Skip to content

Simple Revolutionaries - #692

Open
Mehnix wants to merge 3 commits into
space-wizards:masterfrom
Mehnix:SimpleRevs
Open

Mehnix wants to merge 3 commits into
space-wizards:masterfrom
Mehnix:SimpleRevs

Conversation

@Mehnix

@Mehnix Mehnix commented Nov 12, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

I got asked to put my thoughts on the additions to revs i've been making into a Proposal. Here it is.

TL;DR, people have lots of opinions on reworking revs. They tend not to deliver on them because they're big reworks that are complicated. This is a small not-rework that adds things and is so a bit more feasible.

Relates to this PR currently:
space-wizards/space-station-14#46563

Revolutionary Shop prototype is also done but needs refining and specifying a market of items.

@github-actions github-actions Bot added Design Related to design documentation for Space Station 14. English labels Nov 12, 2026

@ketufaispikinut ketufaispikinut left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

this is really good.

- Xenoborgs are a splinter of a hyper-advanced machine-mind here to harvest the station of its power and sapient minds.

- Revolutionaries are...?
The most common theme seems to be they are the people's antagonist, unionists, proletariats, etc rising up against a tyrannical leadership using anything and everything they can find to bring down the man. Very much in the theme of the French and Communist revolutions.

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

proletarians or the proletariat, proletariats would be the plural of proletariat while unionists are the members / pro-union activists


The current concept draws heavily from modern communication methods like the Telegram App, obscure forums, or hidden messages in a newspaper. Effectively "Hiding in plain sight" using the establishments own communications systems against them with messages they can't see. But that the establishment can try to counteract through heavy handed suppression.

The "Undercommon" Radio Channel exists parallel to the Common channel, it consists of subliminal messages, static, and other nonsense background noise that those not tuned into the revolution will not notice. To the revolutionary, they can speak and pick it out as if it were second nature. As long as the Common Channel exists, revolutionaries can speak and hear Undercommon.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I want to reiterate hear what I really dislike about Undercommon:

  • It's counter to the pillar of an interconnectedness. It exists only for revs, to a degree that it's not accessible even when there are revs in the round.
  • It's counter to the pillar of intuitiveness. It's a unique mechanic that's not well signposted unless you're a rev. It's hard to know it even exists, adding a knowledge check to crew and command.
  • It's counter to the pillar of chaos. It's impossible for anyone to interact with it outside of revs, and explicitly regarded as a bad thing to be able to do so.
    • "Make sure to sprinkle plenty of opportunities for players to intentionally or unintentionally screw up while interacting with your mechanic."
  • It's counter to the pillar of player agency. The idea that Undercommon can be countered by turning off the comms server is binary and not open for choice. There's an obvious best thing to do once Revs are confirmed, which is designing for a meta.
    • "avoid creating situations where players are “Railroaded” into a specific action either mechanically or by the metagame. A player should never feel like they have no options in their situation."

@piskaczek

Copy link
Copy Markdown

this is really really good at making amazing points but it does not seem like the actual proposals target the points well.
undercommon seems underdeveloped as an idea.
if undercommon is always available for all revs you completely take out the organizational strategy aspect.
revs should supposedly start out as a weak few, get more materials as they organize together, and lastly become an unstoppable wave (assuming the winning case).
there should be pushback at each of those points.
at the start, there's an obvious "do not get found out try get a small group of people and get some more flashes and protection and simple weapons" then there's a "okay we cannot be hidden anymore we need to survive in this size and set up logistics" and then "hunt them down." undercommon eliminates the pushback throughout the 2nd stage and in the transition between the 1st and the 2nd.

you cannot solve this by removing the organization element. (as in, the strategy behind it.)
that is how you are supposed to have a person who can get you tools, who can get you weapons, flashes, implant removers, cuffs, healing...
any and all of the logistics.
you start with trash, grow with proper organization, and then set up any form of any logistics.

although i see the inspiration behind it, you cannot convert telegram group chats into a hidden comms channel.
a real revolution has thousands of people in tens possibly hundreds of group chats each group exchanging info of different caliber.
it has strength in the fact that it is massively decentralized.

we have about an hour and fifteen of like an average of 40 revs tops where things can completely change by the second.
give them an ability to spontaneously group but also to agree on the groups.
give them a middleguy.
the entire revolution falls immediately when two guys do, and that's fine when there's few, but that shouldn't be the case once there's 40 people converted.
give headrevs an action after they convert 5 people that lets them make a converted into some sort of middle role and basically all of the points mentioned in the overview go away (doesn't have to move across groups when they are assigned one. can keep less people focused on their specific goal easier. can command a smaller group to action easier. a plan is easier to figure out when you have any structure.)

this is basically what it's all about no? you have a lot of people, the difficulty lies in utilizing them.
make the attempt not get stuck immediately in building-any-structure-is-impossible hell before any delegation even happens.

also give the middleguys some alternate way to convert that's not viable by itself but that makes them unique enough to give them some claim to leadership, make it so that deconversion happens only once two of the headrev OR their middleguys die at the same time and you most likely fix:
no longer a single point of failure headrev (at any level. do not have to be the best leader ever to win as rev.)
communication is better. spreads more effectively. (or can do so)
less fragile: the above, middleguys can convert when they absolutely need to/when headrev absolutely cannot be there.

i really, really like the black market. it should be a very difficult decision to buy anything from it, and it should not be the main thing to rely on.

this and codeword revs are in their ideal form two sides of the same coin.
codeword has an absolute refusal of the necessity and centrality of headrevs.
simple gives headrevs constant flexibility and gives them more tools to sidestep that they are supposed to distribute.
you cannot give simple comms if you want to keep heads as the central focus.

also: this needs base roundmode sugar. what's the major / minor win / loss condition? what's still up for interpretation? how do you imagine roundflow would look within this? does deconversion still work the same way as current rev? you don't mention deconversion at all!

this highlights the pain points of revs better than codeword and most likely better than anything else ever. good work!

@riccardi48 riccardi48 left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I really like the Black Market proposal.


The Black Market basically acts as the way revs can tip the scales. If materials are in shortage, they can buy some from the black market. If they have a good base set up, they might want to buy a contraband ammo fabricator to resupply whatever weapons they've managed to scrounge up. This would also be where the thematic change to revs comes in. The Black Market is meant to be the primary vector by which the revolution receives supplies from their nebulous backers.

The revolution does not use spesos to purchase its goods, instead, it earns favour from their backers through conversion. This amount earned can vary depending on the converted. Converted Security officers or Command members can offer more earned favour, encouraging them not to be round removed due to the loss of bonus rewards.

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I think it would be much easier to implement if they just use money but are not able to add money to the revolution account normally. Then they receive money instead of favours, that way it can piggyback on top of all of the existing cargo stuff instead of needing to refactor bank accounts to allow for different currencies.

@Mehnix Mehnix Nov 13, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Allowing multiple different currencies and currency symbols is a very minimal C# change and a bit of yaml. It's something I've had experience doing before. My current prototype is very much already using the existing cargo accounts and markets system.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

Design Related to design documentation for Space Station 14. English

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

5 participants