ac3e40f29c3cbd9a1df6e21583bcba5aefaec3c0a787c61ff"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-7.log",
      "sha256": "026f3b4171b7528e93fe3ba817b4eb3b127a76a56a194af661ab97de617cd9f1"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-8.log",
      "sha256": "6a3161ccaa57eb7a2a02944478d7960b7b119c42d1d645f5715327a041909f2e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-9.log",
      "sha256": "57366d0b0d16d59901622142f4605f223c34b34096c4e95d0e36dcdb81502269"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-initialmatrix-v5.json",
      "sha256": "51a686e98fab690012a80fe788ed0f213482e217c9b951d41faadd12288c34bf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-repeat-v5.json",
      "sha256": "918d42183cce64e71a609c656c4eb60d986797b0fe948ce413de4ad6c1462332"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v5-execution.json",
      "sha256": "0117e00e1218a1d3d391cf97f9ab6b6c72c883012ed95ebe6183984921da82d6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.json",
      "sha256": "6a3d01c2bf3049c181a6b25000ef83acfd22b24d21976d4aa6119b70014e31c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.log",
      "sha256": "0e6ebe7165c483c2cbca07a1b722896871327b052054cf08cc5f90c24c421e41"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v5.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v5.log",
      "sha256": "e7caabddae0c9524357f4cb13489a704c398750bf42888f9468d1a3ba8768222"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v5.json",
      "sha256": "504000acbb96b68040941a2225e89405e5902e8534974ef2b09333e39ff61bbd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v5.log",
      "sha256": "397c89b35c710b8cc5824f2ae5abb905e2f8a3de22291f51d4d0685d0676c622"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-v4.log",
      "sha256": "cca9412561d8b558c49f5281bb6720fcc6b9073154364a4cc720651345e362c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5-execution.json",
      "sha256": "e768163e175aff481c903afc703448ed9630db01ed38bcd6ddf30a1253184a9b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5.log",
      "sha256": "3f2ffc40a398bfb80a7ce681b4976514c3b17ec74cff608588b2b6ac84acff35"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-v5-zero-refusal-diagnostic.py",
      "sha256": "fc50c127b767cc452f2cc6e58f1ab9c52065cdfacbf0b7df5081fac6016211df"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    },
    {
      "kind": "pr-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pr-review.md",
      "sha256": "7debc8c24ea8eecd1ae1cb05bac8d65ed811a120065d89579828dda0594e6e30"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "f06672bde84f10bfda2cfee2861f0e62a802047282cf2bc8f26f05767d104232"
    },
    {
      "kind": "additional-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-reviewer-configuration-v5.json",
      "sha256": "025d25ca53d1dca9a853f7b30de3b4e296fa171e8496c01776e26cdf0fbce133"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-review-return-v5.md",
      "sha256": "e7fe1a227fe1ba3458fa9f2f2f81b57398ca2c9884e5e25048c1482a261230c6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-review-return-v5.md",
      "sha256": "ddd3bef8cb197ad322bb732d534880c4fc51423afe996df7944b8b6dbcb103ee"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-v5-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "06d121193cf7e5badf5a7568490b5ff7585790f3dffcb0633cc9ad1b11ef9ab7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-v5-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "72a420b7a71714e33f436517bfcf2f041289c4ae998abe982af07cad6dc02e50"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "correction",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/correction.md",
      "sha256": "9df096756743f617f2d079deb945da3f07b8393b225b40e7b331eedce076166b"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed correction evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  }
}
correction.md

Original SHA256 9df096756743f617f2d079deb945da3f07b8393b225b40e7b331eedce076166b; display SHA256 9df096756743f617f2d079deb945da3f07b8393b225b40e7b331eedce076166b. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

# Final review dispositions

0c163912/candidate7d0e891a sourcePASS fromClaude/Grok. CI003RequiredMedium source-resolved:prepare2strictcitypasses onceperphase, notperversion;bothoriginalnationversionoracles and15secguardunchanged. ActualCI39701583980pending. CI002RequiredHighresolvedc7d2/runtimeunchanged/currentpriorLinuxS16pass. CLA004RecommendedLowguardmessage+phaseelapsed selected/applied andreviewersaccepted;optionalhelperunselected. OAI001/CLA001/CLA002 remainLowunselected/no followup. CLA003notcreated; no newGrokfinding.

Authornarrative0peerphrase correctedtoactual5underSV7 withoriginalSV6preserved; no source/checkchanges. Review6acceptsactualsamepinnedsource-return, notnewexecution. Exactsource10/10/40nationattempt0;5unattributedpeerrefusals diagnosticriskseparate;initialzero-thresholdharnessstop preserved. Full48/0/3,fresh6smoke,Clippy/fmt/Python/placement/staged/outgoingPASS. WholeCargo35.79s vslibtest35.68s distinguished. Outgoing5snapshotcompletionorderingbeforepushunverified; no falsebeforepushclaim.

No selectedsource/reportchanges remain. Originalunknownlocal47/1 andnewfixturebaseCapacityunknown;negativecontrololdertestqualifiedreuse;RuntimeDropoutside15secguard. ActualcurrentLinuxCI and remoteobservation remainrequiredforreadiness. No merge/deployment/cleanupbeforeallconsumersdone.

@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Pre-merge endpoint complete — no merge authorized or performed.

At 0c163912 / base 307defeb, both independent source reviews PASS and all 14 current PR checks succeeded. Linux CI 39701583980 completed: domestic 177/0/2 and runtime_services 48/0/3, including S16 own-acquisition and factory reconstruction. CI-002 and CI-003 are resolved; CLA-004 diagnostics applied. Three Low recommendations remain unselected, with no follow-up.

The final exact-source repeat matrix passed 10/10 with 40 national responses on attempt zero. Five unattributed peer refusals remain a flake-risk signal. Previous unknown local/base failures and the Runtime Drop timing limitation remain recorded. Task-owned target cleanup recovered about 1.59 GiB of free space; three retained-binary smoke modes passed afterwards without rebuilding.

This is readiness against the current stacked base. Parent #2841 remains open and must be integrated first. PR remains open; auto-merge and queue are disabled. No deployment or formal GitHub approval is claimed. Full completion gate, receipt and selected CI/cleanup evidence follow.

Candidate evidence archive — 0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd — completion-v5-evidence (1/1). Full structured records retained beyond ephemeral CI artifacts. CI/review status is separate; this is not merge authorization.

merge-ready.json

Original SHA256 65b860dbddaec299e2bcbb8a8d40c53c415dd5b36dd17a9694e91e8b8162842b; display SHA256 65b860dbddaec299e2bcbb8a8d40c53c415dd5b36dd17a9694e91e8b8162842b. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "head": "0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "merge_ready": true,
  "push_verified": true,
  "pr_verified": true,
  "mergeable": true,
  "required_ci_passed": true,
  "protections_satisfied": true,
  "human_requests_resolved": true,
  "remote_state_verified": true,
  "merge_authorized": false,
  "auto_merge_enabled": false,
  "merge_queue_enqueued": false,
  "repository": "WizardFactory/TodayWeather",
  "pr_url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851",
  "authority_source": "AK explicit PR/review/CI endpoint, merge excluded; scoped pre-merge account transfer authority",
  "checked_at": "2026-10-22T01:20:18.389607+00:00",
  "remote_record": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851",
  "production_trigger": "none",
  "authority": {
    "kind": "pre-merge-authority",
    "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pre-merge-authority.json",
    "sha256": "d3310008cc8d9b3e0abbaed327f95c005bd3a4c823191962f41ffd112c7f8f7c"
  },
  "evidence": [
    {
      "kind": "remote-readiness",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/remote-readiness-v5.json",
      "sha256": "73b80975b7e9c711b1ee85d5b65ad008d99800be259cd416a709f71fb793bc72"
    },
    {
      "kind": "source-binding",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/candidate-commit.json",
      "sha256": "63f1c33996d95e2b8d296d6296feea9b9ef99a12fc66c191ea365c3bf135e889"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "f06672bde84f10bfda2cfee2861f0e62a802047282cf2bc8f26f05767d104232"
    },
    {
      "kind": "additional-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-reviewer-configuration-v5.json",
      "sha256": "025d25ca53d1dca9a853f7b30de3b4e296fa171e8496c01776e26cdf0fbce133"
    },
    {
      "kind": "cleanup",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cleanup-v5-result.json",
      "sha256": "68407623fe9d9df1aa9cfcba10d1632a1069dbfd4c2caa5c39f12fa4527de8e4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "post-cleanup-smoke",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-postcleanup-v5.json",
      "sha256": "9ba3e176de83118682d0a05d9661bd00bc0be25895bf5e1553dd74db52154efc"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation-final",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation-final-v5.json",
      "sha256": "73f37f8a3d879e5e86c27270e2c3adb061036f1439c10bebe97ad327509d7d18"
    }
  ]
}
completion.md

Original SHA256 c58d6c42b473de819d5939896f7dbfacfe89b158f9101e629d35878ce42860b9; display SHA256 c58d6c42b473de819d5939896f7dbfacfe89b158f9101e629d35878ce42860b9. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

# Issue #2850 pre-merge completion

PR: https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851
Head: 0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd
Base: 307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f
Candidate: sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9

Both independent source reviews returned PASS. All 14 current PR checks succeeded, including Linux CI 39701583980. The downloaded full log explicitly records the original S16 own-acquisition case and corrected factory reconstruction case as passing. CI-002 and CI-003 are resolved; CLA-004 diagnostics were applied. Three Low recommendations remain unselected, with no follow-up. No author-selected changes remain.

Acceptance outcomes:

- AC1: key-local RAII writer fences, generation handling and request-local overlay identities are preserved.
- AC2: selector boundaries determine view expiry.
- AC3: bounded catalog-only renewal verifies current authoritative identities.
- AC4: disposable SSD views share the existing bounded cache and pass restart, fault and value-preservation checks.
- AC5: the 22 declared paths, operator documentation, Archify artifacts and response-byte equivalence are verified.

The final fixture correction changes no runtime code. The 11 runtime/test/tool files are unchanged since c7d2. No dependency, production flag or legacy business logic changed.

Final local evidence: exact-source fixture 10/10 with all 40 national responses on attempt zero; full parallel runtime suite 48 passed, 0 failed, 3 ignored; Clippy with warnings denied, fmt, seven Python checks, placement and artifact checks passed. Fresh six-mode smoke preserves 13 golden views and the 42,549-byte HTTP hash. SSD restore and unchanged renewal perform no forecast descriptor/raw GET, parse or fold; the three-hour boundary replay matches. Prior 53 focused Rust checks are qualified reuse; current full Linux CI supplies current workspace evidence. The older reader-disconnection negative control is also qualified reuse, with the exact-prose assertion unchanged.

Limitations retained: five peer refusals in the passing repeat matrix have unknown attribution; zero refusals is not claimed. The earlier local parallel 47/1 failure and base's new-fixture Capacity error retain unknown causes. Runtime Drop can wait for blocking work outside the 15-second phase guard. Historical performance tables describe 66be loopback measurements, not production capacity. Outgoing artifact checks eventually passed for all five commits, but completion before push was not verified. No live provider, S3, AWS, mobile build or deployment was performed.

Cleanup: the exact task-owned shared target was cleaned after all local consumers finished. Allocated before: 1965461504 bytes; after: 0 bytes; observed free-space delta: 1712017408 bytes. Three copied executables were hash-verified and the current binary's runtime dependencies checked. Its post-cleanup smoke passed all three modes without rebuilding. Source, fixtures, golden baselines, manifests, logs, SDLC state, plans, Archify recovery metadata, registry and toolchain were preserved.

Durable structured records:
- https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329966535
- https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6329967087
- https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6330002187
- https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2851#issuecomment-6330002621

Readiness applies to the current stacked PR; parent PR #2841 remains open and must be integrated first. Merge authorization is false. Auto-merge and the merge queue are disabled; PR and issue remain open. No merge was performed.
completion-receipt.json

Original SHA256 012b9e6c2cb4062e9d8ad1b51e3534b263ff057cfe782ae6b56bc4f58bbdda7a; display SHA256 012b9e6c2cb4062e9d8ad1b51e3534b263ff057cfe782ae6b56bc4f58bbdda7a. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "iteration": 1,
  "decision": "PROCEED",
  "reason": "completion deliverable assessed against issue 2850 and current source",
  "authority_source": "AK SDLC request and explicit PR/review/CI endpoint answer, no merge",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "next_action": "Continue next applicable stage within pre-merge authority",
  "inputs": [
    {
      "kind": "triage",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/triage.md",
      "sha256": "ed2bf0afa77601efe2425e2dc73bdf81325ecdef42d0f1f60841ebcc2da2fd2f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "intent",
      "path": "intent/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "1c32108891bf673b58558c207234e143b0e873398e26e8d93d52ef7352208f8d"
    },
    {
      "kind": "investigation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/investigation.md",
      "sha256": "fb7b65809e846cd767a2c45648d216c02d02e50308a3826ac95fc13fac7ea2d3"
    },
    {
      "kind": "spec",
      "path": "specs/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "0c55e6b7d33005c9c014ae22cf4e958242b828960c8f00159565e3963911d9cf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-source",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-html",
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-validation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/design-validation-v2.md",
      "sha256": "ba98c4a9184e9a8532893d58f04472b3dbcc786e5032ed01a763fef72132ada8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "design-rationale",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v2.md",
      "sha256": "47182a9746a3dcee831fe033ea44462db81ac0c6c354e447a573fc97695f8605"
    },
    {
      "kind": "plan",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.md",
      "sha256": "726bfbbd6eea1904cce04e0a746eecc7e9537a580ac1cdcd0fbb14b43eaa9fbf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "user-scenarios",
      "path": "plans/issue-2850.scenarios.json",
      "sha256": "bf809b77455a5b3a0daaaed1471718d97d670eb5c06e5583861f67533b159dc2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-plan",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-plan.md",
      "sha256": "52fa521a3eb848085be2a1daa3fcd21a741f1916225e1c60f5540f996d0324eb"
    },
    {
      "kind": "build",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.md",
      "sha256": "0800a4c41ed570b1927ccd7ca610fee47cfb2cac54a9de5fed5dd4a132cf6fba"
    },
    {
      "kind": "change-record",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/build.patch",
      "sha256": "7f1019fc71d2e833b1034e2536f5d160eac99318817321b18c55b7667ea3d288"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/config/tasks/ForecastRetention2850.json",
      "sha256": "cff3073bf974fbb9adaffa57a36273e483975a2ce100b2155532045766492566"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "12eb79e157925d3099ea4750dcc39ae03ab2871c2daa98714b56aa51dfea0554"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_manifest.rs",
      "sha256": "303ed1b95fcf656b4efcfd59cbf05308a671eb1372582188d5a885dfceee5f5e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/forecast_disk.rs",
      "sha256": "884942aac036eb0efc010146ae01be95fb12135c7b7d6843bd8126a087c45304"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/records.rs",
      "sha256": "d6b4852211dd574f16b18ac0e4f1a115d48fe1705c3cded69d70265e48c47b98"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/mod.rs",
      "sha256": "a36c3c2b43718952d654e6c91643a0628fe8081f8409e8263f37cf5ce4829406"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/domestic/kma/source/doc.rs",
      "sha256": "50f79cb79dd19493a9c826a84cea2920f493c3a8a2ca077f9907431f9e3a95d8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/src/cache/disk.rs",
      "sha256": "b0c0753bef13214207d3cef1adf9cdd1f8deb35f2c878b62ac94175bd0454bb2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/domestic/forecast_cache.rs",
      "sha256": "71be4b0403b02405a3adc30f119c696bc94aef6c71b51b14d1454564b14632c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/examples/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.rs",
      "sha256": "bdd197d82cce0bf80e3cc64368f66bd4c132a03623f33e4d29aef2274c84031f"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "9074092d251389c2a24a700b23a3baa8ce2ab476ee5aaa7522dc1bf3aa51b1c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tools/test_domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
      "sha256": "2b883ba252791fc80aab697d2e5097cbe033936be81a8dfe379aacaf2be5ec38"
    },
    {
      "kind": "candidate-source",
      "path": "server2/tests/runtime_services/inventory.rs",
      "sha256": "10399ff06dff447be58ae14671dbe33b6509920783b0a48ab6d6e9662c37030b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "self-verification",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/self-verification.md",
      "sha256": "ef646d6752fa59ffd0128e10ebc96dc5ee1ea75ab23b75d415216ed8b4b5a231"
    },
    {
      "kind": "test-results",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-results.json",
      "sha256": "08ad1976cb10c2072934258cc14a1605b57b0a25a9d4220e9005602e93504542"
    },
    {
      "kind": "documentation",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/documentation.json",
      "sha256": "d3f59ac2d01c7acb7830dfe2be67fed4ed0132a864631b287f510138c2983d34"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v3.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/artifact-staged-v5.log",
      "sha256": "c33aaa398e5679701f9a2721c2398116e4a0586502f8e94f0b1378519a674187"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/backfill-v3.log",
      "sha256": "847be5791812039d5ea2bd2231a1885512f98ae7bab4ee1f4e98d186c74dd827"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/base-reason-v4.log",
      "sha256": "d4ac4516e4ad3fd3414ba4769d8c5757d58a4d475d63a4b2761dfb4a0f5a1dc7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cache-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0aa038b8ced7a8428e1afe017ef22e299624783d3d71c343bd1c1bbb295a2425"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-boundary-red-owned-peer.log",
      "sha256": "1ba68b39037630617ad53b90741d2407f2c080f602ae2ba694c6c26b85936e14"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/ci-v4-full-failed.log",
      "sha256": "7cc4f23b00d751d08b3c5e7ce8a860e477b83678c9e1df356e7000d590da204c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-guard-diagnosis-v5.md",
      "sha256": "46376a6eb88bbdded4cac0f12c019c8f9a5e90cf60a5c3227e6e1473b4ea6024"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-peer-qualification-v5.md",
      "sha256": "298048891461e017e4b25b435a6ec78e8f50085f96ffdcb9838a0536a3f9f367"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v3.log",
      "sha256": "313ec2c5d659d490d909c447a990fa4a0bb689ac7f9840fc536f189a3fb74715"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/clippy-v5.log",
      "sha256": "8124217857682ae56c2fcacb18cd071094de9ce33f44b630277d33b34bfe01df"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/concurrent-v3.log",
      "sha256": "03c3b8b2b771836f0cc8db75881fcf45eea0d81e8ce33b68b36625e82d067c0e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/diagnosis-v5.md",
      "sha256": "558223ede67e58749a774edc713f3c40605f511d5382cbde13c5da3ad4a030a5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/disk-v3.log",
      "sha256": "0af57e26691be861f976e2edcefce3346f8e0977abf1f50904495b3fe1194d1c"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/example-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d093430eb6d26e74b59afb92f4e3e5eda397dfe6a7af5d89171ea810aa10fd92"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-1.log",
      "sha256": "3bc7d7dc64eb8c2b2eb9de6de1382b1ad65ea07f3dca7d2c3cf38d4ab9bac6c5"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-10.log",
      "sha256": "d870ddb72049ea5ab97333995f127e0a3b425d6cddd66a4bb6055692e4bf9291"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-2.log",
      "sha256": "237dd650bfd6035bd0b5f3a411727eaeee3d2d5dad92a14c214518ef507a67a0"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-3.log",
      "sha256": "6b20290108eaf9a1ef86883b0dbef3daffeb29a55be8c903fc88d59d254f4f50"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-4.log",
      "sha256": "794fc3e1f858527249e4e9cea51b13cbcd3813ff2fc026b2ac61ac6dbca19299"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-5.log",
      "sha256": "1904df457c5f1fa504f082ca72d2a3cbd6375d818506225a46f8e452c642561e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-6.log",
      "sha256": "2733c81350a4713ac3e40f29c3cbd9a1df6e21583bcba5aefaec3c0a787c61ff"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-7.log",
      "sha256": "026f3b4171b7528e93fe3ba817b4eb3b127a76a56a194af661ab97de617cd9f1"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-8.log",
      "sha256": "6a3161ccaa57eb7a2a02944478d7960b7b119c42d1d645f5715327a041909f2e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-final-v5-9.log",
      "sha256": "57366d0b0d16d59901622142f4605f223c34b34096c4e95d0e36dcdb81502269"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-initialmatrix-v5.json",
      "sha256": "51a686e98fab690012a80fe788ed0f213482e217c9b951d41faadd12288c34bf"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/factory-repeat-v5.json",
      "sha256": "918d42183cce64e71a609c656c4eb60d986797b0fe948ce413de4ad6c1462332"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v3-execution.json",
      "sha256": "7987ee0019ec32ae81500740faaf1828dac9019fe8300f1a7b04337b45d4d02e"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/fmt-v5-execution.json",
      "sha256": "0117e00e1218a1d3d391cf97f9ab6b6c72c883012ed95ebe6183984921da82d6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.json",
      "sha256": "6a3d01c2bf3049c181a6b25000ef83acfd22b24d21976d4aa6119b70014e31c8"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/head-negative-v4.log",
      "sha256": "0e6ebe7165c483c2cbca07a1b722896871327b052054cf08cc5f90c24c421e41"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/late-v3.log",
      "sha256": "679d2016884cc2b6a1f838722ca14c18ae52cd2bf65caf981c823b62bab97e7a"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/overlay-red-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d156dfbe5a46ff4a13d0f836e126523041d395523d217a6057e0412aae5c8ba4"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v3.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/placement-v5.log",
      "sha256": "459f30d8ec5e3bce2a1aacf1f67f526f65650de5610c6ed5b1723556fe9f1b12"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v3.log",
      "sha256": "bee1deaeee8a500be7b285bf332ca87c31cd4a45337eff4bd8ff3032b84d90a2"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/python-v5.log",
      "sha256": "e7caabddae0c9524357f4cb13489a704c398750bf42888f9468d1a3ba8768222"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-boundary.log",
      "sha256": "1a97fbd7ac61f4429bad296c95e1415824fb7fabc7cf8a1eccbbc5278dad9b39"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-disk.log",
      "sha256": "ac2608a27ac8e5dca284875e10cf15066b71eedc4451236242ee9d9167eaefcd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-key-direct.log",
      "sha256": "62967070b08a6734bd2952b9533d9f50184419b01c5ba06d5e110cdb21fc1f71"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/red-renewal.log",
      "sha256": "1367727fd366b0ddb8a80815f0610fe20525a0a5d07f79d3852212675c547365"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v5.json",
      "sha256": "504000acbb96b68040941a2225e89405e5902e8534974ef2b09333e39ff61bbd"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-final-v5.log",
      "sha256": "397c89b35c710b8cc5824f2ae5abb905e2f8a3de22291f51d4d0685d0676c622"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/runtime-full-v4.log",
      "sha256": "cca9412561d8b558c49f5281bb6720fcc6b9073154364a4cc720651345e362c9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v3.log",
      "sha256": "3d5555e3b5fce99ec3790cf0cd8fbbaa8731380f2da78da79d815c35d0d33c84"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5-execution.json",
      "sha256": "e768163e175aff481c903afc703448ed9630db01ed38bcd6ddf30a1253184a9b"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-v5.log",
      "sha256": "3f2ffc40a398bfb80a7ce681b4976514c3b17ec74cff608588b2b6ac84acff35"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/summary-v3.log",
      "sha256": "18618fc59990d00e4cb8d6b712ab0223d2a156e45ef1d7e5eb8db26e29ceb8e6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/test-v5-zero-refusal-diagnostic.py",
      "sha256": "fc50c127b767cc452f2cc6e58f1ab9c52065cdfacbf0b7df5081fac6016211df"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3-final.log",
      "sha256": "b44bbc133aebc40d278158365a50fbfd13d3acdfd859defea5ff4d450adcd2d7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "execution-log",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/unit-v3.log",
      "sha256": "d5f95f5c0967987f476ff051d3e47b2a2c1345a820f16fa532a0f5ec0ac21662"
    },
    {
      "kind": "pr-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/pr-review.md",
      "sha256": "7debc8c24ea8eecd1ae1cb05bac8d65ed811a120065d89579828dda0594e6e30"
    },
    {
      "kind": "reviewer-configuration",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/reviewer-configuration.json",
      "sha256": "f06672bde84f10bfda2cfee2861f0e62a802047282cf2bc8f26f05767d104232"
    },
    {
      "kind": "additional-review",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-reviewer-configuration-v5.json",
      "sha256": "025d25ca53d1dca9a853f7b30de3b4e296fa171e8496c01776e26cdf0fbce133"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-review-return-v5.md",
      "sha256": "e7fe1a227fe1ba3458fa9f2f2f81b57398ca2c9884e5e25048c1482a261230c6"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-return",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-review-return-v5.md",
      "sha256": "ddd3bef8cb197ad322bb732d534880c4fc51423afe996df7944b8b6dbcb103ee"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/claude-v5-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "06d121193cf7e5badf5a7568490b5ff7585790f3dffcb0633cc9ad1b11ef9ab7"
    },
    {
      "kind": "review-runtime",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/grok-v5-runtime.json",
      "sha256": "72a420b7a71714e33f436517bfcf2f041289c4ae998abe982af07cad6dc02e50"
    },
    {
      "kind": "correction",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/correction.md",
      "sha256": "9df096756743f617f2d079deb945da3f07b8393b225b40e7b331eedce076166b"
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
      "kind": "completion",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/completion.md",
      "sha256": "c58d6c42b473de819d5939896f7dbfacfe89b158f9101e629d35878ce42860b9"
    },
    {
      "kind": "merge-ready",
      "path": "reports/sdlc/issue-2850/merge-ready.json",
      "sha256": "65b860dbddaec299e2bcbb8a8d40c53c415dd5b36dd17a9694e91e8b8162842b"
    }
  ],
  "assessment": {
    "assessor": "/root Codex",
    "summary": "Read and assessed completion evidence; source claims distinguish tests and unverified production behavior.",
    "criteria": [
      "AC1",
      "AC2",
      "AC3",
      "AC4",
      "AC5"
    ]
  },
  "documentation_final_checked": true,
  "author_changes_remaining": [],
  "merge_authorized": false
}
remote-readiness-v5.json

Original SHA256 73b80975b7e9c711b1ee85d5b65ad008d99800be259cd416a709f71fb793bc72; display SHA256 73b80975b7e9c711b1ee85d5b65ad008d99800be259cd416a709f71fb793bc72. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "checked_at": "2026-10-22T01:20:18.389607+00:00",
  "head": "0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd",
  "base": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
  "all_checks": 14,
  "all_checks_success": true,
  "original_S16_case_ci_passed": true,
  "branch_protection": null,
  "applied_rules": [],
  "unresolved_review_threads": [],
  "auto_merge": false,
  "merge_queue": false,
  "dependency": {
    "baseRefOid": "c1ae9082b2c86f0087727be9872b0cf82b4e3bb1",
    "headRefOid": "307defeb706886217ab67ea858dc7c7b0435752f",
    "mergedAt": null,
    "state": "OPEN",
    "url": "https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/pull/2841"
  },
  "authenticated_route": "Existing gh authenticated WizardFactory/TodayWeather PR route; no account/permission changes; independent cross-account GitHub access not asserted",
  "production_trigger": "none",
  "production_evidence": "Authorized pre-merge fix branch push/PR checks only; Server2 pull_request workflow, no deployment/production flags or workflow changes. Future integration/deployment remains separately human-authorized.",
  "evidence": {
    "ci-v5-completed.json": "e7e1c62abdd6d53db8e0791672b4a01e20344d26f095d2b9a332eed7d80b37b9",
    "ci-v5-full.log": "0e766fdfc697516180be39f3fbf299e8ad484cdd82b381e5489aeeb18dcf5a20",
    "pr-final-observation.json": "9a4067b74c4e666fd272d88c39b549ef5a3ed09ed5c72b6f73fe43a8cab936c3",
    "protections-final-observation.json": "c1c84c089f6de35e1f44891b5b80b94c612067e4587256aebd6d2cd167a00f1f",
    "rules-final-observation.json": "4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945",
    "dependency-final-observation.json": "f89eeaf2abfe1217a9993b6c8f82c9341538c5f740c745eb449f7aeb48a3ded8",
    "required-checks-final-observation.log": "b0c8d65d11861ed0902f626b21361e55141a5eef09d7c7f5b826d91568e97bfd",
    "human-requests-final.json": "1252c099f85c10d730cb170418d9ee8e0ade8e4bd472979c6b8d90483b49d484"
  }
}
ci-v5-completed.json

Original SHA256 e7e1c62abdd6d53db8e0791672b4a01e20344d26f095d2b9a332eed7d80b37b9; display SHA256 e7e1c62abdd6d53db8e0791672b4a01e20344d26f095d2b9a332eed7d80b37b9. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{"conclusion":"success","headSha":"0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd","jobs":[{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:46:02Z","conclusion":"success","databaseId":119571814589,"name":"goldens","startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:20Z","status":"completed","steps":[{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:21Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Set up job","number":1,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:20Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:27Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Run actions/checkout@v4","number":2,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:21Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:30Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Run actions/setup-node@v4","number":3,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:27Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:30Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Run actions/setup-python@v5","number":4,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:30Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:59Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Run python tools/golden/ci.py --install","number":5,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:30Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:46:00Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Post Run actions/setup-python@v5","number":8,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:59Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:46:00Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Post Run actions/setup-node@v4","number":9,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:46:00Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:46:00Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Post Run actions/checkout@v4","number":10,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:46:00Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:46:00Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Complete job","number":11,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:46:00Z","status":"completed"}],"url":"https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/actions/runs/39701583980/job/119571814589"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T01:19:00Z","conclusion":"success","databaseId":119571814623,"name":"foundation","startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:19Z","status":"completed","steps":[{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:20Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Set up job","number":1,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:20Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:27Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Run actions/checkout@v4","number":2,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:20Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T01:18:53Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Run bash tools/ci.sh","number":3,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:27Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T01:18:59Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Run actions/upload-artifact@v4","number":4,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T01:18:53Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T01:18:59Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Post Run actions/checkout@v4","number":8,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T01:18:59Z","status":"completed"},{"completedAt":"2026-10-22T01:18:59Z","conclusion":"success","name":"Complete job","number":9,"startedAt":"2026-10-22T01:18:59Z","status":"completed"}],"url":"https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/actions/runs/39701583980/job/119571814623"}],"startedAt":"2026-10-22T00:45:17Z","status":"completed","updatedAt":"2026-10-22T01:19:01Z","url":"https://github.com/WizardFactory/TodayWeather/actions/runs/39701583980"}
ci-v5-selected.log

Original SHA256 f3dcacaca4217dc39f3d932764f55866ba1165407763c86f96c2b73c5f9bde50; display SHA256 f3dcacaca4217dc39f3d932764f55866ba1165407763c86f96c2b73c5f9bde50. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

Selected exact result lines from CI 39701583980 at 0c163912. Full log SHA256: 0e766fdfc697516180be39f3fbf299e8ad484cdd82b381e5489aeeb18dcf5a20

foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:50:45.7478221Z test result: ok. 171 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 8.44s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:50:45.7593081Z test result: ok. 0 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.00s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:50:46.5320465Z test result: ok. 20 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.76s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:50:46.5349188Z test result: ok. 0 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.00s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:50:52.2045862Z test result: ok. 18 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 5.67s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:50:55.9888777Z test result: ok. 33 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 3.78s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:50:56.1117870Z test result: ok. 10 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.12s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:51:09.7422745Z test result: ok. 33 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 13.63s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:51:23.6187944Z test result: ok. 95 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 13.86s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:58:10.9858225Z test summary_s3::the_requests_own_acquisition_keeps_its_stored_identity ... ok
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:58:19.0404101Z test result: ok. 177 passed; 0 failed; 2 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 415.42s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:58:26.4738988Z test result: ok. 40 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 7.39s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:58:31.9762651Z test result: ok. 8 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 5.15s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:58:45.5719172Z test result: ok. 64 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 13.58s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:58:49.6757159Z test result: ok. 47 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 4.10s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:58:51.2848679Z test result: ok. 3 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 1.60s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:59:44.1372892Z test result: ok. 15 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 52.85s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:59:45.3046333Z test result: ok. 10 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 1.12s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:59:48.7859414Z test result: ok. 13 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 3.48s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:59:48.8307198Z test result: ok. 24 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.02s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T00:59:48.8324996Z test result: ok. 3 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.00s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:00:29.1948152Z test result: ok. 16 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 40.38s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:00:38.2747689Z test result: ok. 50 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 9.08s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:00:40.0076769Z test result: ok. 34 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 1.58s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:00:56.7357120Z test result: ok. 44 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 16.72s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:01:20.6811124Z test inventory::factory_national_prose_reader_survives_factory_reconstruction ... ok
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:01:49.7154052Z test result: ok. 48 passed; 0 failed; 3 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 52.97s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:01:49.7622398Z test result: ok. 4 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.01s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:01:50.5881553Z test result: ok. 30 passed; 0 failed; 1 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.82s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:01:51.5595798Z test result: ok. 27 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.97s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:02:00.2866206Z test result: ok. 31 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 8.72s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:02:28.6960079Z test result: ok. 41 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 28.40s
foundation	Run bash tools/ci.sh	2026-10-22T01:02:31.1031380Z test result: ok. 1 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out; finished in 0.36s
cleanup-v5-result.json

Original SHA256 68407623fe9d9df1aa9cfcba10d1632a1069dbfd4c2caa5c39f12fa4527de8e4; display SHA256 013543f5a1ef79a0bbacacbd214f55a9e190c689679be74c16579f1e03368bc2. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "target": "${CHECKOUT}/server2/target",
  "ownership": "Coordinator-created task2850 target, absent at intake",
  "active_consumers": [],
  "pending_local_consumers": [],
  "remote_ci": "39701583980 completed success; remote runner does not use local target",
  "reviewer_consumers": "Both completed; shared target build/run explicitly prohibited in assignment",
  "allocated_before_bytes": 1965461504,
  "free_before_bytes": 133994622976,
  "retained_executables": [
    {
      "path": "${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin/domestic_warm_cache_smoke",
      "sha256": "0b352babf3efd6273b1e9e5c773da3bee3ec1d5fe07786ebfbe4ec75184b661b",
      "bytes": 20962032
    },
    {
      "path": "${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin-v2/domestic_warm_cache_smoke",
      "sha256": "78ed4cb02d57306cccd7567375a9bf4c96dd2b7304949e697549479e8454dcdb",
      "bytes": 20964144
    },
    {
      "path": "${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin-v3/domestic_warm_cache_smoke",
      "sha256": "b51244fcdacbc20a6ac4ccccd1dacdb1d883bb5fca3ba7acfc8dd6b2d896359e",
      "bytes": 20964144
    }
  ],
  "current_runtime_dependencies": "${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin-v3/domestic_warm_cache_smoke:\n\t/System/Library/Frameworks/Security.framework/Versions/A/Security (compatibility version 1.0.0, current version 62460.1.2)\n\t/System/Library/Frameworks/CoreFoundation.framework/Versions/A/CoreFoundation (compatibility version 150.0.0, current version 5027.0.69)\n\t/usr/lib/libiconv.2.dylib (compatibility version 7.0.0, current version 7.0.0)\n\t/usr/lib/libSystem.B.dylib (compatibility version 1.0.0, current version 1359.0.0)\n",
  "protected": [
    "reports",
    ".planning",
    ".archify recovery metadata",
    "all source/fixtures/golden files/manifests/lockfiles",
    "global Cargo registry and installed toolchain"
  ],
  "command": [
    "sh",
    "${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/cargo.sh",
    "clean",
    "--target-dir",
    "${CHECKOUT}/server2/target"
  ],
  "checked_at": 1792632030.956406,
  "exit_code": 0,
  "free_after_bytes": 135706640384,
  "observed_free_delta_bytes": 1712017408,
  "target_exists_after": false,
  "allocated_after_bytes": 0
}
smoke-postcleanup-v5.json

Original SHA256 9ba3e176de83118682d0a05d9661bd00bc0be25895bf5e1553dd74db52154efc; display SHA256 16e219fe17c5496fcad0d7650e7a9024c90e3c76c9e54bb7aed7839d6c1a942f. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "command": [
    "python3",
    "-B",
    "server2/tools/domestic_warm_cache_smoke.py",
    "--binary",
    "${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/bin-v3/domestic_warm_cache_smoke",
    "--output",
    "${CHECKOUT}/reports/sdlc/issue-2850/smoke-postcleanup-v5",
    "--build-variant",
    "release",
    "--modes",
    "seed",
    "diagnostic",
    "http"
  ],
  "binary_sha256": "b51244fcdacbc20a6ac4ccccd1dacdb1d883bb5fca3ba7acfc8dd6b2d896359e",
  "runtime_source_hashes_unchanged_since": "c7d2a5d2",
  "candidate": "sha256:7d0e891a90940d1527e3e9ef4429553c31891ed733050f0d92a669397f2353d9",
  "exit": 0,
  "elapsed_seconds": 11.00126325,
  "purpose": "Execute retained binary after cleaning the exact task-owned Cargo target; seed, diagnostic and HTTP behavior remain runnable without rebuilding"
}
documentation-final-v5.json

Original SHA256 73f37f8a3d879e5e86c27270e2c3adb061036f1439c10bebe97ad327509d7d18; display SHA256 73f37f8a3d879e5e86c27270e2c3adb061036f1439c10bebe97ad327509d7d18. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "checked_at": "2026-10-22T00:57:42.778898+00:00",
  "head": "0c1639120d60874c1a056d720115bb94a6e888cd",
  "checked": true,
  "unchanged_since_review": true,
  "documents": [
    {
      "path": "docs/architecture/server2.md",
      "sha256": "7ef7a1fa0e181a3f50342e0effe0e5689721ea0b8a39dc58849e5ac158561121"
    },
    {
      "path": "docs/operations/server2-domestic-cache.md",
      "sha256": "e6c49e800df20a1b216752c3119407d508a0d5176c04d628b361990f3c49387c"
    },
    {
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.json",
      "sha256": "f5912cd80353a13c38ef984daa3da45d6bd33f0895880bd88145635ba97b75d5"
    },
    {
      "path": "docs/architecture/diagrams/server2-domestic-cache.html",
      "sha256": "c1d2b17f0ccd53ee0575bfa3c53b5f1d13ed08bfcd6a1ba168f80058ed293c81"
    },
    {
      "path": "docs/evidence/tasks/issue-2850/verification.md",
      "sha256": "f7a2fa8f1b8e06404613dd3281882cae4cfb1b3b6f6cb550f9071d46ece3d76d"
    }
  ],
  "manual_applicability": "Transparent internal cache retention/restore optimization preserves every product API/CLI/UI operation and HTTP bytes. No new user workflow or feature surface; existing operator Markdown and architecture/Archify are updated and checked. README/API unchanged. No new screenshot PDF manual applies. Diagram artifact/actual Chrome and viewed light/dark captures passed; metadata preserved locally.",
  "review_evidence": [
    "claude-review-return-v5.md",
    "grok-review-return-v5.md"
  ],
  "limits": "Unchanged architecture/Archify artifact/browser/visual evidence reused from v6; selected performance historic; current full Linux CI remains independent gate"
}
human-requests-final.json

Original SHA256 1252c099f85c10d730cb170418d9ee8e0ade8e4bd472979c6b8d90483b49d484; display SHA256 1252c099f85c10d730cb170418d9ee8e0ade8e4bd472979c6b8d90483b49d484. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "requested_reviewers": {
    "users": [],
    "teams": []
  },
  "formal_reviews": [],
  "comments_by_others": [],
  "observed_comment_count": 24,
  "assessment": "No outstanding human review requests, formal reviews or comments by other authors observed; independent agent source reviews are separately attributed task comments"
}
pre-merge-v5.json

Original SHA256 7aac76636c4c3c49cdd30c92f3857dd81884ed8fdea3b81b53c5f464d54a8da8; display SHA256 7aac76636c4c3c49cdd30c92f3857dd81884ed8fdea3b81b53c5f464d54a8da8. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "event": "validate",
  "result": {
    "valid": true,
    "task_id": "issue-2850",
    "stage": null,
    "checkpoint": "pre-merge",
    "scope": "Local structure, recorded configuration and digest freshness only; verify authority, meaning and remote state separately."
  }
}
completion-validation-v5.json

Original SHA256 873bf858342521e1785bfe336a50421160b5176da0ffb223e188d5980ea990dd; display SHA256 873bf858342521e1785bfe336a50421160b5176da0ffb223e188d5980ea990dd. Absolute execution paths normalized only for publication; originals retained locally.

{
  "event": "validate",
  "result": {
    "valid": true,
    "task_id": "issue-2850",
    "stage": null,
    "checkpoint": "completion",
    "scope": "Local structure, recorded configuration and digest freshness only; verify authority, meaning and remote state separately."
  }
}

@hwanjjang hwanjjang mentioned this pull request Oct 22, 2026
Open
5 tasks
hwanjjang added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 22, 2026
@hwanjjang @claude
Port the factory prose reconstruction fixture from #2851 (#2849)
7eadefb 
runtime_services::inventory::factory_national_prose_reader_survives_factory_reconstruction
fails on the D2 head 307defe and passes on its merge base. Once the
owner hand-off fix let the domestic tests pass, CI on this stack
reached that test and failed there. The test file is taken unchanged
from 0c16391 (PR #2851, commits 24fb0fb and 0c16391; test only):
each reconstruction phase prepares its weather once and ends detached
owners and pools at its runtime boundary. Locally runtime_services
passes 48/48 on this branch with it.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@hwanjjang hwanjjang mentioned this pull request Oct 22, 2026
Open
@hwanjjang

hwanjjang commented Oct 22, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

AK extended the scope after the local/CI completion: measure and improve #2850 on a dedicated Seoul t3.small, following #2849's source-bound fixture comparison. AK approved the dedicated host/temporary SSH resources and instructed proceeding without repeat questions below a USD100 campaign ceiling. One host at a time, max2hours, CPU Unlimited, root<=32GiB; no production/IAM/live-S3/provider change or merge.

The original0c163912 local/CI readiness remains historical evidence. The extended target-host requirement is now in progress. A source-bound Linux example and base307defeb comparison binary are prepared; portable denominator/RSS/timeout checks and the loopback delay/concurrency check pass. A one-sample Linux pilot preserves all13Docs and the exact HTTP reference at0/10ms; it is explicitly insufficient for performance acceptance.

An owned t3.small is running with zero public egress, operator-onlySSH and host/operator termination guards. The original candidate's EC2 pilot at modeled0/10/20ms has started. Target latency, errors, CPU/RSS and control/raw/parse/fold counts will determine any runtime correction before20-sample comparisons, renewed independent review and CI. No target-host performance result is claimed yet.

hwanjjang added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 22, 2026
@hwanjjang @claude
Record the Seoul t3.small empty-cache matrix (#2849)
982055d 
On one Spot t3.small (2 vCPUs) with the loopback peer, no binary
answered an empty-cache request inside 3 s at 0, 10 or 20 ms. A
running server's views are ready after 4.6 / 5.3 / 6.4 s with the
candidate and 6.7 / 8.2 / 8.3 s with D2, whose owners stop at 8 s
with few views. The 0 ms floor is parse and fold CPU; a 24-permit
gate variant cut the 10/20 ms times to 4.8 / 5.3 s without lowering
it. Also documents the matrix tool's stricter problem rule
(CX-2852-001) and the test fixture ported from #2851 in the plan.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@hwanjjang
Reduce forecast catalog validation wait and add target measurements (#…
745352f 
…2850)

Keep identity validation within existing S3 admission using a rolling read window. Retain exact response and authority checks, add reproducible synthetic measurement controls to CI, and record Seoul t3.small results with failed and insufficient cohorts.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Reviewers

No reviews

Assignees

No one assigned

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Milestone

No milestone

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant

@hwanjjang