Skip to content

Native IRQ affinity is not restored after the first cycle in multi-state configurations #126

Description

@karuboniru

Without irqbalance , intel-lpmd uses its native IRQ migration path. With a configuration containing the following states:

State Active CPUs IRQMigrate
ECORE_ONE_MODULE 16-19 1
ECORE_TWO_MODULES 12-19 1
FULL_POWER 0-19 -2 (SETTING_RESTORE)

In a multi-state cycle, IRQ affinity is restored correctly only the first time.

During the first transition to a restricted state, the native implementation saves each IRQ's original smp_affinity while irq_updated is false. After updating the IRQs, it sets irq_updated to 1.

When entering FULL_POWER, IRQMigrate=-2 selects the native restore path. native_restore_irqs() restores the cached affinities and clears the cache with memset(), but it does not reset irq_updated to 0.

Consequently, during the next low-power cycle, irq_updated is still 1, so the original IRQ affinities are not cached again. The IRQs are restricted to the selected cluster, but the following FULL_POWER transition has an empty cache and therefore restores nothing. The state machine still applies the FULL_POWER CPU configuration after processing IRQs, because process_cgroup() is called after process_irq().

For example, after the second ECORE_TWO_MODULES -> FULL_POWER transition, the system can end up in the following inconsistent state:

CPU affinity: 0-19
IRQ affinity: 12-19

If the transition passes through ECORE_ONE_MODULE, IRQ affinity may remain restricted to 16-19 instead.

Expected behavior: every FULL_POWER transition with IRQMigrate=-2 restores the IRQ affinities that existed before the corresponding low-power cycle.

Actual behavior: only the first restore succeeds; subsequent restores leave IRQ affinity restricted to the last low-power cluster.


<?xml version="1.0"?>

<Configuration>
    <lp_mode_cpus></lp_mode_cpus>
    <lp_mode_epp>-1</lp_mode_epp>
    <Mode>1</Mode>
    <PerformanceDef>-1</PerformanceDef>
    <BalancedDef>0</BalancedDef>
    <PowersaverDef>1</PowersaverDef>
    <HfiLpmEnable>0</HfiLpmEnable>
    <WLTHintEnable>0</WLTHintEnable>
    <util_entry_threshold>10</util_entry_threshold>
    <util_exit_threshold>95</util_exit_threshold>
    <IgnoreITMT>1</IgnoreITMT>

      <States>
          <CPUFamily>6</CPUFamily>
          <CPUModel>186</CPUModel>
          <CPUConfig>*</CPUConfig>
          <State>
              <ID>1</ID>
              <Name>ECORE_ONE_MODULE</Name>
              <EntrySystemLoadThres>2</EntrySystemLoadThres>
              <EnterCPULoadThres>50</EnterCPULoadThres>

              <ActiveCPUs>16-19</ActiveCPUs>

              <EPP>-1</EPP>
              <EPB>-1</EPB>
              <ITMTState>-1</ITMTState>
              <IRQMigrate>1</IRQMigrate>

              <MinPollInterval>500</MinPollInterval>
              <PollIntervalIncrement>-1</PollIntervalIncrement>
              <MaxPollInterval>2000</MaxPollInterval>
          </State>
          <State>
              <ID>2</ID>
              <Name>ECORE_TWO_MODULES</Name>
              <EntrySystemLoadThres>10</EntrySystemLoadThres>
              <EnterCPULoadThres>95</EnterCPULoadThres>

              <ActiveCPUs>12-19</ActiveCPUs>

              <EPP>-1</EPP>
              <EPB>-1</EPB>
              <ITMTState>-1</ITMTState>
              <IRQMigrate>1</IRQMigrate>

              <MinPollInterval>500</MinPollInterval>
              <PollIntervalIncrement>-1</PollIntervalIncrement>
              <MaxPollInterval>2000</MaxPollInterval>
          </State>
          <State>
              <ID>3</ID>
              <Name>FULL_POWER</Name>

              <ActiveCPUs>0-19</ActiveCPUs>

              <EPP>-1</EPP>
              <EPB>-1</EPB>
              <ITMTState>-1</ITMTState>

              <IRQMigrate>-2</IRQMigrate>

              <MinPollInterval>500</MinPollInterval>
              <PollIntervalIncrement>-1</PollIntervalIncrement>
              <MaxPollInterval>2000</MaxPollInterval>
          </State>
      </States>

</Configuration>

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions