Skip to content

docs(stage2): prospective closure evidence reconciliation - #98

Merged
Robinlee0929 merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
codex/stage2-closure-prospective-20261106
Nov 10, 2026
Merged

Robinlee0929 merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
codex/stage2-closure-prospective-20261106

Conversation

@Robinlee0929

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Purpose

Establish a prospective Stage 2 Closure evidence chain through this PR on 2026-11-09, without retroactively accepting the historical review gap. The frozen documentation candidate was prepared on 2026-11-08; its preparation-time status fields are retained. The local validation, independent review, commit and branch publication milestones below occurred afterward. Stage 2 is not formally closed.

Scope

Documentation-only reconciliation across exactly six files, including the bounded FIX-04 Candidate technical acceptance record:

  • README.md
  • docs/automation_readiness/actual_automation_integration_plan.md
  • docs/automation_readiness/stage2_formal_closure.md
  • docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_10_trusted_runtime_composition.md
  • docs/automation_readiness/stage2_vrrp_readonly_s2_ro_11_live_entrypoint.md
  • docs/portfolio/public_reviewer_walkthrough.md

The PR contains two commits and a three-dot diff of 203 insertions / 30 deletions:

  • c09e634100f7d87516838b573e0d29037e422fc7 — FIX-04 bounded Candidate technical acceptance.
  • 0f774c47b2529a5f93c0b0abd7c245b85e2d61d2 — prospective Stage 2 closure candidate.

Verified base: main@dbf18f7b17e3277a6c76d1773749190c55d30834.
Verified head: codex/stage2-closure-prospective-20261106@0f774c47b2529a5f93c0b0abd7c245b85e2d61d2.
Merge base: 399b810716f3187d4da4843cc2e2af736a974831; ahead 2 / behind 2.

No code, test or CI workflow changes are included. PR #97's existing Portfolio document and walkthrough link are not authorized for deletion. The endpoint-tree difference is not a replacement of main, and no merge or history rewrite is authorized by this PR.

Validation

These are completed local evidence for the frozen candidate, not GitHub Safe CI results:

  • Focused Stage 2: 523 PASS, exit code 0.
  • Complete Stage 2: 1,892 PASS, exit code 0.
  • Full pytest: 4,870 PASS, exit code 0.
  • Report-index: ACCEPTABLE WARN, exit code 0; 14 optional items, 1 PASS, 13 MISSING, 0 required failures, 0 unknown and 0 invalid statuses.
  • Independent pre-commit review: PASS, by a different Agent from the document author, with no unresolved material findings. This does not establish different-human or organizational independence.
  • Candidate six-file SHA-256 identities remained unchanged through validation, review, commit and publication checks.

No local tests were rerun during PR creation. GitHub Safe CI remains to be verified. A pull_request run may check out a synthetic merge commit: CI event, CI head SHA and actual checkout SHA must be recorded separately before claiming exact-head validation.

Historical Limitation

The original 2026-09-22 pre-commit independent review evidence remains NOT_ESTABLISHED. Historical PR #92 merged and declared closure; the recovered historical post-CI review is PASS_WITH_PROVENANCE_LIMITATION. Neither historical result fills the missing pre-commit provenance or validates this new candidate.

The different-Agent review above applies to this prospective candidate only; it is not a backdated historical PASS.

Safety Boundary

  • Stage 2 Formal Status = CLOSURE_CANDIDATE
  • FIX-04 Candidate = ACCEPTED_WITH_NOTES
  • Inactive Runtime Binding = NOT_ESTABLISHED
  • Deployment Acceptance = PENDING
  • No Live Authority
  • No Root Activation
  • No Approval Signing / Placement
  • No Stage 3 Authorization

All six FIX-04 Owner acceptance notes remain verbatim and unresolved. Startup Pins comparison does not prove current Runtime inactivity. Historical S2-RO-01 through S2-RO-11 and Lab1/Lab2 technical results retain their existing limits.

Remaining Gates

  1. New candidate Safe CI, satisfying the exact pushed-commit requirement in Closure Contract §13. A synthetic merge checkout must not be represented as exact-head CI.
  2. Post-CI independent closure review.
  3. Owner Formal Closure Decision.

PR creation grants no merge, auto-merge or manual workflow-dispatch authority.

@Robinlee0929
Robinlee0929 merged commit 18fd0d6 into main Nov 10, 2026
1 check passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant